Reviews The 10 Best Restaurants in Baileys Harbor

5/5 - (1 vote)

Baileys Harbor, nestled on the picturesque shores of Lake Michigan in Door County, Wisconsin, is a charming destination that captivates visitors with its natural beauty and warm hospitality. Amidst this tranquil setting, food enthusiasts are treated to a delightful culinary experience. Here, we present a handpicked selection of the 10 best restaurants in Baileys Harbor, where impeccable flavors, exceptional service, and inviting atmospheres converge to create memorable dining moments.

Situated on the eastern shore of the enchanting Door County peninsula, just a short distance from the renowned Ashbrooke Hotel, lies the charming town of Baileys Harbor. With a population of 1,003 residents according to the 2000 census, this unincorporated community is also home to the census-designated place of Baileys Harbor. But beyond its tranquil ambiance and scenic landscapes, Baileys Harbor holds a delectable secret: its exceptional restaurants. Whether you’re in search of an elegant fine dining experience or a laid-back eatery, the restaurants in Baileys Harbor are sure to leave a lasting impression on your taste buds. Prepare to indulge in culinary delights as we explore the gastronomic wonders that await in this captivating town.

The 10 Best Restaurants in Baileys Harbor

Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub

Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub is a popular spot in close proximity to the Ridges Nature Center, making it a convenient choice for visitors looking to grab a bite after exploring the area. The establishment offers a bar area, a separate restaurant, and an outdoor patio, catering to different preferences. Upon entering, I noticed the vibrant artwork on the walls, some of which were available for purchase, adding a touch of character to the ambiance.

Although the establishment generally receives positive reviews for its food and staff, the service encountered during my visit was a mixed bag. Our server seemed a bit grumpy and failed to fulfill our requests promptly. However, the situation was mitigated by the assistance of other staff members who stepped in when needed. It’s evident that teamwork is valued here, which is commendable.

Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub

As for the menu, the pizza and chili are standout dishes according to the reviews I gathered. My wife and I followed the server’s recommendation and opted for the fish tacos, which unfortunately turned out to be a little dry for my liking. However, my wife enjoyed her portion, and my daughter was pleased with her mini-pizza. It’s worth noting that while Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub may not offer fine dining, it does provide a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for a casual meal and relaxation.

The prices at the establishment are considered reasonable, which is another positive aspect. Additionally, the back room is equipped with video gaming and displays racks of local area information, adding to the overall entertainment value. However, a common complaint among reviewers is the limited and outdated bathroom facilities, which could benefit from some improvements.

Overall, Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub seems to be a well-liked neighborhood establishment where regulars gather to enjoy good food and drinks. While the service during my visit had some hiccups, the friendly atmosphere and reasonable prices make it a recommendable choice for those seeking a laid-back dining experience.

Service options: Dine-in · Takeaway · No delivery
Address: 8123 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 11 AM Mon
Menu: baileysharborcornerstonepub.com
Phone: +1 920-839-9001

Harbor Fish Market & Grille

Harbor Fish Market & Grille in Bailey’s Harbor is a restaurant that comes highly recommended based on multiple positive reviews. Although reservations were not made, the reviewers were accommodated in the bar area at a “high top” table, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The meal itself was described as delicious, with exceptional service to match.

One reviewer highlights their experience with the Caesar salad, tailored to their preferences by omitting anchovies, while their spouse enjoyed a prime rib dish. Another reviewer raves about the grouper they had, showcasing the diverse menu options available at Harbor Fish Market & Grille. Based on these positive experiences, it is evident that the restaurant takes pride in serving quality meals.

The restaurant offers stunning views, both from the inside dining room and the outdoor seating area, creating a picturesque setting for lunch. The food received high praise from another reviewer who enjoyed the lobster bisque, while the walleye sandwiches were a hit with everyone in their group.

Harbor Fish Market & Grille

Miguel, a member of the restaurant’s staff, is commended for providing wonderful service, enhancing the overall dining experience for another group of customers. The shrimp with curry sauce received high praise, even from someone who doesn’t typically enjoy curry dishes. Such positive feedback suggests that the flavors and execution of the dishes at Harbor Fish Market & Grille are outstanding.

A family dinner on Memorial Day was a memorable occasion for another reviewer, who found the atmosphere relaxing after a busy day. The diverse menu options, including crab cakes, pheasant, shrimp, and blackened white fish, impressed the adults in the group, with each plate prepared to perfection. The children were also catered to with offerings such as chicken tenders and shrimp. The cocktails, particularly the recommended “Twisted 57,” were a topic of conversation throughout the meal. The service received high marks for being attentive, pleasant, and especially accommodating to the two grandchildren in the group.

Overall, Harbor Fish Market & Grille in Bailey’s Harbor proves to be a highly recommended dining establishment. With its delectable dishes, beautiful views, and attentive service, it offers an exceptional culinary experience. Whether you’re seeking a casual lunch or a memorable family dinner, this restaurant provides a delightful atmosphere to indulge in the flavors of the region.

Service options: Dine-in · Takeaway · No delivery
Address: 8080 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 9 AM Mon
Menu: harborfishmarket-grille.com
Reservations: harborfishmarket-grille.com, exploretock.com
Phone: +1 920-839-9999

Wally’s Weenie Wagon

Wally’s Weenie Wagon in Baileys Harbor is a hidden gem, serving up delicious hot dogs and other mouthwatering delights. According to several rave reviews, the portions are generous, making it an ideal choice for those looking to stock up on meals. One reviewer was thrilled with their purchase, mentioning that their crew would be eating for days after enjoying a feast from Wally’s Weenie Wagon.

The location itself adds to the charm, as you can sit and enjoy your food while taking in the beautiful waterfront view. The courtyard is described as magical, providing a picturesque setting to savor your meal. While many people were praising the Chicago dogs, the reviewers had their own agenda and were delighted by the variety of options available. It’s worth noting that the prices are reasonable considering the amount of food you receive, ensuring good value for your money.

See also  10 Best Steakhouses in Atlantic City - Must you try

Adjacent to Wally’s Weenie Wagon is the Corner Stone restaurant, where you can grab a drink from the bar and enjoy it by the wagon. This adds to the overall experience, allowing you to create your own ideal combination of food and beverages.

Wally's Weenie Wagon

The food itself receives high praise in the reviews. The Chicago hot dogs are said to be really good, with a satisfying snap and generous size. Gyros, fries, and brats are also highlighted as delicious options. One reviewer mentions the outstanding Banh Mi dog, a creative fusion of Vietnamese flavors and hot dog goodness, while their husband enjoyed the Wisconsin dog with fried cheese curds on top—a true indulgence.

The owners, Wally and Mrs. Wally, are commended for their dedication to crafting expertly made hot dogs and fries. The menu is described as fairly expansive, featuring a variety of high-quality dogs, fresh gyros, grilled kebabs, fried cheese curds, beer-battered onion rings, and hand-cut fries. The addition of a Greek salad with chickpeas, cucumber, tomato, and feta is also appreciated. The commitment to quality and creativity sets Wally’s Weenie Wagon apart as a next-level food truck.

One reviewer expresses their love for Wally’s Weenie Wagon by making regular 50-mile round trips from their home to indulge in the menu. The variety of options, vegetarian choices, and the possibility of gluten-free modifications make it a welcoming spot for various dietary preferences. The presence of a few umbrella tables adds to the convenience of enjoying your meal on-site.

In summary, Wally’s Weenie Wagon in Baileys Harbor is a must-visit for hot dog enthusiasts and food lovers alike. With its mouthwatering menu, waterfront location, and dedication to quality, it offers a unique and enjoyable dining experience. Whether you’re craving a classic Chicago dog, a creative fusion creation, or simply a delicious hot dog with fries, Wally’s Weenie Wagon delivers flavors that will leave you satisfied and craving more.

Service options: Takeaway · No delivery
Located in: Baileys Harbor Cornerstone Pub
Address: 8123 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 11 AM Mon
Phone: +1 920-493-3016

Chives Door Coupon

Chives Door County has received mixed reviews based on the feedback provided. While one review highlights a great dining experience with attentive service, another reviewer expresses disappointment with their recent visit.

The positive review describes a pleasant dining experience, praising the friendly and helpful staff, as well as the delicious food. The Chives Trio, consisting of lump crab cake, smoked salmon, and wontons, served as a delightful appetizer while enjoying a cocktail. The whitefish entree, accompanied by fingerling potatoes and French green beans, and the beef cheeks in red wine sauce with spaetzle were enjoyed as main courses. The wine selection was well-matched to their respective entrees. However, the reviewer notes that the portion of creme brulee for dessert was small. The total cost per person, including tax and tip, was $90.

Chives Door Coupon

On the other hand, the negative review details a disappointing experience. The reviewer arrived early for their reservation and were initially forgotten about while seated at the bar. After reminding the staff, they were eventually seated at a vacant table. However, the service continued to disappoint as there was a 30-minute wait between the salad and the main course. The rib eye steak ordered was overcooked, and although the beef cheeks were good, the reviewer opted to keep their meal rather than wait for the steak to be corrected. The service further faltered as the waiter did not return for another glass of wine, and the reviewer eventually decided to skip dessert.

Additionally, the negative review mentions an unpleasant encounter with a female hostess. The hostess allegedly lied about the availability of window seats, claiming they were reserved for a group of four. However, after a 45-minute wait, two other people arrived and were promptly seated at one of the window seats, which led the reviewer to suspect favoritism or bias on the hostess’s part. The reviewer concludes by expressing their disappointment with the hostess’s behavior and indicating that it was their last visit to Chives.

Overall, based on these contrasting reviews, it appears that Chives Door County has the potential to provide a great dining experience with attentive service and delicious food. However, inconsistencies in service and potential issues with staff professionalism and seating allocation may have contributed to less satisfactory experiences for some patrons.

Service options: Dine-in · Kerbside pickup · No delivery
Address: 8041 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4 PM Mon
Menu: chivesdoorcounty.com
Reservations: chivesdoorcounty.com, opentable.com
Order: toasttab.com
Phone: +1 920-839-2000

Morning Glory on Baileys

Morning Glory on Baileys is a welcoming and modern establishment that left a positive impression on its patrons based on the reviews. Upon arrival, guests were greeted warmly and impressed by the clean and contemporary atmosphere. Ordering was a breeze, with the staff readily available to answer any questions and provide helpful recommendations.

One notable aspect was the self-seating option, allowing guests to choose their preferred spot. As the food arrived, the Morning Glory omelets were served piping hot. The reviewer mentions ordering hash browns and American fries, ultimately finding the latter to be the preferred choice. The omelet itself received high praise, with the ingredients expertly cooked and blended together to create a harmonious and flavorful dish. The omelet’s proportions were also noted to be well-balanced, adding to the overall enjoyment.

Morning Glory on Baileys

Another highlight of Morning Glory on Baileys is its scenic location. Guests have the option to sit closer to the street, where they can relish a fantastic view of the water. This feature enhances the dining experience, allowing patrons to enjoy their meal alongside picturesque surroundings.

Overall, Morning Glory on Baileys appears to be a delightful breakfast spot, offering warm hospitality, a clean and modern ambiance, and deliciously prepared omelets. With attentive service, delectable food, and the added bonus of a beautiful view, this establishment is a worthy choice for a satisfying breakfast experience.

See also  Reviews of the 10 Best Coffee Shops in Kansas City

Service options: Dine-in · Takeaway · No delivery
Address: 8037 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 7 AM Mon
Order: toasttab.com

Coyote Roadhouse

Coyote Roadhouse in Baileys Harbor has garnered positive reviews from its patrons. The shrimp dinner and ribeye sandwich were enjoyed by one couple. The shrimp had a light breading and was flavorful, while the ribeye sandwich, though slightly undercooked, was still delicious and tender. The food arrived promptly after ordering, ensuring a satisfying dining experience. To enhance the celebration, the cherry margaritas were described as terrific, adding to the overall enjoyment of the anniversary.

Another reviewer mentioned visiting Coyote Roadhouse after a trip to Stones Throw winery. While the food was praised for its quality, the reviewer noted that the indoor seating area could get quite loud. However, the ambiance was enhanced by the enjoyable music from the 50s and 60s. The Reuben sandwich was specifically highlighted as excellent, showcasing the establishment’s ability to deliver delicious and satisfying meals.

Coyote Roadhouse

For another group of patrons, Coyote Roadhouse is a must-stop destination during their visits to Baileys Harbor. The lunch menu offered a variety of options, and the outdoor seating provided a pleasant environment. The inclusion of lawn activities for the grandchildren added to the overall appeal. The quesadillas, burgers, ribeye steak sandwich, and chicken tenders were all enjoyed, showcasing the range of tasty offerings available. After a morning of hiking at Cave Point, the relaxing lunch at Coyote Roadhouse provided a welcome respite.

Overall, Coyote Roadhouse offers a positive dining experience with its delicious food and pleasant ambiance. Whether you’re craving seafood, sandwiches, or other lunch options, the menu provides a satisfying selection. While the indoor seating may get loud, the enjoyable music adds a nostalgic touch to the atmosphere. With prompt service and outdoor seating options, it’s a great spot to unwind after exploring the area.

Service options: Dine-in · Kerbside pickup · No delivery
Address: 3026 County Rd E, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 11 AM Mon
Phone: +1 920-839-9192

Door County Brewing Co. Taproom, DCBC Eats & Music Hall

Door County Brewing Co has received a range of reviews, highlighting both positive and negative aspects of the establishment. While some reviewers expressed disappointment with the food quality and lack of meat in the nachos, others praised the brewery as a must-visit destination with great beers and a cozy atmosphere.

One negative review pointed out that the food was served cold and criticized the pork for being fatty and topped with unappetizing “mac n cheeze.” The reviewer also compared the pulled pork unfavorably to Wilson’s in Ephriam, Wisconsin. However, they acknowledged that the positive reviews they had seen might be due to the enjoyable atmosphere.

Door County Brewing Co. Taproom, DCBC Eats & Music Hall

Conversely, another reviewer described Door County Brewing Co as a must-stop destination, praising the great beers and highlighting the on-tap root beer that their children loved. They highly recommended trying the pretzel and mentioned the availability of fun games both inside and outside the brewery. This reviewer also mentioned that they enjoyed visiting the brewery for date nights, with friends, and as a family outing.

A positive review highlighted the enjoyable experience during a first visit to Door County Brewing Co. The reviewer mentioned that all four beers they tried were delicious. They appreciated the cozy atmosphere and the friendly and helpful staff. They expressed a desire to return to the brewery in the future and mentioned the possibility of enjoying the outdoor space during the summer months.

Overall, while there may be mixed opinions about the food quality at Door County Brewing Co, the positive aspects of the brewery, such as the great beers, cozy atmosphere, and friendly staff, are consistently mentioned. Visitors can expect a range of delicious beers to choose from and the opportunity to enjoy a pleasant and inviting space. The brewery also offers entertainment options, both indoors and outdoors, making it a versatile and enjoyable destination for different occasions.

Service options: Dine-in · Takeaway · No delivery
Address: 8099 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours:Closed ⋅ Opens 11 AM Mon
Menu: dcbceats.com
Phone: +1 920-239-8181

PC Junction

PC Junction is a family-friendly establishment located in a remote area near Bailey’s Harbor in beautiful Door County. The restaurant offers a unique experience centered around trains, making it a popular destination for families with young children. The outdoor area provides ample entertainment options, including slides, bikes, and basketball, creating a fun-filled environment for both kids and adults.

One reviewer mentioned the reduced hours due to staffing issues but emphasized the importance of prioritizing a visit to PC Junction, especially with children aged 2 to 10. The staff received praise for their great service on weekends, and the reviewer highlighted the entertaining outdoor area that helps pass the time while waiting for a table. Despite having only six tables that receive train delivery, the reviewer considered it well worth the wait and expressed a desire to return with their children as they grow older.

PC Junction

Another reviewer visited PC Junction due to their partner’s love for trains. They were informed of a wait time of one to one and a half hours, which they were fine with. During the wait, they explored the grounds and found the facilities to be ideal for elementary-aged children, featuring slides, bikes, and basketball activities. Their wait ended up being shorter than anticipated, and they were seated in a room with large windows, allowing them to enjoy the pleasant weather and breeze. It’s important to note that train delivery of food is specific to certain rooms, and since they were not seated in one of those rooms, they only caught a glimpse of the train as they were paying, which left them somewhat disappointed. The food received positive feedback in terms of taste and price, although the staff’s friendliness and knowledgeability were perceived as lacking. Despite these shortcomings, they would recommend PC Junction primarily to families with energetic kids who don’t mind waiting or need an outlet for their energy.

See also  The 20 Best Hotels in Panama City Beach

While PC Junction has its charms, another reviewer highlighted the challenges of understaffing, which is a prevalent issue in many establishments. The popularity of the outdoor area, enjoyable for both kids and adults, contributes to the restaurant’s summer rush. The food is regarded as pretty good, and their excellent ice cream is worth mentioning. However, the reviewer experienced longer wait times due to understaffing, particularly on the first day of favorable weather in the region. Despite the delays, they still considered PC Junction worth a visit.

In summary, PC Junction offers a unique dining experience focused on trains, making it a favored spot for families with young children. The outdoor area provides ample entertainment, while the food is generally regarded as good, with excellent ice cream options. However, staffing issues can lead to longer wait times and occasional challenges with service. Nonetheless, for families seeking a fun and interactive dining experience, PC Junction remains a popular choice in Door County.

Service options: Dine-in · Kerbside pickup · No delivery
Address: 7898 Co Rd A, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 10 AM Mon
Menu: pcjunctiondoorcounty.com
Phone: +1 920-839-2048

Blue Ox

Blue Ox, located in Pai, has received mixed reviews regarding its dining experience. One reviewer expressed extreme disappointment with the steak, describing it as filled with gristle and fat, not up to export quality, and improperly cooked. This reviewer had a poor experience and advised against wasting money on the poor quality of meat served at the establishment.

However, another reviewer, who stayed at the hotel where the restaurant is located, enjoyed their chargrilled New Zealand steak. They appreciated the full-bodied chargrill flavor and found the 250g steak to be lovely. While the buffalo wings were not as spicy as expected, they enjoyed the comfortable seating arrangement, which surpassed some other establishments along the street.

On the other hand, one reviewer had mixed feelings about their dining experience at Blue Ox. They enjoyed the fried softshell crab but found the deep-fried whole fish to be very dry. They were also disappointed by the loud live music, which they felt was not suitable for a restaurant. However, they had a pleasant interaction with an attentive waiter and enjoyed their sparkling wine.

Blue Ox

Despite mixed reviews, Blue Ox is regarded as the top trendy restaurant in Pai, with sightings of Thai celebrities adding to its allure. The setting is beautiful, with various seating options such as tables near the street, indoors with interesting decor, or in a fabulous garden at the back. The staff is described as friendly and pleasant, providing good service. Among the dishes ordered, the pasta carbonara was praised as very good, the vegetable spring rolls were tasty but not served hot, and the New Zealand rib-eye steak was of high quality and nicely cooked at a reasonable price. The reviewer found the ribs tender, although they did not particularly enjoy the barbeque sauce used. Overall, the prices were considered reasonable for the quality of food and level of service provided.

In summary, the reviews for Blue Ox in Pai vary. While one reviewer had a highly negative experience with the steak, others enjoyed their meals, albeit not considering them exceptional. The ambiance and setting of the restaurant receive positive remarks, with seating options to suit different preferences. Prices are generally regarded as reasonable, and the level of service is described as friendly and attentive. For those considering dining at Blue Ox, it may be advisable to manage expectations and choose dishes based on the positive recommendations given.

Service options: Dine-in · Takeaway · No delivery
Address: 8051 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Open ⋅ Closes 2 AM
Menu: theblueoxbar.com
Phone: +1 920-839-2771

Florian II Supper Club

Florian II Supper Club has received mixed reviews from its patrons. One reviewer expressed deep disappointment, stating that the restaurant did not live up to its claim of being a supper club and instead felt like a local family restaurant. They mentioned that the fish they ordered was served cold, and they were surprised by an added service charge on their bill. They felt it was a typical tourist trap and gave low ratings for the food, ambiance, service, and supper club experience. As a result, they do not plan to return or recommend the establishment.

In contrast, another reviewer had a positive experience at Florian II Supper Club. They gave a rating of 5 out of 5, mentioning that they couldn’t find anything to complain about. Although they acknowledged that it was not as great as their favorite supper club back home, they found no faults with the restaurant. They praised the facility, highlighting the awesome bar and live entertainment. The service provided by Mehmet was excellent, and they were particularly pleased with their perfectly cooked 8 oz tenderloin steaks, which were juicy, tender, and free of fat or gristle. The reviewer also enjoyed the fresh salad, homemade mini loaf of bread, and a well-prepared Brandy Old Fashioned. They appreciated the seating in the atrium with a view overlooking the harbor.

Florian II Supper Club

However, another reviewer had a less favorable experience at Florian II Supper Club. While they enjoyed the 60s/70s lounge vibe, live music, and scenic lake view, they found the food to be lackluster. The steak and hash browns lacked flavor and were not properly seasoned. They also mentioned that certain elements typically associated with a supper club experience were missing, such as a pre-dinner relish tray. They expressed disappointment with their dining experience, despite enjoying a good Old Fashioned.

In summary, Florian II Supper Club has received a mix of reviews. While one reviewer was greatly disappointed with their experience, another had a positive dining experience, appreciating the service, well-cooked steaks, and overall atmosphere. However, a third reviewer found the food lacking in flavor and missed some traditional supper club elements. As with any restaurant, experiences may vary, and it’s important to consider individual preferences and expectations when deciding to dine at Florian II Supper Club.

Service options: Dine-in · Takeaway · No delivery
Address: 8048 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4:30 PM Wed
Phone: +1 920-839-2361

Leave a Reply