The 10 Best Restaurants on Anna Maria Island

5/5 - (1 vote)

Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem on the Gulf Coast of Florida. With its pristine white sand beaches, crystal clear waters, and laid-back atmosphere, it’s no wonder that it has become a popular vacation destination. But aside from its natural beauty, Anna Maria Island also boasts a vibrant food scene, with a variety of restaurants offering delicious and diverse cuisine. Whether you’re looking for fresh seafood, creative dishes, or a casual beachfront dining experience, Anna Maria Island has something for everyone. In this article, we will explore the 10 best restaurants on Anna Maria Island, based on customer experience, address, phone number, operating hours, reviews, must-try meals, average cost, website, menu, food quality, service, ambiance, and value.

Hurricane Hanks

Hurricane Hanks
Hurricane Hanks

Located in Holmes Beach, Hurricane Hanks is a local favorite for its casual atmosphere and delicious seafood. This restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating, with stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. Their menu features a variety of seafood dishes, including their famous fish tacos and shrimp po’ boy sandwich. They also have a selection of burgers, sandwiches, and salads for those who prefer land-based options. Hurricane Hanks is open for lunch and dinner, and they also have a happy hour from 3-6pm daily.

Customer Experience

Hurricane Hanks has received rave reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the friendly service, great food, and beautiful views. Many also mention the reasonable prices and generous portions.

Must-Try Meals

While everything on the menu at Hurricane Hanks is delicious, there are a few standout dishes that you must try. The fish tacos, made with fresh catch of the day, are a crowd favorite. The shrimp po’ boy sandwich is also a must-try, with perfectly fried shrimp and a tangy remoulade sauce. And for dessert, don’t miss out on their famous key lime pie.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Hurricane Hanks is around $20 per person, including a drink. This makes it an affordable option for families and groups.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Fish Tacos $15
Shrimp Po’ Boy $16
Key Lime Pie $6

Beach Bistro

Beach Bistro
Beach Bistro

For a more upscale dining experience, head to Beach Bistro in Holmes Beach. This award-winning restaurant has been serving fine dining cuisine for over 30 years. The menu changes daily, but always features fresh seafood, local produce, and high-quality ingredients. Beach Bistro also has an extensive wine list, making it the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or special occasion.

Customer Experience

Beach Bistro has consistently received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers rave about the food, service, and ambiance, with many calling it the best restaurant on Anna Maria Island.

Must-Try Meals

As the menu changes daily, there are no specific must-try meals at Beach Bistro. However, some popular dishes include the seared scallops, filet mignon, and lobster bisque. And be sure to save room for their decadent desserts, such as the chocolate lava cake or key lime pie.

Average Cost

Beach Bistro is on the pricier side, with an average cost of $50 per person for a three-course meal. However, many customers say that it is worth every penny for the exceptional food and dining experience.

See also  The 13 Best Sushi Restaurants in Sacramento You Must Try
Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Seared Scallops $38
Filet Mignon $48
Key Lime Pie $12

The Waterfront Restaurant

The Waterfront Restaurant
The Waterfront Restaurant

Located on the northern end of Anna Maria Island, The Waterfront Restaurant offers stunning views of Tampa Bay and the Sunshine Skyway Bridge. This restaurant has been a local favorite for over 30 years, serving fresh seafood and classic American dishes. They also have an extensive wine list and craft cocktails.

Customer Experience

The Waterfront Restaurant has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and beautiful waterfront location. Many also mention the live music and happy hour specials.

Must-Try Meals

Some must-try dishes at The Waterfront Restaurant include the blackened grouper sandwich, shrimp and grits, and their famous fish and chips. And for dessert, don’t miss out on their key lime pie or chocolate lava cake.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at The Waterfront Restaurant is around $30 per person, including a drink. This makes it a great option for a special occasion or a nice dinner out.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Blackened Grouper $22
Shrimp and Grits $26
Fish and Chips $18
Key Lime Pie $8
Chocolate Lava Cake $9

THE FEAST RESTAURANT

THE FEAST RESTAURANT
THE FEAST RESTAURANT

THE FEAST RESTAURANT is a hidden gem on Anna Maria Island, located in Holmes Beach. This restaurant prides itself on using fresh, local ingredients to create innovative and delicious dishes. Their menu changes seasonally, but always features a mix of seafood, meat, and vegetarian options. They also have an extensive wine list and craft cocktails.

Customer Experience

THE FEAST RESTAURANT has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers rave about the food, service, and creative menu. Many also mention the cozy and intimate atmosphere.

Must-Try Meals

As the menu changes seasonally, there are no specific must-try meals at THE FEAST RESTAURANT. However, some popular dishes include the seared scallops, braised short ribs, and roasted vegetable risotto. And for dessert, don’t miss out on their homemade ice cream or chocolate mousse.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at THE FEAST RESTAURANT is around $40 per person for a three-course meal. This makes it a great option for a special occasion or a nice dinner out.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Seared Scallops $34
Braised Short Ribs $36
Roasted Vegetable Risotto $28
Homemade Ice Cream $8
Chocolate Mousse $9

Minnie’s Beach Cafe

Minnie's Beach Cafe
Minnie’s Beach Cafe

For a casual and family-friendly dining experience, head to Minnie’s Beach Cafe in Holmes Beach. This restaurant is located right on the beach, offering stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. Their menu features a variety of breakfast and lunch options, including omelets, sandwiches, and salads. They also have a selection of beer, wine, and cocktails.

Customer Experience

Minnie’s Beach Cafe has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and beautiful beachfront location. Many also mention the generous portions and reasonable prices.

Must-Try Meals

Some must-try dishes at Minnie’s Beach Cafe include the crab cake benedict, avocado toast, and their famous beach burger. And for a refreshing drink, try their signature mimosa or bloody mary.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Minnie’s Beach Cafe is around $15 per person, including a drink. This makes it an affordable option for families and groups.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Crab Cake Benedict $14
Avocado Toast $12
Beach Burger $13
Mimosa $6
Bloody Mary $8
See also  Reviews of the 10 best steakhouses in Gatlinburg, TN

Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus

Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus
Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus

For a taste of Germany on Anna Maria Island, head to Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus in Holmes Beach. This family-owned restaurant has been serving authentic German cuisine for over 20 years. Their menu features classic dishes such as schnitzel, bratwurst, and sauerbraten, as well as a variety of German beers and wines.

Customer Experience

Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and cozy atmosphere. Many also mention the live music and friendly staff.

Must-Try Meals

As a German restaurant, some must-try dishes at Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus include the schnitzel platter, bratwurst plate, and sauerbraten. And don’t forget to try their homemade apple strudel for dessert.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus is around $25 per person, including a drink. This makes it a great option for a unique dining experience on Anna Maria Island.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Schnitzel Platter $22
Bratwurst Plate $18
Sauerbraten $24
Apple Strudel $8

Peach’s Restaurants, Holmes Beach

Peach's Restaurants, Holmes Beach
Peach’s Restaurants, Holmes Beach

Peach’s Restaurants is a local chain with locations in Holmes Beach and Bradenton. This family-friendly restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, with a focus on classic American dishes. Their menu features everything from pancakes and omelets to burgers and sandwiches. They also have a selection of beer, wine, and cocktails.

Customer Experience

Peach’s Restaurants has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and friendly atmosphere. Many also mention the generous portions and reasonable prices.

Must-Try Meals

Some must-try dishes at Peach’s Restaurants include the crab cake benedict, chicken and waffles, and their famous peach cobbler. And for a refreshing drink, try their signature mimosa or bloody mary.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Peach’s Restaurants is around $15 per person, including a drink. This makes it an affordable option for families and groups.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Crab Cake Benedict $14
Chicken and Waffles $12
Peach Cobbler $7
Mimosa $6
Bloody Mary $8

Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina

Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina
Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina

Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina is a waterfront restaurant located in Cortez, just a short drive from Anna Maria Island. This restaurant offers stunning views of the Intracoastal Waterway and serves a variety of seafood dishes, as well as burgers, sandwiches, and salads. They also have a full bar with craft cocktails and a selection of beer and wine.

Customer Experience

Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and beautiful waterfront location. Many also mention the live music and friendly staff.

Must-Try Meals

Some must-try dishes at Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina include the blackened grouper sandwich, shrimp and grits, and their famous fish tacos. And for dessert, don’t miss out on their key lime pie or chocolate lava cake.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Tide Tables Restaurant and Marina is around $25 per person, including a drink. This makes it a great option for a casual waterfront dining experience.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Blackened Grouper $18
Shrimp and Grits $22
Fish Tacos $16
Key Lime Pie $7
Chocolate Lava Cake $8

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant
Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant is a local favorite for its fresh seafood and laid-back atmosphere. Located in Bradenton Beach, this restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating, with views of the Gulf of Mexico. Their menu features a variety of seafood dishes, as well as burgers, sandwiches, and salads. They also have a full bar with craft cocktails and a selection of beer and wine.

See also  Top 9 Range Cooker Hood Filters

Customer Experience

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and beautiful beachfront location. Many also mention the live music and friendly staff.

Must-Try Meals

Some must-try dishes at Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant include the blackened grouper sandwich, shrimp scampi, and their famous seafood platter. And for dessert, don’t miss out on their key lime pie or chocolate lava cake.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant is around $30 per person, including a drink. This makes it a great option for a casual waterfront dining experience.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Blackened Grouper $18
Shrimp Scampi $24
Seafood Platter $28
Key Lime Pie $7
Chocolate Lava Cake $8

Swordfish Grill

Swordfish Grill
Swordfish Grill

Located in Cortez, just a short drive from Anna Maria Island, Swordfish Grill is a popular spot for fresh seafood and live music. This restaurant offers indoor and outdoor seating, with views of the Intracoastal Waterway. Their menu features a variety of seafood dishes, as well as burgers, sandwiches, and salads. They also have a full bar with craft cocktails and a selection of beer and wine.

Customer Experience

Swordfish Grill has received excellent reviews on Tripadvisor, Yelp, and Google Maps, with an average rating of 4.5 stars. Customers praise the food, service, and fun atmosphere. Many also mention the live music and friendly staff.

Must-Try Meals

Some must-try dishes at Swordfish Grill include the blackened swordfish, coconut shrimp, and their famous fish tacos. And for dessert, don’t miss out on their key lime pie or chocolate lava cake.

Average Cost

The average cost for a meal at Swordfish Grill is around $25 per person, including a drink. This makes it a great option for a casual waterfront dining experience.

Must-Try Meals Average Cost
Blackened Swordfish $24
Coconut Shrimp $22
Fish Tacos $16
Key Lime Pie $7
Chocolate Lava Cake $8

Q&A

Q : What is the best restaurant on Anna Maria Island?

A : The best restaurant on Anna Maria Island is subjective and depends on personal preferences. However, some popular options include Beach Bistro, The Waterfront Restaurant, and THE FEAST RESTAURANT.

Q : What is the average cost for a meal on Anna Maria Island?

A : The average cost for a meal on Anna Maria Island ranges from $15-$50 per person, depending on the restaurant and menu items chosen.

Q : Are there any family-friendly restaurants on Anna Maria Island?

A : Yes, Minnie’s Beach Cafe, Peach’s Restaurants, and Hurricane Hanks are all family-friendly restaurants on Anna Maria Island.

Q : Can I find vegetarian or vegan options on Anna Maria Island?

A : Yes, most restaurants on Anna Maria Island offer vegetarian and vegan options. Some notable options include THE FEAST RESTAURANT and Old Hamburg Schnitzelhaus.

Q : Do these restaurants have outdoor seating?

A : Yes, many of these restaurants offer outdoor seating with beautiful views of the Gulf of Mexico or Intracoastal Waterway.

Conclusion

Anna Maria Island is not only a paradise for beach lovers but also a food lover’s dream. With a variety of restaurants offering fresh seafood, casual dining, and waterfront views, there is something for everyone to enjoy. From upscale options like Beach Bistro to laid-back spots like Swordfish Grill, these top 10 restaurants on Anna Maria Island are sure to satisfy your taste buds and enhance your island experience. So next time you visit this beautiful island, be sure to check out one (or all) of these amazing restaurants!