Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Siesta Key

5/5 - (1 vote)
Welcome to the ultimate guide presenting authentic reviews and culinary delights showcasing the “best seafood in Siesta Key.” Nestled amidst the stunning shores and vibrant ambiance of Siesta Key, this compilation unveils the top ten seafood establishments that epitomize excellence in taste, service, and ambiance. Brace yourself for a gastronomic journey as we delve into the finest seafood havens, each offering a unique and delectable experience that embodies the essence of this picturesque coastal paradise.

Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Siesta Key

1.Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key

Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood, a revered gem nestled in the heart of Siesta Key Village, encapsulates the essence of fine dining with an alluring blend of impeccable service and exceptional culinary mastery. Boasting an illustrious history intertwined with the essence of Siesta Key, this establishment has won the hearts of locals and tourists alike. Guests revel in an experience that transcends mere dining—a sentiment echoed by a chorus of loyal patrons who’ve made it a perennial destination.
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key
Step into the realm of Summer House, where gastronomic marvels await. The menu, an ode to exquisite taste, features delights that consistently earn accolades. From the tantalizing smoked old-fashioned cocktails to the meticulously prepared dishes that grace the table, every element is orchestrated to perfection. The tender, melt-in-your-mouth steaks stand as a testament to culinary craftsmanship, while the seafood offerings enchant the palate, leaving a lasting impression of coastal indulgence.
The attentive and cordial staff, including the esteemed addition of Ricco, elevates the dining experience to unparalleled heights. Their commitment to excellence shines through in every interaction, ensuring that each guest feels cherished and attended to, fostering an ambiance of warmth and hospitality.
One can’t help but be captivated by the attention to detail exhibited here. Celebrations are elevated to new heights as evidenced by a heartwarming tale of a 5th birthday celebration for a young grandson, where the staff went above and beyond to create cherished memories for the family. The little one even found an unlikely friend in the form of a Pufferfish, adding an extra sprinkle of magic to the evening.
The ambiance exudes sophistication and charm, mirroring the coastal allure of Siesta Key. While not every dish may resonate equally with every palate—such as the mixed opinions on the Brussel sprouts—the overall culinary symphony leaves an indelible mark.
The restaurant’s rebirth, paying homage to Siesta Key’s history, is a testament to its evolution and dedication to culinary excellence. Chef Evan Gastman orchestrates a culinary journey that surpasses expectations, showcasing a menu that marries tradition with innovation.
For those seeking an exceptional dining experience in Siesta Key, Summer House Steak & Seafood stands tall as a beacon of culinary finesse. Whether savoring a 10-ounce filet mignon with a bleu cheese crust or relishing in the delightful oysters, each visit promises a symphony of flavors that will linger in memory long after the last bite.
In essence, Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood transcends the ordinary, crafting moments that transcend time and place, making it a cherished haven for aficionados of fine dining.
Address: 149 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242, United States
Menu: siestakeysummerhouse.com
Reservations: summerhousesiestakey.com
Phone: +1 941-260-2675

2.Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar – Siesta Key in Siesta Key

Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar on Siesta Key embodies the essence of a culinary gem, attracting both longtime visitors and newcomers to this charming island paradise. Nestled on the southern end of Siesta Key, this establishment boasts its own little village, complete with an inviting restaurant and an attached bar that exudes a lively and cheerful atmosphere, complemented by live music and entertainment.
The allure of Captain Curt’s extends beyond its vibrant ambiance; it’s the flavors that truly steal the show. A testament to this is the revered clam chowder that receives unanimous praise from patrons—rich, hearty, and adorned with ample succulent clam pieces, it stands out as a signature dish that even those not typically fond of clam chowder find irresistible. The addition of Captain Curt’s hot sauce adds an extra zing, elevating the experience to new heights.
Captain Curt's Crab & Oyster Bar - Siesta Key in Siesta Key
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar – Siesta Key in Siesta Key
The menu offers a delightful array of seafood options that captivate the taste buds. From the Cajun and garlic butter file fish, both celebrated for their excellence, to the tantalizing fried oyster basket paired with fries and coleslaw, each dish is a testament to quality and flavor. The grouper, grouper bites, and chicken wings have also garnered high praise, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to culinary excellence.
Beyond the gastronomic delights, Captain Curt’s envelops its patrons in a joyful dining experience. The lively ambiance, coupled with the tunes drifting from the neighboring Tiki Bar, creates an atmosphere that beckons guests to relax and immerse themselves in the island’s spirit. The presence of live music, including a one-man band, adds an extra layer of entertainment, enhancing the overall experience.
The attentive and timely service adds to the positive ambiance, with staff ensuring that every guest feels welcomed and taken care of. Whether visiting for an afternoon snack or an evening meal, the consistent quality of both the food and service makes Captain Curt’s a favored destination.
For those seeking a genuine taste of Siesta Key’s culinary delights, Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar stands out as a must-visit spot. With its flavorful offerings, lively atmosphere, and dedication to customer satisfaction, it’s no wonder that both locals and visitors continue to return, making it a cherished dining destination on this picturesque island.
Address: 1200 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States
Menu: captaincurts.com
Order: alohaorderonline.com
Phone: +1 941-349-3885

3.Lobster Pot Restaurant – best seafood in Siesta Key

Nestled within the vibrant Siesta Village on Siesta Key, the Lobster Pot Restaurant stands as a beacon of New England culinary tradition amid the sun-soaked shores of Sarasota, Florida. Rooted in a rich legacy traced back to the 1940s when Glen Medeiros’ father, a Portuguese fisherman, first established the Lobster Pot in Cape Cod, this family legacy transcends generations, offering a taste of authentic seafood excellence.
From the moment you step into the quaint yet inviting ambiance, it’s evident why patrons hold this restaurant in high esteem. Boasting a charming setting and a warm welcome, Lobster Pot radiates a cozy atmosphere that invites you to savor a delightful meal while creating cherished memories.
Lobster Pot Restaurant - best seafood in Siesta Key
Lobster Pot Restaurant – best seafood in Siesta Key
The menu, a testament to freshness and quality, features an array of delectable seafood offerings that capture the essence of the Gulf of Mexico’s bounty. Patrons rave about the tender cod fish and chips, a perennial favorite that embodies the perfect blend of crispness and tenderness. The sampler meal, a medley of shrimp, scallops, fish, and fried clams, presents a flavorful symphony that appeals to both adults and children alike, catering to varied tastes and appetites.
Highlighting the dining experience are the staff members, particularly Vera, who consistently go above and beyond to ensure each guest feels valued and attended to. Their warmth and attentiveness elevate the overall dining experience, making every visit not just a meal but a joyful and friendly encounter.
Undoubtedly, Lobster Pot’s appeal extends beyond its delectable offerings. Its consistency in delivering fresh, flavorful seafood dishes coupled with exceptional service cements its status as a beloved dining spot on Siesta Key. Even for those leaning toward dishes outside the seafood spectrum, the restaurant’s commitment to excellence shines through, delighting patrons with memorable dining experiences.
Despite occasional crowds, particularly during peak seasons, the allure of Lobster Pot endures. Patrons attest to the restaurant’s ability to maintain exceptional service and cuisine, making it a reliable choice for those seeking quality seafood in a welcoming setting.
For anyone yearning for a taste of New England’s seafood tradition amidst the charm of Siesta Key, the Lobster Pot Restaurant emerges as a beacon of culinary excellence. Its fresh offerings, congenial atmosphere, and unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction make it a cherished destination for seafood enthusiasts and families alike.
Address: 5157 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States
Menu: sarasotalobsterpot.com
Phone: +1 941-349-2323

4.SPEARFISH GRILLE – best seafood in Siesta Key

SPEARFISH GRILLE, nestled in the scenic Siesta Key Marina at 1265 Old Stickney Point Road, is a seafood haven that beckons both locals and visitors seeking an exceptional dining experience. Its idyllic setting overlooking the inland waterway and bustling marina sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. However, recent parking experiences adjacent to the restaurant have raised concerns, detracting from an otherwise stellar dining outing.
The restaurant, specializing in locally caught seafood, boasts a menu that tantalizes the taste buds with a variety of delightful options. Dishes like jumbo coconut Gulf shrimp, fish tacos, hogfish variations, and grilled tiki corn leave patrons raving about the flavors that captivate the palate. Noteworthy recommendations such as the sushi nachos and the flavorful hogfish tacos stand out as crowd favorites, promising a delightful gastronomic journey.
SPEARFISH GRILLE - best seafood in Siesta Key
SPEARFISH GRILLE – best seafood in Siesta Key
Yet, amid the culinary delight, recent parking woes, orchestrated by an adjacent parking management company, have cast a shadow over the overall experience for some patrons. Reports of exorbitant billing tactics and an alleged lack of transparent signage in the automated parking lot have marred the otherwise positive dining experience. This unfortunate situation, unrelated to the restaurant’s operations, has soured the experience for guests and brings into question the tourist-friendly ethos of the location.
Setting aside the parking predicament, the ambiance at SPEARFISH GRILLE paints a picture of conviviality and relaxation. The patio area, complemented by live music and a friendly atmosphere, adds to the charm of this waterfront dining destination. Families find solace in the entertainment offerings for children, albeit the occasional loudness of live music.
Despite the parking debacle, the restaurant itself remains a highlight, drawing praise for its excellent waitstaff and culinary prowess. Patrons laud the attentive and knowledgeable servers who enhance the dining experience with their friendly yet unobtrusive service.
In conclusion, while SPEARFISH GRILLE stands as a beacon of delightful seafood dining in Siesta Key, recent parking-related challenges have marred the overall experience for some patrons. The culinary offerings and amiable atmosphere create a compelling draw, yet the need for improved parking transparency nearby remains a significant concern that detracts from the overall enjoyment of this otherwise commendable establishment.
Located in: Safe Harbor Siesta Key
Address: 1265 Old Stickney Point Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Phone: +1 941-349-1971

5.The Cottage – best seafood in Siesta Key

The Cottage, nestled in the heart of Siesta Village at 153 Avenida Messina, stands as a culinary gem on Siesta Key, captivating diners with its superb cuisine and inviting ambiance. This establishment, a beacon of dining excellence since 1997, has garnered a loyal following for its remarkable blend of flavors and welcoming atmosphere.
As you step into The Cottage, a sense of comfort and warmth envelopes you, setting the stage for an exceptional dining experience. With two charming outdoor dining patios and a serene back terrace, patrons have the privilege of choosing their ideal setting. Those who dined on the back terrace expressed a delightful case of FOMO (fear of missing out) about the front porch but found solace in the mellow guitar tunes that graced the patio—a testament to the establishment’s attention to creating a relaxing yet vibrant ambiance.
The Cottage - best seafood in Siesta Key
The Cottage – best seafood in Siesta Key
The menu at The Cottage presents a tantalizing array of traditional and conventional Florida fare, with an emphasis on the freshest catches from the nearby Gulf of Mexico. Dishes like Chilean salmon, blackened Florida grouper, and delectable salads featuring lobster bisque and Cottage Caesar salad with romaine hearts exemplify the culinary expertise that patrons have come to expect. And of course, the iconic key lime pie, a Florida staple, remains a consistent delight for dessert enthusiasts.
Amidst the delightful culinary journey, the service at The Cottage is a standout feature. Cherri and Crystal, among other attentive servers, are lauded for their exceptional hospitality and dedication, elevating the dining experience to unparalleled heights. Patrons praise the outstanding service that begins from the moment of seating, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable meal for all.
Whether it’s a delightful brunch, a memorable lunch, or an evening of delectable seafood, The Cottage promises an exquisite dining experience. From the grilled grouper to the blackened tuna club, each dish is crafted to perfection, leaving an indelible mark on the taste buds of diners. The cocktails, noted for their uniqueness and fabulous flavors, add an extra layer of delight to the overall culinary journey.
In conclusion, The Cottage emerges as a quintessential dining destination in Siesta Key, where exceptional service meets an outstanding culinary offering. With its inviting atmosphere, flavorsome dishes, and attentive service, it comes as no surprise that patrons praise this establishment as a go-to spot for a solid meal in a fantastic location.
Address: 153 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242, United States
Phone: +1 941-312-9300

6.Another Broken Egg Cafe in Siesta Key

Another Broken Egg Cafe, nestled in the bustling heart of Siesta Key, stands as a beacon of delightful breakfast and brunch options, enchanting patrons with its delectable offerings and vibrant ambiance. Renowned for its flavorful creations and welcoming atmosphere, this establishment has cemented its place as a go-to spot for an exceptional morning meal experience.
From the moment you step into Another Broken Egg, the excitement for an outstanding breakfast journey begins. The drinks menu shines with exceptional concoctions like the Abe Bloody Mary and the tantalizing blueberry margaritas, praised by patrons for their unique flavors that pleasantly surprise even non-aficionados of these beverages.
Another Broken Egg Cafe in Siesta Key
Another Broken Egg Cafe in Siesta Key
Despite the occasional crowd, adept management and a convenient online check-in system facilitate a smoother dining experience. Patrons recommend using the online check-in option to minimize wait times, ensuring a hassle-free start to the dining adventure.
Once seated, the menu unfolds a delightful array of options, each dish crafted with precision and excellence. The key lime pancakes, lauded for their heavenly taste, stand out as a highlight, leaving diners enchanted by their flavorful allure. The children’s silver dollar pancakes also garner praise for their perfect portion size and delightful taste.
The Cafe’s commitment to catering to various dietary needs is evident with offerings like gluten-sensitive pancakes, a welcome gesture appreciated by guests. The attentive and efficient service, highlighted by servers like Denise, adds an extra layer of delight to the dining experience, ensuring patrons feel welcome and well-attended.
The menu diversity at Another Broken Egg Cafe extends beyond food to its drink offerings, showcasing a variety that caters to diverse tastes. From the Peach Bellini to the Strawberry Lemonade Spritzer, each beverage complements the meal exquisitely, further enhancing the overall dining experience.
In conclusion, Another Broken Egg Cafe emerges as a delightful breakfast and brunch destination in Siesta Key. With its delectable offerings, efficient service, and inviting atmosphere, it’s no wonder patrons consistently recommend this establishment as a must-visit spot for those seeking an exceptional morning meal while in the area.
Address: 140 Avenida Messina, Siesta Key, FL 34242, United States
Order: anotherbrokenegg.com, doordash.com, grubhub.com, postmates.com, seamless.com, ubereats.com, trycaviar.com
Phone: +1 941-552-8320

7.Sun Garden Cafe – best seafood in Siesta Key

Sun Garden Cafe, adorned with multiple accolades including “Best Breakfast,” “Best Lunch,” “Best Outdoor Dining,” and the esteemed title of “Best Bacon,” stands as a culinary gem in Siesta Key Village, Florida. Nestled at 210 Avenida Madera just off Ocean Boulevard, this pet-friendly haven beckons both locals and visitors alike, promising a delightful dining experience every time.
The cafe, revered for its convenience and habit-forming allure, remains a short drive from the condominiums in Siesta Key. Open daily from 7:30 to 1:30, it boasts a welcoming atmosphere that extends a warm embrace to patrons seeking a savory late breakfast or a delightful lunch after a day at the beach.
Sun Garden Cafe - best seafood in Siesta Key
Sun Garden Cafe – best seafood in Siesta Key
Breakfast at Sun Garden Cafe is a feast for the senses. Patrons rave about the extensive menu that boasts classic rock-inspired dishes, with portions that generously satiate hunger pangs. The traditional Eggs Benedict, adorned with poached eggs, Canadian bacon, and hollandaise sauce on an English muffin, steals the spotlight. Complemented by a delightful selection of breakfast options such as the A.M. Cobbler and banana pancakes, each dish is a testament to the cafe’s culinary prowess.
The portion sizes, often deemed immense, invite guests to savor their meal and enjoy the flavors beyond a single sitting. Despite prices in the mid-teens, patrons enthusiastically declare that breakfast at Sun Garden Cafe is a value-for-money experience, akin to a “buy one, get one free” deal due to the generous servings.
Returning patrons affirm the consistency in the cafe’s excellence, noting that their recent visit was as exceptional as their previous experiences. The freshness and tastiness of the food, coupled with the welcoming demeanor of the staff, continue to leave a lasting impression on guests, prompting immediate requests for return visits.
For those seeking the finest Bloody Mary in Siesta Key, Sun Garden Cafe stands out as a remarkable discovery. Amidst the bustling scene on a sunny Saturday morning, patrons find solace in the cafe’s relaxed outdoor seating, relishing the sweet and helpful service provided by the waitstaff. The meticulously prepared breakfast sandwiches, fresh fruit, and an array of tempting menu options serve as a testament to the cafe’s culinary excellence, leaving diners eager for future visits.
In conclusion, Sun Garden Cafe emerges as a quintessential dining destination in Siesta Key, offering not only an exceptional breakfast but also a warm and inviting atmosphere complemented by attentive service. Its consistent delivery of fresh, tasty dishes ensures an experience that’s not to be missed, making it a cherished gem for both locals and visitors exploring Siesta Key’s culinary delights.
Located in: Siesta Key Village
Address: 210 Avenida Madera, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Phone: +1 941-346-7170

8.Miguel’s Restaurant – best seafood in Siesta Key

Miguel’s Restaurant, an exquisite French culinary haven nestled at 6631 Midnight Pass Road on Siesta Key in Sarasota, Florida, has established itself as a beacon of fine dining excellence. Since its inception in 1983 by the visionary Miguel Garcia, the restaurant has undergone a transformative journey, evolving into a revered dining destination managed by his sons, Gabriel and Daniel, who have steered the establishment to new heights of success.
Miguel's Restaurant - best seafood in Siesta Key
Miguel’s Restaurant – best seafood in Siesta Key
This esteemed restaurant offers an array of culinary experiences, ranging from an early bird menu catering to cost-conscious diners to classy tableside presentations that elevate dining into an art form. Open daily from 4 to 10, Miguel’s is a place where reservations are a must due to its well-deserved popularity.
The dining experience at Miguel’s is nothing short of a culinary masterpiece. The menu boasts a range of delectable options, from escargot and Tiger shrimp to classic French delicacies like Coquille St. Jacques Mornay and Chateaubriand for Two. Each dish, meticulously prepared, showcases the culinary expertise that has earned the restaurant its stellar reputation.
The tableside presentations at Miguel’s add an extra layer of elegance and spectacle to the dining affair. From the Caesar salad meticulously prepared with parmesan, croutons, and the house’s creamy dressing to the signature desserts like Bananas Foster for Two, each presentation is a delightful culinary performance.
The ambiance at Miguel’s exudes a relaxed yet upscale aura, offering patrons a sophisticated and inviting space to relish the exquisite flavors. Complemented by excellent professional service, the restaurant ensures that every guest experiences nothing short of a memorable fine dining extravaganza.
In conclusion, Miguel’s Restaurant stands tall as a fantastic French dining destination in Siesta Key, offering an unparalleled gastronomic journey that showcases exceptional food, impeccable service, and a captivating ambiance. For those seeking an extraordinary culinary experience that transcends mere dining into an unforgettable celebration of flavors and elegance, Miguel’s is an absolute must-visit destination.
Address: 6631 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States
Order: miguelsrestaurant.net
Phone: +1 941-349-4024

9.Connors Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key

Connors Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key stands as a testament to consistent excellence, delivering a delightful array of steak and seafood offerings at reasonable prices within an inviting atmosphere.
Upon stepping into Connors, one is greeted not only by a diverse menu featuring steak and seafood but also by exceptional service that elevates the dining experience. Servers like Steven B. and Renee are hailed for their knowledge, humor, and attentiveness, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to the meal. They masterfully guide guests through the menu, offering insights into specials and providing recommendations that pleasantly surprise, like the delicious deviled eggs that left a lasting impression.
Connors Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key
Connors Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key
The food itself is consistently outstanding. Dishes like perfectly cooked steaks and delectable salmon paired with vibrant accompaniments like multi-colored couscous and broccoli showcase the culinary expertise of Connors. Guests find themselves indulging in mouthwatering starters such as mushrooms and delightful salads before delving into the main courses, each dish leaving a lasting mark of culinary excellence.
Celebrations at Connors are made even more special by exceptional service, exemplified by servers like Connor, who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable experience. Their attentiveness and anticipation of guests’ needs enhance the dining affair, turning special occasions like birthdays into cherished memories.
The ambiance at Connors contributes to a comfortable and enjoyable dining experience, allowing guests to savor their meals in a relaxed setting. The combination of excellent food, reasonable pricing, and exemplary service makes this restaurant a frequent choice for patrons seeking both quality and value.
In conclusion, Connors Steak & Seafood in Siesta Key continues to shine as a beacon of consistency, offering a delightful fusion of steak and seafood in a pleasant environment. With exceptional service, delectable dishes, and reasonable prices, it’s no wonder that patrons eagerly anticipate their return visits to savor both the food and the welcoming atmosphere.
Located in: Crossings at Siesta Key
Address: 3501 S Tamiami Trail #1165, Sarasota, FL 34239, United States
Reservations: connorsrestaurant.com, opentable.com
Phone: +1 941-260-3232

10.The Hub Baja Grill – best seafood in Siesta Key

The Hub Baja Grill on Siesta Key is a vibrant and flavorful dining spot that entices patrons with its fantastic food, upbeat atmosphere, and attentive service.
For those seeking authentic street-style tacos, The Hub delivers a treat with their Tuesday Taco special. Guests praise the flavorful meat fillings and appreciate the option to personalize with cheese and sour cream. While the chips and salsa are satisfying, some feel the pricing is a tad high, but the taco special is deemed worth revisiting.
The Hub Baja Grill - best seafood in Siesta Key
The Hub Baja Grill – best seafood in Siesta Key
The restaurant’s accommodating service stands out, especially for patrons with dietary restrictions like gluten-free preferences. The outdoor seating offers a pleasant view of Ocean Blvd, setting the stage for a delightful dining experience. The early arrival strategy pays off, as visitors enjoy delicious, generously portioned meals. The chimichangas and the sizable nachos, part of the enticing Happy Hour deal, receive rave reviews, complemented by the award-winning margaritas priced attractively during this time. However, parking limitations are noted as a minor inconvenience.
Guests praise the scrumptious Mahi Mahi blackened lettuce wraps, a standout dish that wins hearts with its exquisite taste. Even picky eaters find joy in the menu options, as highlighted by the kids’ satisfaction with their meals.
The culinary adventure continues with the must-try margaritas, a highlight among many. Dishes like Mahi Mahi tacos and rack of ribs leave taste buds singing praises, while the appetizer featuring Mexicorn, coated in delectable cojito cheese, steals the show.
The overall experience at The Hub Baja Grill is a blend of amazing food, a bustling ambiance, and an attentive, friendly staff. From the appetizing nachos to the beloved Cuban sandwich, patrons are treated to an exceptional culinary journey that leaves a lasting impression. Whether it’s for the outstanding meals or the refreshing margaritas, this restaurant comes highly recommended for anyone visiting the area, promising a memorable dining escapade.
Address: 5148 Ocean Blvd, Sarasota, FL 34242, United States
Phone: +1 941-349-6800
See also  The 10 Best Steakhouses in Fort Lauderdale