Reviews of the 10 Best Steakhouses in Pittsburgh

5/5 - (1 vote)
Welcome to the ultimate guide featuring comprehensive reviews of the top ten contenders vying for the title of the “10 best steakhouses in Pittsburgh.” Delving deep into the heart of this vibrant culinary scene, we’ve meticulously curated an assortment of Steakhouse experiences, each promising a symphony of flavors and an unparalleled dining journey. From sizzling prime cuts to masterfully crafted dishes, embark with us on a gastronomic exploration through Pittsburgh’s finest establishments, poised to tantalize even the most discerning palates.

Reviews of the 10 Best Steakhouses in Pittsburgh

1. Eddie Merlot’s 

Eddie Merlot’s in Pittsburgh stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, consistently delivering exceptional dining experiences that linger in memory long after the last bite. Nestled in the bottom floor of an office building downtown, this steakhouse magnetizes patrons seeking refined gastronomy and attentive service. A cacophony of praises echoes the sentiment of unparalleled quality found within its walls. From the onset, the impeccable service sets the tone, neither rushed nor neglected, achieving a harmonious balance. Derek, Armindo, Henry, and Bill are hailed as paragons of hospitality, elevating the dining experience with their attentiveness and expertise.
Eddie Merlot's - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Eddie Merlot’s – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
The culinary journey commences with libations – martinis poured to perfection and an extensive wine list offering gems like the Duckhorn Merlot. The appetizers set a tantalizing precedent; the Caesar salad, embellished with anchovies, and the French onion soup earn acclaim as some of the finest renditions tasted by patrons. Steak aficionados revel in the glory of flawlessly cooked filet mignons, while seafood enthusiasts relish in the delightful flavors of lobster tails. Complementing these savory delights are the Eddies Brussels sprouts and bacon, an ode to culinary excellence.
The expertise of the staff extends beyond meal pairings, culminating in desserts that dazzle the senses. The tableside preparation of the triple chocolate cake leaves an indelible mark, described as nothing short of fantastic. Even the carrot cake, decadent and generously portioned, receives high commendations, proving a sweet ending to an already extraordinary feast.
While the ambiance lacked an open outdoor patio during some visits, the bar area offers its own allure. Patrons rave about the bartender’s prowess in concocting delightful libations and providing stellar recommendations. The shrimp fajita salad and the blue cheese sirloin sandwich with truffle fries exemplify the diverse and delectable offerings available. Warm, seasoned bread sets the stage, adding a comforting touch to the overall experience.
Noteworthy is the anticipation for the 3-course lunch special, a testament to the restaurant’s promise of an enticing and diverse menu that beckons return visits. The consensus stands firm: Eddie Merlot’s is more than a mere restaurant; it is an institution of culinary mastery in Pittsburgh, beckoning food enthusiasts to revel in its sumptuous offerings and unparalleled hospitality. Whether celebrating milestones or simply indulging in a gastronomic delight, Eddie Merlot’s remains a definitive destination for an extraordinary dining experience.
Located in: Four Gateway Center
Address: 444 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States
Phone: +1 412-235-7676

2. Ruth’s Chris Steak House 

Ruth’s Chris Steak House in Pittsburgh embodies an enduring legacy of culinary excellence, making it a paramount destination for those seeking an elevated dining experience. Situated next to PPG Plaza, the ambiance is not just inviting but exudes a relaxed sophistication, perfect for special occasions or casual gatherings alike.
The consensus among patrons praises the consistent quality of food, delivered on sizzling hot plates that intensify the flavors of perfectly cooked steaks and fish. The garlic mashed potatoes stand out as a culinary triumph, while opinions vary on the creamed spinach, albeit the unanimous declaration of the best Caesar Salad, second only to a legendary rendition at Chart House in the US Virgin Islands. Dessert, notably the chocolate cake, is hailed as an indulgence worth savoring, even if it means saving half for a morning coffee pairing.
Ruth's Chris Steak House - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Ruth’s Chris Steak House – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Large groups find solace in the accommodating patio space, a serene setting against the backdrop of a balmy evening at PPG Plaza. Ruth’s Chris maintains its reputation for delivering impeccable food, reassuringly consistent and served with warmth. The staff’s kindness and amiability amplify the dining experience, adding a personal touch that resonates with patrons, ensuring a desire for return visits.
The menu’s array of starters, featuring fresh oysters, and crab cakes, evoke admiration for their tantalizing flavors and high-quality ingredients. The wedge salads, pleasantly surprising in their size, serve as a delightful prelude to the main course. The surf and turf, an 11 oz filet paired with two 5 oz tails, earn commendation for their faultless preparation, complemented by a choice Bordeaux wine that heightens the entire dining experience.
For Pittsburgh visitors during Steelers Weekend or locals seeking a reliable dining destination, Ruth’s Chris emerges as a steadfast recommendation. Patrons advise securing reservations well in advance to ensure an ideal dinner time, attesting to the restaurant’s popularity and consistent ability to leave diners thoroughly satisfied, often with enough for leftovers, a testament to both the generous portions and the restaurant’s unwavering commitment to culinary excellence.
Address: Six PPG Place, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States
Phone: +1 412-391-4800

3. Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in Pittsburgh stands as a beacon of excellence, offering an unparalleled dining experience that resonates with its patrons long after their visit. Renowned for its impeccable service, exquisite food offerings, and captivating ambiance, this restaurant has garnered an ensemble of accolades from connoisseurs of fine dining.
Diners are unequivocal in their praise, hailing Hyde Park as a standout among high-end steakhouses, with one visitor deeming it their best restaurant experience in over a year. The consensus highlights the harmonious blend of exceptional service, delectable cuisine, and an inviting atmosphere—all offered at a commendable value, ensuring a promise of return visits.
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
The menu, adorned with culinary delights, boasts signature dishes that captivate palates and become must-have indulgences for regulars. The thick cut bacon in cider glaze emerges as a perennial favorite appetizer, consistently wowing diners with its flavors. The filets, adorned with a variety of delectable glazes and accouterments, receive accolades for their impeccable preparation, meeting and exceeding expectations every time.
Service at Hyde Park is more than just efficient; it’s a testament to personalized attention. Logan, Jaime, and Ashley, among others, are celebrated for their warmth, efficiency, and engaging personalities, enhancing the dining experience with their attentiveness and charm. The management’s commitment to guest satisfaction shines through their regular table visits, adding a touch of hospitality that doesn’t go unnoticed.
The ambience itself becomes an integral part of the experience, with the interior exuding sophistication through soft lighting, charming red accents, and tasteful decor. Diners revel in the elegant setting, enhancing the pleasure of savoring their carefully crafted meals.
Specialty dishes like the Japanese Wagyu steak, likened to “butter” for its melt-in-your-mouth tenderness, leave an indelible mark on taste buds. Accompaniments like candied bacon bit Brussels sprouts and Mac & Cheese elevate the dining affair to an exquisite culinary journey, earning it accolades as the “best meal” in recent memory.
While the restaurant’s excellence is undisputed, some patrons express a desire for expanded hours, especially on game days, to accommodate early diners—a testament to the restaurant’s popularity among sports enthusiasts seeking a pre-game indulgence.
In conclusion, Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse in Pittsburgh isn’t just a dining venue; it’s an epitome of upscale gastronomy, where meticulous attention to detail, exemplary service, and culinary mastery converge, ensuring an unforgettable experience that beckons patrons back time and again. For those seeking a symphony of flavors and an ambiance of refined elegance, Hyde Park remains a pinnacle of dining excellence, earning its place as a true culinary gem in the city’s dining landscape.
Address: 247 N Shore Dr, Pittsburgh, PA 15212, United States
Phone: +1 412-222-4014

4. The Capital Grille 

The Capital Grille in Pittsburgh effortlessly embodies the pinnacle of culinary finesse, seamlessly merging delectable cuisine with impeccable service and an inviting ambiance. Renowned for its consistency in delivering a top-tier dining experience, this establishment exudes sophistication while maintaining an air of approachability.
Patrons laud the restaurant’s elegant decor, setting the stage for a memorable dining affair. The prosciutto-wrapped mozzarella appetizer garners high acclaim, hailed as one of the finest starters patrons have ever indulged in. Main courses, including the sliced filet and sea bass, are prepared to perfection, reflecting a dedication to culinary excellence that resonates through each savory bite.
However, beyond the exceptional fare, it is the service that elevates the evening to extraordinary heights. Darla, Horacio, and the staff stand out for their consummate professionalism, their knowledge, and their ability to curate a seamless dining experience, leaving an indelible mark on patrons’ hearts.
The Capital Grille - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
The Capital Grille – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
For first-time visitors, the Capital Grille surpasses expectations, providing a first-class experience marked by well-crafted cocktails, generous pours, and memorable culinary creations. The ambiance exudes an attractive allure, striking a perfect balance between bustling energy and a comfortable atmosphere, ensuring that diners feel both welcomed and relaxed throughout their visit.
Even without reservations, the staff’s dedication to accommodating guests shines through, ensuring an exceptional dining experience. Steak enthusiasts are delighted by the amazing quality and taste of the cuts, while those opting for lobster and steak combinations find themselves enamored by the flawlessly executed dishes. The consistent high quality of the meat, combined with impeccable service, makes for an evening that exceeds expectations.
Moreover, a heartwarming incident involving the compassionate owner stands as a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to hospitality. His kindness and thoughtfulness toward a distressed young guest, going above and beyond to comfort her after an accidental spill, demonstrate an exceptional level of care that transcends the culinary experience. This personal touch leaves a lasting impression, echoing the ethos of warmth and genuine hospitality that defines The Capital Grille.
Even during breakfast service, this establishment shines. A visit en route to Kennywood turned into an unforgettable experience, with a delightful Nutella and bananas pancakes special stealing the spotlight. The exceptional quality of the meal combined with the kindness extended to their granddaughter cements this restaurant as a must-return destination for those in the area.
In sum, The Capital Grille in Pittsburgh isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an epitome of culinary excellence coupled with heartfelt hospitality. With its outstanding cuisine, welcoming ambiance, and a team dedicated to ensuring an unparalleled dining journey, it stands as a beacon of refined dining, inviting patrons to indulge in a symphony of flavors and genuine care.
Located in: Piatt Place Downtown
Address: 301 Fifth Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States
Phone: +1 412-338-9100

5. Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse 

Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse in Pittsburgh reigns as an indulgent culinary haven, enchanting patrons with an exquisite blend of tantalizing flavors, attentive service, and an inviting ambiance that beckons diners into a world of gastronomic delight.
Nestled within the renovated Saks Fifth Avenue, this establishment stands out as a treat for the senses. The dining experience is characterized by a collaborative effort among waitstaff, ensuring seamless service. The Market Table, a treasure trove of about 60 delectable dishes, captivates guests with its freshness, variety, and enticing flavors.
From Brazilian sausages at the omelet bar to savory sides like mashed potatoes with a hint of garlic, cornbread, and bananas in a subtly sweet sauce, each offering contributes to a symphony of tastes that thrill the palate.
Celebratory occasions find a perfect home here, as families gather to revel in the graduation of a high school senior. Even for vegetarians, the culinary journey at Fogo de Chão is exceptional, with options like the delightful cauliflower steak leaving a lasting impression. The consensus echoes the outstanding quality of the meats and sides, accompanied by a favorable pricing that adds value to the overall dining experience.
Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
The sophisticated setting harmonizes with the excellence in food and service, creating an ideal environment for a memorable brunch or celebratory dinner. The variety at the Market Table Buffet continues to impress, offering a diverse range of dishes that delight the taste buds. The collaborative effort of the waitstaff ensures a continual stream of attention, adding to the overall pleasure of the dining experience.
For those new to Brazilian steakhouses, Fogo de Chão emerges as a revelation, leaving a profound impression with its exceptional food and inviting ambiance. Patrons are enamored by dishes like the lamb, coupled with the expansive salad bar featuring a range of hot and cold selections. The welcoming atmosphere, coupled with an attentive and accommodating staff, fosters an atmosphere conducive to celebration and relaxation.
Moreover, the delightfully crafted cocktails, like the caramelized pineapple Old Fashioned, complement the meal experience, offering a sensory journey that encompasses both taste and ambiance.
In conclusion, Fogo de Chão Brazilian Steakhouse in Pittsburgh is a testament to culinary mastery, providing a tapestry of flavors that cater to diverse palates. With its captivating dishes, attentive service, and inviting atmosphere, this establishment ensures an unforgettable dining “experience,” beckoning patrons to return for another captivating journey through its offerings.
Address: 525 Smithfield St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States
Phone: +1 412-312-5001

6. Texas de Brazil 

Texas de Brazil in Pittsburgh stands as a carnivorous paradise, beckoning meat enthusiasts to embark on a gastronomic journey marked by impeccable service, an expansive buffet, and succulent cuts of meat.
For those uninitiated to this style of dining, the concept is simple—$50 grants access to an all-you-can-eat extravaganza featuring an array of salads, soups, rice, and various delectable items in the primary buffet, while perfectly cooked meats are brought to your table. The “green for more, red to stop” coaster signals the arrival of more meats, cooked to perfection and served rare, providing a delightful feast for voracious diners. The exceptional customer service coupled with the vibrant night scene adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the dining experience.
Texas de Brazil - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Texas de Brazil – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
First-timers find themselves in awe of the phenomenal culinary adventure that awaits. Despite the price tag, patrons unanimously agree that the experience is undeniably worth it. Reservations are highly recommended due to the restaurant’s popularity; those without reservations faced a substantial wait, highlighting the importance of planning ahead to ensure a timely and enjoyable dining experience.
The bustling Saturday evening didn’t deter the seamless service; instead, it added to the charm of the ambiance. Kizzy and other staff members shine with their exceptional service, ensuring a flawless experience from beginning to end. The salad bar, far from the conventional notion, offers an upscale selection that complements the main attraction—the succulent, sizzling meats delivered piping hot and carved tableside, a spectacle that amplifies the dining experience.
While acknowledging the cost, patrons unanimously agree that the value delivered surpasses expectations. The outstanding quality of the food and the attentive service contribute to an unforgettable dining affair. The servers, with their personable and helpful demeanor, enhance the overall atmosphere, creating a welcoming environment for diners to relish their feast.
In conclusion, Texas de Brazil in Pittsburgh stands tall as an epitome of indulgence, where the extravagance of an all-you-can-eat buffet meets the excellence of perfectly prepared meats. Despite the price point, the quality, variety, and impeccable service ensure an exceptional dining experience that beckons patrons to return, eagerly anticipating their next feast in this carnivorous paradise.
Located in: Station Square
Address: 240 W Station Square Dr ste d-1, Pittsburgh, PA 15219, United States
Phone: +1 412-230-3816

7. Gaucho Parrilla Argentina 

Gaucho Parrilla Argentina in Pittsburgh stands as a culinary gem, drawing patrons with its exceptional flavors, attentive service, and an inviting atmosphere that transports diners to the heart of Argentina’s vibrant gastronomy.
Located conveniently close to the Pirates’ ballpark, this restaurant delivers an outstanding dining experience that mirrors the authenticity of Argentine cuisine. The star attraction, meats, doesn’t disappoint and could easily rival the best in Buenos Aires. Accompanying this delightful fare are great wines, enhancing the overall dining affair and earning it a resounding recommendation from patrons.
Gaucho Parrilla Argentina - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Gaucho Parrilla Argentina – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Attentive and knowledgeable service takes center stage, complementing the culinary delights. Diners revel in an array of impeccably prepared dishes, from succulent steaks to exquisite fish options, each leaving an indelible mark on the taste buds. The overall dining experience is characterized by a seamless blend of engagement without intrusion, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to impeccable service.
With a nod to Argentina’s culinary heritage, a table of six friends indulges in a feast reminiscent of the flavors of Argentina itself. The appetizers, featuring empanadas, chorizo, and provoletta, pave the way for the grandeur of the massive paella, accentuated by the perfect pairing of Argentinian Malbec and Sauvignon Blanc. The dining journey culminates in the indulgence of flan and chocolate dolce de leche, exemplifying the richness and authenticity of Argentine desserts. Under new management, the service elevates the overall dining experience, with servers like Dan embodying professionalism, friendliness, and a knack for excellent recommendations.
While previously situated in another location, the downtown setting in the theater district adds to the allure of a memorable night out. Amid seating restrictions due to Covid protocols, patrons are advised to secure reservations well in advance to savor this culinary delight.
In sum, Gaucho Parrilla Argentina is more than a restaurant; it’s an immersive experience into the heart of Argentine flavors and hospitality. Whether relishing the homemade sauces that enhance each dish or reveling in the inviting atmosphere, patrons unanimously agree that this establishment, with its high-quality food and delightful ambiance, remains an enduring favorite among diverse palates.
Address: 146 6th St, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States
Phone: +1 412-709-6622

8. Eddie V’s Prime Seafood 

Eddie V’s Prime Seafood in Pittsburgh stands as a beacon of exceptional dining, where impeccable service, delectable cuisine, and an inviting ambiance converge to offer patrons an unforgettable gastronomic experience.
Amid a bustling Monday evening, the restaurant exudes a vibrant yet intimate atmosphere, maintaining its allure even during peak hours. Jesse, among other adept servers, shines with suggestions and unwavering attentiveness, contributing to a seamless dining journey. The seafood dishes, meticulously prepared and generously portioned, stand as a testament to the kitchen’s dedication to culinary excellence.
Eddie V's Prime Seafood in Pittsburgh - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Eddie V’s Prime Seafood in Pittsburgh – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
For those familiar with Eddie V’s chain, the establishment consistently upholds high standards, surpassing expectations in different locations. This commitment to quality and service earns the restaurant the loyalty of patrons, ensuring a continued preference for Eddie V’s wherever available.
First-time diners are greeted with an experience that surpasses all previous culinary endeavors. Jeremy and the attentive staff orchestrate an exceptional dining affair, guiding patrons through a gastronomic journey from appetizers to desserts. The extensive wine selection adds an extra layer of sophistication, complementing the phenomenal dishes.
The ambiance, crafted with discreet compartments despite the restaurant’s size, creates an intimate dining experience. Patrons relish the filet mignon, hailed as one of the finest ever tasted. This, coupled with the perfect friendly service, elevates the evening to an unparalleled dining escapade.
Celebrating a 35th wedding anniversary becomes a truly memorable occasion at Eddie V’s. The staff’s attentive and knowledgeable approach ensures every guest feels like a VIP. The seafood, notably the sea bass, and the steak tartare, emerge as standout dishes, encapsulating the epitome of culinary excellence. The restaurant’s ability to make every patron feel special further enhances the celebratory atmosphere, adding a personalized touch to each dining experience.
In essence, Eddie V’s Prime Seafood is not just a restaurant; it’s an institution of fine dining that transcends expectations. With its exceptional service, outstanding cuisine, and an atmosphere that exudes warmth and elegance, Eddie V’s beckons patrons in search of a special meal to indulge in an unparalleled culinary journey.
Located in: Union Trust Building
Address: 501 Grant St # 100, Pittsburgh, PA 15219, United States
Phone: +1 412-391-1714

9. Meat & Potatoes 

Meat & Potatoes in Pittsburgh presents an exquisite dining experience, weaving together sumptuous flavors, attentive service, and a cozy atmosphere that beckons patrons to indulge in a memorable culinary journey.
For carnivorous couples seeking the ultimate indulgence, the porterhouse steals the spotlight, delivering perfection in every bite and leaving a delightful sensation that led to a leisurely stroll through the charming neighborhood, enhanced by a serene snowfall. The drinks, from generously poured G&Ts to excellent wine pairings, complemented the meal impeccably. Service resonated with warmth, friendliness, and helpfulness, contributing to an overall exceptional dining experience that warranted a gratuity beyond the standard 20%.
Meat & Potatoes - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Meat & Potatoes – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Upon arriving promptly for a reservation, diners are embraced by the restaurant’s comfortable ambiance, characterized by mirrored walls, high ceilings, and an intimate setting that fosters easy conversation despite tables being fairly close together. The recommendations from the waitress are spot-on, guiding patrons toward culinary delights like fried brussel sprouts, bacon-wrapped dates, flat iron steak, and pork dishes, each leaving an indelible mark of satisfaction. The regret of not discovering this culinary haven sooner lingers, as the experience surpassed expectations, leaving a yearning for more.
The flexibility of seating at the bar offers a comfortable dining alternative for those without reservations. The pork chop, a generous and flavorful portion, becomes a highlight of the evening, impressing with its taste and impeccable cooking. The sizable portion even allows for a delightful lunch the next day, a testament to both quality and quantity.
Exploring the menu’s classics, like the meatloaf with mashed potatoes, unveils a culinary delight that stands out among previous visits. The high-quality beef in the meatloaf and creamy mashed potatoes with a delightful skin elevate the dining experience. Complementing the meal, appetizers like Burrata and Brisket Mac and Cheese satisfy taste buds and set the stage for a feast that delights all diners. Although prices lean toward the higher side, the quality and taste of the dishes justify the expense, rendering Meat & Potatoes a worthwhile dining destination.
In conclusion, Meat & Potatoes isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a haven for those seeking an exceptional culinary experience. With its exquisite dishes, attentive service, and an ambiance that strikes a chord between intimacy and vibrancy, this establishment remains a standout choice for those looking to savor delectable meals in Pittsburgh’s vibrant dining scene.
Address: 649 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15222, United States
Phone: +1 412-325-7007

10. Altius 

Altius in Pittsburgh stands as a beacon of exceptional dining, where impeccable service, breathtaking city views, and exquisite cuisine converge to offer patrons an unparalleled culinary experience.
From the moment patrons step in, the service exudes perfection. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, including the friendly waitress and manager, ensure a seamless dining journey. The synchronized arrival of each plate by a well-coordinated team underscores the commitment to providing a top-notch dining experience.
Altius - best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
Altius – best steakhouse in Pittsburgh
The setting itself earns top marks, with an exquisite city view that captivates diners, especially those lucky enough to secure a window seat. The restaurant’s location adjacent to the Duquesne Incline adds an extra layer of charm, inviting patrons to integrate it into their Pittsburgh experience.
For solo diners seeking an extraordinary meal, Altius exceeds expectations. From the unmatched views to the warm reception and exceptional food suggestions, the staff ensures a memorable experience, even for those dining alone. Bartenders go the extra mile, crafting personalized cocktails that cater to individual preferences, enhancing the overall dining affair.
Celebrating special occasions at Altius becomes a memorable affair, as evidenced by an anniversary celebration that unfolded flawlessly. From the warm congratulations upon arrival to the prompt seating with a spectacular view, every aspect of the dining experience was meticulously orchestrated. Each course, accompanied by delightful “extras,” showcased culinary finesse, while the friendly, informative, and attentive service added a personal touch to the celebration. Valet parking further adds to the convenience, making the entire experience seamless and enjoyable.
Even for patrons stopping by for a drink, Altius doesn’t disappoint. The bar offers an unparalleled view of the city, enhancing the enjoyment of a cold beverage as the sun sets. Despite the price, the exceptional service leaves a lasting impression, prompting a desire to return for a complete dining experience during future visits to Pittsburgh.
In essence, Altius isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an experience that transcends ordinary dining. With its breathtaking views, exceptional service, and exquisite cuisine, it stands as a quintessential destination for those seeking an unparalleled culinary adventure in the heart of Pittsburgh.
Address: 1230 Grandview Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15211, United States
Phone: +1 412-904-4442
See also  Reviews of The 10 BEST Steakhouses in Cleveland