Reviews of the 10 best Seafood in Islamorada

5/5 - (1 vote)
Discovering the epitome of oceanic delight in Islamorada, a picturesque haven nestled within the Florida Keys, is an adventure that unfolds amid a symphony of flavors and culinary craftsmanship. Unveiling the Reviews of the 10 Best Seafood in Islamorada promises a gastronomic journey through the azure waters’ bounties, capturing the essence of each establishment’s dedication to serving the finest, freshest, and most delectable seafood creations in this tropical paradise.

Reviews of the 10 best seafood Restaurants in Islamorada

1. Chef Michael’s  

Chef Michael’s in Islamorada stands as a beacon of culinary excellence and seafood indulgence, just a leisurely stroll away from Cheeca Lodge. Renowned for its daily rotating fish mains, the restaurant draws patrons seeking a taste of the ocean’s finest offerings. Stepping into this elegant and classy establishment, patrons are greeted with a warm atmosphere and a staff that treats returning guests like cherished family.
Shelly, an attentive and knowledgeable server, adeptly guided us through the menu’s highlights, steering us toward the day’s catch – the Hogfish and the triple tail, prepared in the Adriatic style. Each dish, priced at $48, boasts generous portions and delectable flavors, making it well worth the investment.
Chef Michael's - best seafood in Islamorada
Chef Michael’s – best seafood in Islamorada
The mahi-mahi, adorned with its unique sauce, and the Hogfish, both meaty and flavorsome, showcased the chef’s expertise in seafood preparation. The dining experience continued to soar with the delightful Key Lime pie, albeit with a recommendation to bypass the sweet whipped cream. The bar, overseen by the skilled bartender Lacy, offers a curated menu and an extensive wine selection.
Lacy’s expert guidance led us to savor the roast duck and the intriguing “fish three ways,” an ensemble featuring three distinct fish fillets, each adorned with a unique sauce. The freshness and flavors of the seafood, coupled with the generous portions, left an indelible mark on our palates. The roast duck, accompanied by mango sauce and jasmine rice, proved equally tantalizing. To commence the culinary voyage, the conch chowder brimmed with rich flavors, setting the tone for the exquisite evening ahead. The triple tail, prepared with a crab-mushroom-caper sauce and blackened to perfection, accompanied by sides like coconut rice and mashed potatoes, elevated the dining experience to new heights.
As a finale, the caramel cheesecake stole the show, leaving not a morsel behind. The intimate and quaint ambiance adds to the allure of this gastronomic gem, making reservations a must for those seeking a memorable dining escapade in Islamorada. With its impeccable service, diverse menu, and consistently stellar dishes, Chef Michael’s emerges as an absolute culinary delight and a must-visit destination.
Address: 81671 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-664-0640

2. Lobster Shack 

Nestled along the scenic route of Islamorada, Lobster Shack stands as a quirky yet delightful culinary haven, drawing travelers seeking a taste of colossal lobster and savory delights. The iconic attraction of the “world’s largest lobster” sculpture by the roadside sets the stage for an experience that marries novelty with gastronomic satisfaction. The Lobster Shack exudes a charming appeal, with Katie, the amiable owner, lending a personal touch to every visit.
Lobster Shack - best seafood in Islamorada
Lobster Shack – best seafood in Islamorada
The lobster roll, a star attraction here, boasts fresh, succulent meat nestled alongside crisp lettuce on a roll – a departure from the typical lobster salad mix, yet a flavorful delight for purists seeking the essence of the lobster. The homemade pasta salad emerges as a surprising gem, its flavors beckoning for a larger portion. Patrons revel in the ambiance under the shade of expansive trees, enjoying ample seating and a serene environment perfect for relishing the generous lobster roll and other delectable offerings. The Key Lime pie, a quintessential Floridian dessert, delivers on its promise of tangy sweetness, a fitting conclusion to a seafood-filled affair. For some, the Lobster Shack also serves as a breakfast destination, earning accolades for its exceptional Bacon, Egg, and Cheese sandwich, a standout amidst the Keys’ varied offerings.
While some may find the prices steep, the quality and freshness of the fare eclipse any reservations, making it a worthwhile stop in the journey through Islamorada. Beyond the gastronomic delights, the surrounding area offers a haven for browsing through eclectic arts and gifts, providing a well-rounded experience for travelers.
Kathie’s warmth and hospitality add an extra layer of charm, making a return visit a compelling consideration for anyone passing through the area. The Lobster Shack encapsulates a unique blend of novelty, quality cuisine, and friendly service, making it a cool, must-stop destination for those traversing the Keys’ scenic route.
Located in: Rain Barrel Village
Address: 86700 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 954-260-0469

3. Square Grouper Islamorada 

Square Grouper in Islamorada emerges as a culinary gem nestled along the picturesque route between the mainland and Key West, inviting travelers and locals alike to an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you arrive, the ambiance exudes a vibrant, refined-casual charm, perfectly complementing the delectable offerings awaiting within. The restaurant boasts an impressive menu that tantalizes the taste buds, paired with impeccable service and a setting that effortlessly combines fun, cleanliness, and a colorful atmosphere.
Square Grouper Islamorada - best seafood in Islamorada
Square Grouper Islamorada – best seafood in Islamorada
Upon entering, the staff’s hospitality shines through, as exemplified by Mike, a solid and accommodating server who went above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit. Gemma from NJ rightly lauds the Square Grouper’s seamless teamwork, acknowledging the entire staff’s dedication to making each dining experience exceptional.
Families find this establishment particularly welcoming, with attentive hostesses catering to their needs, ensuring a comfortable wait with refreshments for both adults and the little ones. The culinary journey begins with delightful calamari, a hit even among discerning young palates. The main courses – the seafood pasta bowl and the scallops entree – stand out as culinary masterpieces, pleasing even the most discerning tastes.
The Square Grouper isn’t just a culinary delight; it’s a breath of fresh air for Islamorada. Its bay-side marina location offers more than just picturesque views; it delivers on quality and service, setting a new standard for dining in the Keys. The upstairs Happy Hour adds another layer of enjoyment, offering an elevated experience that’s unparalleled.
For those seeking hearty portions and flavors that linger in memory, the stew, aptly described by the waitress as “big enough to soak your feet in,” stands as a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to quality and generosity. Even the heartiest appetites might find it a challenge to conquer the substantial servings. Accompanied by great wine, excellent service, and an inviting atmosphere, Square Grouper beckons visitors to partake in an unparalleled dining experience in the Keys. If you appreciate exceptional food, attentive service, and a welcoming atmosphere, Square Grouper should undoubtedly find its place on your list of must-visit destinations in Islamorada.
Address: 80460 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 786-901-5678

4. Twisted Shrimp  

Twisted Shrimp in Islamorada emerges as a delightful culinary gem, winning the hearts of patrons seeking gluten-free options and a diverse range of flavorful seafood delights. This quaint, family-owned establishment captivates visitors with its warm ambiance and a menu that boasts creative twists on shrimp dishes, leaving a lasting impression that beckons repeat visits.
Twisted Shrimp - best seafood in Islamorada
Twisted Shrimp – best seafood in Islamorada
The gluten-free options served as a magnet, drawing us back three times in just five days—an unmistakable testament to the quality and variety of offerings available. The Boom Boom Shrimp, adorned with a mustard-based sauce, might cater more to mustard aficionados, yet its delectable taste left a lasting impression, urging a second order the very next day. Meeting the owner, who exudes warmth and friendliness, added a personal touch to the dining experience, enhancing our appreciation for this charming eatery.
The pride and care taken in crafting each dish at Twisted Shrimp are evident in every bite. The homemade crab bisque earns well-deserved accolades, setting a high bar for seafood bisques. Though minor, a sign directing patrons to additional parking would enhance the overall experience.
The attention to detail shines through in the perfectly executed dishes. From the lightly battered and fresh mahi in the fish and chips to the burst of flavors in the jerk-seasoned grilled shrimp accompanied by Brussels sprouts, every element attests to the dedication to quality and culinary expertise. The mahi tacos, adorned with fresh mango salsa, delighted my husband’s taste buds, showcasing the freshness and thoughtfulness in every bite.
During our lunch visit, the friendly waitress guided us through the menu, setting the stage for an exceptional meal. The shrimp rice bowl, adorned with fresh shrimp and complemented by pineapple and mango salsa atop fluffy rice, presented a harmonious blend of flavors, a testament to the kitchen’s commitment to culinary excellence.
While the decor might not boast extravagance, it’s the passion for food and attentive service that truly steal the spotlight at Twisted Shrimp. I wholeheartedly recommend this place, as its dedication to crafting delicious, diverse, and gluten-free seafood options transcends any lack of fanciful decor. For those journeying through the Keys in search of a memorable dining experience, Twisted Shrimp is undoubtedly a destination worth savoring.
Address: 87745 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-440-2942

5. Bayside Gourmet 

Bayside Gourmet in Islamorada stands as a hidden culinary gem, charming patrons with its diverse menu offerings and welcoming atmosphere. Nestled within the heart of the Keys, this unassuming spot captures the essence of quality dining without the frills, delivering exceptional flavors that leave a lasting impression.
Bayside Gourmet - best seafood in Islamorada
Bayside Gourmet – best seafood in Islamorada
During our visit, the standout dishes were the pizza and key lime pie, both earning high praise. The pizza boasted an excellent crust, generously topped with fresh ingredients, delighting the palate with each bite. The key lime pie was hailed as exceptional, ranking as the best sampled among various eateries. Service was a shining highlight—prompt, warm, and efficient—adding to the overall enjoyable dining experience.
The restaurant’s diverse beverage selection, including an array of local beers and a varied wine list, complemented the flavorful dishes. Our server, Andrea, guided us through the menu with expertise, offering friendly and helpful suggestions that enhanced our culinary journey.
The veggie pizza, with its thick and flavorful crust, emerged as a crowd favorite, showcasing freshness and taste in every bite. Even after indulging in the satisfying meal, we couldn’t resist taking home desserts—a testament to our contentment and the quality of the dining experience.
Bayside Gourmet’s unassuming appearance belies its culinary prowess. The lobster bisque, Cuban sandwich, and other delectable offerings highlight the kitchen’s commitment to excellence. This insight led us to appreciate the quality found in smaller, lesser-known establishments, surpassing the fame of larger names in the area.
The restaurant’s retro ambiance, reminiscent of the ’80s and ’90s, added a unique charm to our dining experience, setting the stage for a relaxed and enjoyable meal. Dishes such as the veal parmesan and the prosciutto, spinach, and mushroom pizza impressed with their flavors, showcasing the kitchen’s culinary finesse. The carrot cake, taken to-go, proved to be a delightful finale to a memorable dinner.
Bayside Gourmet’s unpretentious yet quality-driven approach to food and service solidifies its standing as a must-visit spot in Islamorada. For those seeking a blend of exceptional flavors, friendly service, and a laid-back atmosphere, this eatery stands as a testament to the notion that the best culinary experiences often hide in unassuming corners.
Address: 82758 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-735-4471

6. Mangrove Mike’s Cafe 

Mangrove Mike’s Cafe in Islamorada serves as a beacon of warmth and flavor, capturing the hearts of travelers and locals alike. Nestled on the route to Key West, this charming spot offers an inviting breakfast experience that lingers in memory long after the meal ends.
Mangrove Mike's Cafe - best seafood in Islamorada
Mangrove Mike’s Cafe – best seafood in Islamorada
Our journey to this establishment began with a spontaneous decision based on glowing reviews, and we were greeted by a bustling yet welcoming atmosphere. Despite the crowd, we found ample space to savor a delightful breakfast. The menu, abundant with choices, coupled with impeccable service, immediately won us over and made us feel right at home.
Beyond the exceptional culinary offerings, Mangrove Mike’s embodies a deeper sense of community and empathy. The cafe’s tribute to 2001 First Responders, coupled with their support for the mission of Service Dogs Saving Lives, reflects their commitment to giving back and honoring those who serve. This genuine care and dedication resonate with patrons, adding an extra layer of significance to the dining experience.
The cafe’s Florida vibe, complemented by delicious cuisine and a laid-back atmosphere, creates an inviting ambiance that beckons visitors seeking an authentic local experience. The staff’s friendliness and expertise, especially regarding food allergies, reflect a commitment to guest satisfaction and comfort.
During our stay in Islamorada, Mangrove Mike’s became a frequent haunt, impressing us with consistently outstanding meals during our three visits. We learned of Mike’s legacy, a local hero who sadly passed away, yet left behind a restaurant that embodies his spirit and values. The dedication of the staff to preserving Mike’s memory through exceptional service and cuisine truly stands as a testament to his impact on the community.
From the moment you step inside, the warm greetings and attentive service set the tone for a memorable dining experience. Whether seated at a table or enjoying the counter service, the prompt attention and quality of the food, particularly the delectable grits, continue to astound. Our five breakfasts here were a testament to the consistency and excellence that Mangrove Mike’s Cafe consistently delivers.
In summary, Mangrove Mike’s Cafe isn’t just a place to dine; it’s an embodiment of community, warmth, and exceptional flavors, making it an unmissable stop for those seeking a genuine taste of Florida hospitality in Islamorada.
Located in: Lobster Trap Art Gift Shop and Gallery
Address: 82200 Overseas Hwy MM, 82 sunset inn, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Areas served: Islamorada and nearby areas
Phone: +1 305-664-8022

7. The Oceanview Inn & Sports Pub  

The Oceanview Inn & Sports Pub in Islamorada stands as a timeless gem along the route to Key West, offering a unique and charming experience that beckons travelers to slow down and savor the essence of the Keys. This classic establishment exudes an undeniable charm, resonating with guests seeking a taste of nostalgic hospitality blended with modern-day vibrancy.
The Oceanview Inn & Sports Pub - best seafood in Islamorada
The Oceanview Inn & Sports Pub – best seafood in Islamorada
Breaking the journey between Miami and Key West proved to be an excellent decision, and Oceanview Inn became the highlight of our stopover. The ambiance, reminiscent of a bygone era, coupled with the warmth of the staff and fellow patrons in the sports bar, created an inviting atmosphere that felt like a home away from home. The rooms, though embodying a classic charm, carried a distinct appeal reminiscent of simpler times, adding to the overall allure.
Every interaction with the staff at OV was met with genuine kindness and assistance, enhancing the overall experience. The sports pub and restaurant didn’t disappoint, offering nightly entertainment that added a layer of fun to our stay. The steak night was a culinary delight, complemented by a lively atmosphere and excellent service from all the bartenders, especially William, whose infectious energy added to the enjoyment of our time there.
The spacious and clean rooms, accompanied by a serene pool just steps away, painted a picturesque setting. The seamless transition from room to lush greens leading to the pool area created a tranquil escape. The convenience of having the bar right by the pool added an element of leisure, making it effortless to indulge in refreshing cocktails while soaking up the Florida sun.
Staying at Oceanview Inn allowed us to explore the diverse sites from Key Largo to Marathon, adding to the convenience and appeal of this charming abode. Whether lounging by the pool, enjoying delectable dolphin fingers and pork sliders, or relishing cold beers while watching sports, each visit during our stay left an indelible mark, compelling us to return thrice within our six-night stay.
In summary, The Oceanview Inn & Sports Pub is more than just a place to rest; it’s an immersive experience that embodies the spirit of the Florida Keys. From the inviting accommodations to the vibrant atmosphere of the sports pub, it’s a haven for travelers seeking nostalgia, warmth, and a touch of modern enjoyment. A stay here is a must for anyone traversing the Keys, promising a stay filled with relaxation, entertainment, and delightful memories that linger long after checkout.
Address: 84500 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-664-8052

8. MEAT Eatery And Taproom 

MEAT Eatery And Taproom in Islamorada stands as a culinary haven, beckoning both locals and visitors to indulge in a gastronomic experience unlike any other along the Key West to Miami Beach route. Renowned for its excellence, featured on “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives,” this eatery delivers on its promise of exceptional burgers and so much more.
MEAT Eatery And Taproom - best seafood in Islamorada
MEAT Eatery And Taproom – best seafood in Islamorada
The atmosphere exudes a local charm that resonates with patrons, steering away from typical tourist spots. The staff, cool and friendly, adds a personal touch to the dining experience. Engaging in conversations beyond just the food, whether about music or beverages, further enhances the welcoming ambiance.
The star of the show is undoubtedly the award-winning burger, a delightful symphony of flavors and juiciness that satisfies every palate. Complemented by sides like onion rings or French fries, each element stands out, especially the flavorful condiments that elevate the meal. For those not inclined towards kale, the coleslaw offers an alternative side choice that’s equally appetizing.
For travelers seeking out iconic spots featured on television shows like “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives,” MEAT Eatery And Taproom perfectly aligns with the quest for delicious and iconic food. The Fancy Nancy burger, cooked to perfection, earns accolades for its flavorful profile and expertly crafted bun, leaving a lasting impression and a craving for another visit.
Beyond burgers, the menu boasts an array of chef-inspired creations, all made in-house. From house-smoked bacon to house-made pork rinds, each item reflects the dedication to culinary excellence. The extensive selection of beers, wines, and canned cocktails caters to diverse tastes, offering the perfect beverage to accompany the mouthwatering dishes.
Regular patrons attest to the consistency and quality that MEAT Eatery And Taproom delivers, labeling their burgers as among the best nationwide. The commitment to crafting everything in-house, combined with the extensive beverage options, sets this establishment apart as a culinary destination worth revisiting time and again.
In essence, MEAT Eatery And Taproom is more than a burger joint; it’s a culinary marvel that celebrates house-made delights and an ambiance that invites patrons to savor every bite and sip. Whether you’re a burger aficionado or seeking a memorable dining experience amidst your travels, this spot promises satisfaction and leaves you yearning for the next visit.
Address: 88005 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-852-3833

9. Lazy Days Restaurant 

Lazy Days Restaurant in Islamorada captures the essence of a quintessential seaside dining experience, boasting an array of fresh, unfrozen culinary delights coupled with a picturesque view that accentuates the dining pleasure.
Lazy Days Restaurant - best seafood in Islamorada
Lazy Days Restaurant – best seafood in Islamorada
Upon arrival, one can’t help but notice the breathtaking vista that awaits at the back of the store—an amazing view that enhances the dining ambiance. While the establishment might benefit from a bit of tender loving care, the quality of the food surpasses any superficial concerns. The grilled mahi mahi, cooked to perfection, exemplifies the freshness and care that goes into each dish, earning praise alongside other delectable plates.
What sets Lazy Days apart is its dedication to freshness and quality. The menu boasts an outstanding array of fish prepared in various ways, all made from scratch, including condiments like tartar sauce and blue cheese dressing, and accompanied by freshly baked hot yeast rolls. Though not considered cheap, the experience justifies the cost, offering exceptional value for the quality and variety of dishes.
The breathtaking beachside view further enhances the dining experience, allowing guests to marvel at tarpons swimming in the backdrop, adding a touch of serenity to the meal. The service receives commendation, with the waitstaff delivering top-notch service, even while maneuvering trays of food down the stairs with remarkable agility.
For those seeking a taste of local favorites, Lazy Days delivers. Conch fritters, shrimp cocktail, and chicken teriyaki all receive acclaim, prompting return visits owing to the impressive quality and service experienced during previous dining occasions.
Recommended by locals who frequent Islamorada, this restaurant lives up to its reputation. The waitstaff’s excellence, combined with the delectable offerings such as oysters, boiled shrimp, and the jalapeño-crusted fish sandwich, paints a picture of culinary satisfaction. Beyond the culinary delights, the beautiful view adds a layer of tranquility to the dining experience, further cementing Lazy Days as a must-visit spot in Islamorada.
In summary, Lazy Days Restaurant stands as a beacon of exquisite seafood dining, offering not only a diverse and flavorful menu but also a stunning view that complements the outstanding service. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience in Islamorada.
Address: 79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-664-5256

10. Islamorada Fish Company 

The Islamorada Fish Company is an outdoor gem nestled in Islamorada, boasting a casual yet delightful atmosphere that’s perfect for a leisurely lunch or dinner. The scenic tiki patio offers stunning views, allowing guests to dine amidst a picturesque setting that’s complemented by friendly service and an extensive menu.
Islamorada Fish Company - best seafood in Islamorada
Islamorada Fish Company – best seafood in Islamorada
During our visit, my mom and I were greeted by a warm and helpful waitress who guided us through the diverse menu. The selection was vast, offering a wide variety of delicious options that did not disappoint. We indulged in the seasonal stone crab claws, which lived up to their reputation, along with a full signature salad and a side of mashed potatoes that were generously sized and easily shareable. The perfect finale came in the form of their key lime pie – rich, sweet, and tangy, a true Floridian delight.
The large tiki patio, while warm, provided a refreshing breeze off the water, enhancing the dining experience. Amidst this scenic backdrop, the grouper fish and chips stood out as a delectable choice, accompanied by the joy of observing tarpons, angel fish, manatees, and pelicans adding to the ambiance.
The friendly server ensured speedy service, delivering sizable portions that satisfied our party of four. The meal pleased everyone’s palate, and the highlight was undoubtedly the fantastic Key Lime pie, a must-try delicacy at Islamorada Fish Company.
For seafood enthusiasts, the Wahoo took center stage. We savored fresh smoked Wahoo dip followed by two Wahoo-based dishes: Wahoo tacos and a generous Wahoo sandwich overflowing with flavor. The crispy seasoned fries and coleslaw perfectly complemented these dishes, culminating in a delightful dining experience worth savoring. A visit to the famed sports fishing store added a touch of history, completing our outing with an iconic view of the yacht made famous by Ernest Hemingway.
This stop along the way to Marathon, Florida, recommended by a friend, exceeded our expectations. The butterfly-style fried shrimp, served with fries and coleslaw, became an instant favorite, warranting our wholehearted recommendation to others.
In essence, the Islamorada Fish Company is more than a restaurant; it’s a destination that offers not just a diverse menu but also a delightful ambience filled with scenic views and friendly service. For seafood aficionados seeking a memorable dining experience amidst nature’s beauty, this establishment stands as a must-visit along the Keys.
Located in: Bass Pro Shops – World Wide Sportsman
Address: 81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States
Phone: +1 305-664-9271
See also  Reviews of the 10 Best Steakhouses in Atlanta, GA