If you’re a connoisseur of fine dining and have a penchant for perfectly seared steaks, then you’re in for a treat as we embark on a culinary journey through the heart of the Big Apple. In this article, we’ll be serving up our reviews of the 10 best steakhouses in Midtown NYC, where sizzling cuts of prime beef, expertly seasoned and grilled to perfection, are the name of the game. Whether you’re a New Yorker looking to indulge in the city’s finest carnivorous offerings or a visitor seeking an unforgettable dining experience, these top-notch establishments are sure to satisfy your cravings for the best steaks Midtown NYC has to offer.
The 10 best steakhouses in Midtown Nyc
Keens Steakhouse
Keens Steakhouse in Midtown NYC is a timeless gem that continues to impress diners with its rich history, impeccable service, and mouthwatering steaks. From the moment you step through the doors, you’re greeted with a warm and friendly atmosphere that sets the tone for a memorable dining experience. The attentive staff, as noted by many patrons, is both punctual and genuinely hospitable, ensuring that you feel welcome throughout your meal.
The true star of the show at Keens is undoubtedly the perfectly cooked steaks. Whether you opt for the T-Bone or the Filet mignon, you can expect nothing less than perfection on your plate. While one reviewer did mention that the lobster was a tad rubbery, the overall consensus is that the steaks are cooked to perfection. The variety of sauces, including the house steak sauce, provides an opportunity to explore different flavor profiles and enhance your steak-eating experience.
Dessert offerings at Keens, like the Key lime pie and Creme Brulee, maintain the high standard set by the main courses, leaving diners with a sweet and satisfying conclusion to their meal.
The ambiance at Keens is steeped in history, with its Churchwarden pipes adorning the ceilings and an impressive collection of over 90,000 pipes smoked by historical figures like Roosevelt, B. Ruth, Einstein, and J.P. Morgan. This unique decor adds to the restaurant’s charm and transports diners to a bygone era.
As for service, Keens continues to shine. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, including Marshall and Rusty, ensure that your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. The whiskey selection, while not extensive for Irish whiskey lovers, still impresses with its variety.
In summary, Keens Steakhouse stands as one of the best steak houses in New York City, where history, craftsmanship, ambiance, and impeccable service converge to create an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re a longtime patron or a first-time visitor, Keens remains a must-visit destination for those seeking the finest steaks and a taste of New York’s culinary history.
Address: 72 W 36th St., New York, NY 10018, United States
Hours: Closes soon ⋅ 10:30 PM ⋅ Opens 11:45 AM Fri
Menu: keens.com
Reservations: resy.com
Order: chownow.com
Phone: +1 212-947-3636
STK Steakhouse Midtown NYC
STK Steakhouse in Midtown NYC offers a dining experience that combines delectable cuisine, a vibrant atmosphere, and exceptional service, leaving patrons with lasting memories of their visit. From the moment you step inside, the friendly ambiance and prompt seating set the stage for an enjoyable evening.
One standout feature consistently praised in reviews is the knowledgeable and attentive waitstaff. Servers like Sergi and Matthew are known for their helpful recommendations and dedication to ensuring every guest’s needs are met. They not only guide diners through the menu but also create a welcoming and enjoyable atmosphere, elevating the overall dining experience.
The star of the show at STK is undoubtedly the food. Patrons rave about the perfectly cooked steaks, complemented by mouthwatering sides and sauces like the Truffle sauce. Reviewers often express their satisfaction with the culinary offerings, emphasizing the quality and taste of each dish.
While the food and service take center stage, the lively ambiance at STK also receives acclaim. Guests appreciate the upscale, modern steakhouse setting that seamlessly blends with a club-like atmosphere. The music and energetic vibe make it an ideal spot for those seeking a night out with a twist.
Furthermore, numerous reviews highlight the exceptional customer service provided by the staff, even in challenging situations. Instances where the staff went above and beyond to accommodate diners, as noted with the experience involving American Airlines, showcase the dedication and professionalism of the team at STK.
In summary, STK Steakhouse in Midtown NYC offers an exceptional dining experience that seamlessly fuses outstanding cuisine, a lively atmosphere, and top-notch service. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for a memorable night out, STK delivers on all fronts, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking a fun and delicious dining experience in the heart of the city.
Address: 1114 6th Ave, New York, NY 10036, United States
Hours: Open ⋅ Closes 12 AM
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Reservations: stksteakhouse.com
Order: myguestaccount.com
Phone: +1 646-624-2455
Strip House Steakhouse
Strip House Steakhouse in Midtown NYC stands as a beloved gem among steak enthusiasts and those seeking a sophisticated, classic New York dining experience. As noted by numerous patrons, this establishment boasts an ambiance that exudes class and maturity, making it a preferred choice for those looking to enjoy an adult-oriented dining experience. The decor, characterized by dark, clubby aesthetics, red leather, and classic pinup art, adds to the retro and cozy atmosphere, creating an ideal setting for a memorable meal.
Service at Strip House is consistently applauded for its excellence. Guests frequently commend the attentive and knowledgeable staff who offer impeccable recommendations and cater to their needs throughout the meal. The combination of great service, a carefully curated wine list, and standout sides ensures that every aspect of the dining experience is top-notch.
The star of the show, of course, is the food. Reviewers repeatedly praise the perfectly cooked steaks, with options like the fillet and ribeye earning accolades for their tenderness and flavor. Sides like the creamed spinach and Strip House potatoes add depth and richness to the meal, while the famous 24-layer chocolate cake is a dessert to remember.
The menu at Strip House is complemented by creative cocktails and an array of appetizers, including Tuna Tartare with black caviar and shrimp cocktail, further enhancing the overall dining experience. The restaurant’s commitment to quality and innovation in its cuisine is underscored by dishes like the Faroe Island salmon with a maple soy butter glaze and Miso Sea Bass in a truffle citrus butter sauce.
For those seeking an intimate and romantic dining experience, Strip House offers an ideal setting. The ambiance, characterized by dim lighting and classic decor, adds a touch of elegance to special occasions and romantic dinners.
In conclusion, Strip House Steakhouse in Midtown NYC consistently delivers on its reputation as a top-tier steakhouse. With its outstanding service, delectable cuisine, and timeless atmosphere, it remains a go-to destination for those in search of a classic New York steakhouse experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a superb steak, Strip House promises an unforgettable dining journey.
Address: 15 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4 PM
Menu: striphouse.com
Reservations: striphouse.com, opentable.com
Phone: +1 212-336-5454
Wolfgang’s Steakhouse
Wolfgang’s Steakhouse in Midtown NYC has garnered a loyal following for good reason, as evident in the numerous positive reviews from satisfied diners. Located in a bustling part of the city, this establishment provides a fantastic dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable.
One recurring highlight mentioned by patrons is the impeccably cooked porterhouse, which seems to be a favorite among diners. The steak, consistently described as cooked to perfection, is praised for its tenderness and flavor. It’s often recommended that the generous portions make sharing an excellent option, allowing guests to savor this culinary delight without feeling overwhelmed.
The attentive and professional service, represented by servers like Danny, is another standout feature. These service professionals enhance the overall experience by providing knowledgeable guidance and ensuring diners’ needs are met. The efficiency and courtesy of the staff contribute to the restaurant’s reputation for excellent service.
In addition to the steak, the sides, such as the potatoes and vegetables, receive praise for their generous portions and flavor. While some mention minor inconsistencies, the overall consensus is that the food at Wolfgang’s Steakhouse is delicious and worth the price.
The ambiance and decor of the restaurant contribute to its charm. Diners appreciate the sophisticated atmosphere and the sense of occasion that dining here brings. For many, Wolfgang’s Steakhouse serves as a go-to spot for special occasions and celebrations.
Despite the overwhelmingly positive reviews, there are occasional mentions of price concerns, particularly regarding the service charge added to checks. While this is noted as an issue by some, it doesn’t seem to detract from the overall positive dining experience.
In conclusion, Wolfgang’s Steakhouse in Midtown NYC has earned its reputation as a top-notch steakhouse with exceptional food and service. The porterhouse, attentive staff, and upscale atmosphere make it a go-to destination for both locals and visitors looking for a memorable steakhouse experience in the heart of Manhattan.
Address: Times Building, 250 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 12 PM
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Reservations: opentable.com
Phone: +1 212-921-3720
Sparks Steak House
Sparks Steak House in Midtown NYC holds a special place in the hearts of its patrons, and it’s evident in the glowing reviews from loyal customers who have made this establishment a part of their lives. With a history dating back to the 1960s, Sparks Steak House is not just a restaurant; it’s a cherished institution known for delivering an exceptional dining experience.
One of the recurring themes in these reviews is the enduring appeal of Sparks Steak House. Many diners, like the reviewer who’s been visiting for 20+ years, consider it a second home. The combination of fabulous food, impeccable service, and a sense of nostalgia creates an atmosphere that feels like a warm embrace.
The waitstaff, often mentioned by name, such as Miguel and Hector, play a crucial role in ensuring that guests have an unforgettable experience. Their dedication, knowledge, and hospitality elevate the dining experience to a level that keeps customers coming back for more.
The star of the show, of course, is the steak, specifically the Steak Fromage, which is highly praised for its flavor and size. The portion sizes at Sparks Steak House are renowned for being generous and satisfying, making sharing a common and enjoyable practice among diners.
Apart from the steak, the side dishes, including hash browns, asparagus, and spinach salad, receive their share of accolades for their quality and flavor. The consistency of the food and its preparation as ordered contribute to the restaurant’s stellar reputation.
The ambiance at Sparks Steak House is often described as a step back in time, providing an old New York charm that many seek when dining in the city. The atmosphere strikes a balance between being bustling and intimate, allowing for enjoyable conversations and a comfortable dining experience.
While some mention the prices, they also emphasize the value for money given the quality and quantity of the food served. The steak, in particular, is hailed as delicious and unforgettable.
In conclusion, Sparks Steak House in Midtown NYC continues to stand as a beloved icon of fine dining. With its exceptional service, delectable cuisine, and timeless ambiance, it’s no wonder that this restaurant has maintained its status as a top-notch establishment. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking an outstanding steak, Sparks Steak House delivers an experience that is both timeless and treasured.
Address: 210 E 46th St, New York, NY 10017, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 12 PM
Menu: sparkssteakhouse.hngr.co
Reservations: opentable.com
Order: doordash.com
Phone: +1 212-687-4855
Empire Steak House West
Empire Steak House West in Midtown NYC continues to impress diners, offering a memorable culinary experience that brings them back for more. With a reputation for impeccable service, a diverse menu, and a welcoming atmosphere, this establishment stands out among the many dining options in the city.
One of the key highlights in these reviews is the consistent quality of Empire Steak House. Customers are pleasantly surprised by the superb steaks and other offerings, making it a must-visit for those with a hankering for top-notch steak. The restaurant’s ability to maintain its high standards over time is a testament to its dedication to providing exceptional cuisine.
The bar staff, often mentioned by name, play a crucial role in creating a fantastic dining experience. Nantia, Marianna, and Thomas are commended for their expertise in serving drinks and food flawlessly. The cocktail recommendations, such as the old fashioned and martinis, are highly praised, making the bar a standout feature.
Service at Empire Steak House West is often described as attentive, courteous, and professional. Servers like Artie receive special mentions for their dedication to ensuring guests have a wonderful time. The atmosphere is noted for being pleasant and conducive to conversations, making it an ideal setting for a special evening out.
Albert, the general manager, and Besmir, also mentioned by name, are highlighted for their management skills, ensuring that guests have a memorable dining experience. Their attention to detail and focus on customer satisfaction contribute to the restaurant’s stellar reputation.
The variety of dishes, including steak, seafood, and vegetarian options, caters to a wide range of tastes, making it an attractive choice for diverse groups of diners. The portions are generous, and the quality of the food is consistently praised.
For special occasions, Empire Steak House West goes above and beyond to create memorable moments, such as singing “Happy Birthday” with personalized candles and providing exceptional hospitality.
In conclusion, Empire Steak House West in Midtown NYC has garnered a loyal following for its outstanding food, exemplary service, and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, seeking a delicious steak, or simply looking for a memorable dining experience, this restaurant delivers on all fronts, making it a must-visit destination for locals and visitors alike.
Address: 237 W 54th St, New York, NY 10019, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 7 AM
Delivery: 12 PM–10:30 PM · More hours
Menu: empiresteakhousenyc.com
Reservations: empiresteakhousenyc.com
Order: empiresteakhousenyc.com
Phone: +1 212-586-9700
Gallaghers Steakhouse
Gallaghers Steakhouse in Midtown NYC stands out as an exceptional dining establishment, where every aspect of the experience, from the ambiance to the service, and, most importantly, the food, exceeds expectations.
The reviews repeatedly emphasize the exceptional quality of the steak at Gallaghers. Diners are consistently impressed by the taste and tenderness of the steaks, which are cooked to perfection. The Rib Steak and Filet Mignon receive particular praise for their flavor and quality. The generous portions make sharing sides a common practice, further enhancing the dining experience.
The ambiance of Gallaghers Steakhouse is described as electric, and the bar area is noted as a vibrant and enjoyable space to begin the evening. The restaurant’s welcoming and energetic atmosphere contributes to the overall sense of excitement. It’s no wonder that the restaurant is fully booked on many evenings, even mid-week.
The service, notably attentive and charming, is a standout feature of Gallaghers. Waitstaff, like Xavier and Sean, are commended for their dedication to making each diner’s experience memorable. Attention to detail is evident in the care taken to provide high-quality cotton hand towels in the restrooms, adding to the overall impression of excellence.
The dessert offerings, such as crème brûlée and chocolate cake, round out the meal on a sweet note. The extensive dessert menu ensures there’s something to satisfy everyone’s cravings.
Gallaghers’ commitment to celebrating special occasions is evident in the attention and care they provide to guests celebrating anniversaries and birthdays. Personalized candles and thoughtful gestures, like glasses of champagne, create memorable moments for diners.
Overall, Gallaghers Steakhouse receives high praise for its exceptional dining experience, making it a must-visit destination for those looking to enjoy a memorable meal in Midtown NYC. The combination of outstanding steaks, attentive service, lively ambiance, and special touches sets Gallaghers apart as a top-tier steakhouse.
Address: 228 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 11:45 AM
Menu: gallaghersnysteakhouse.com
Reservations: opentable.com
Phone: +1 212-586-5000
Frankie & Johnnie’s Steakhouse
Frankie & Johnnie’s Steakhouse in Midtown NYC offers a delightful dining experience, making it a great choice for locals and visitors alike.
The reviews consistently highlight the fantastic service and delicious food at Frankie & Johnnie’s. Diners are impressed by the attentive and well-trained staff who ensure that every guest feels welcome and well-cared for. The accommodating service is especially appreciated by families, as the restaurant caters to all ages, even offering options for young ones like chicken tenders and butter noodles.
The menu at Frankie & Johnnie’s is met with praise. From lobster appetizers to perfectly cooked steaks, the food is consistently described as delicious and well-prepared. The porterhouse veal chop and Chilean Sea bass are standout items, showcasing the restaurant’s ability to cater to various palates. The au poivre sauce, onion strings, and asparagus are also commended for their taste and quality.
The ambiance at Frankie & Johnnie’s is noted for its old-school charm, with classic star photos adorning the walls. The atmosphere is described as both classy and relaxed, making it a comfortable setting for diners. The restaurant’s clean and well-presented interior adds to the overall appeal.
Despite a slow start with the bread, diners find themselves enjoying an array of delectable dishes. The corn bisque is described as phenomenal, while the lamb chops and steak sandwiches are cooked to perfection. The staff, exemplified by servers like Rukshandra, is professional and attentive, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Frankie & Johnnie’s is recognized for being a reliable choice for a pre-theater meal, with service that keeps guests on schedule for their shows. The location is convenient for theatergoers, and the restaurant offers a well-timed dining experience.
In summary, Frankie & Johnnie’s Steakhouse is celebrated for its great food, exceptional service, classic ambiance, and its ability to cater to both families and theater enthusiasts. It consistently delivers a memorable dining experience, making it a top choice for those looking for a delicious meal in Midtown NYC.
Address: 32 W 37th St, New York, NY 10018, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 12 PM
Menu: fj37.square.site
Reservations: opentable.com
Phone: +1 212-947-8940
212 Steakhouse
212 Steakhouse in Midtown NYC offers a top-notch dining experience with its exceptional food and attentive service.
Customers consistently praise the quality of the food, especially the steak and pasta dishes. Despite being on the high end in terms of pricing, the generous portions and outstanding presentation justify the cost. Diners commend the Wagyu Ribeye and Halal Ribeye for their exceptional flavor and tenderness, making them stand out as some of the best steaks they’ve ever had. Other menu items like oysters and lobster also receive high praise.
The restaurant’s ambiance may initially seem subdued, but this does not detract from the overall experience. The elegant interior, attentive staff, and exceptional dishes make up for any initial reservations. The establishment’s atmosphere is noted as fitting for various occasions, including special celebrations.
Service is a highlight at 212 Steakhouse, with patrons describing the staff as friendly, attentive, and professional. Waitstaff are quick to address any issues, such as a steak not being cooked to the desired doneness, ensuring that guests are well taken care of.
The restaurant’s drink offerings, including cocktails and wine selections, are well-received and complement the meal perfectly.
212 Steakhouse is recognized for creating a wonderful dining atmosphere with its impeccable service, delicious food, and inviting decor. Whether it’s a special occasion or an impromptu dinner, this establishment consistently delivers an enjoyable and memorable experience for its patrons.
Address: 316 E 53rd St, New York, NY 10022, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 12 PM
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Reservations: opentable.com
Order: doordash.com
Phone: +1 212-858-0646
Mastro’s Steakhouse
Mastro’s Steakhouse in Midtown NYC stands out as a top-tier dining establishment among the city’s many high-quality steakhouses.
The restaurant’s stylish decor and great ambiance create the perfect setting for an exceptional dining experience. Customers appreciate the attention to detail, from the elegant interior to the impeccable service.
Rachel, one of the attentive servers, receives accolades for her friendliness and helpful suggestions. Diners are impressed with the high level of service they receive at Mastro’s.
The restaurant’s food is nothing short of perfection. The prawn cocktail is highlighted by its dramatic presentation with billowing dry ice. Lobster bisque and juicy, tender steaks, such as the chef’s cut ribeye and filet mignon, are some of the standout dishes. The sides, including lobster mash and sautéed asparagus, complement the steaks perfectly.
While the restaurant caters to those with specific dietary preferences like halal, it also offers a wide range of options for seafood lovers, as evidenced by the lobster tail and oyster offerings.
Mastro’s attention to detail even extends to special occasions, such as anniversaries, with personalized touches like candles and greetings on desserts.
The only minor hiccup in one review was a delay in receiving the check, which made guests late for a show. However, this seems to be an isolated incident and did not detract significantly from the overall experience.
In conclusion, Mastro’s Steakhouse consistently delivers top-tier service and a dining experience to remember. From the phenomenal food to the attentive servers, it’s no wonder that Mastro’s is considered a must-visit in New York City, especially for special occasions and celebrations.
Address: 1285 6th Ave, New York, NY 10019, United States
Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 12 PM
Menu: mastrosrestaurants.com
Reservations: landrysinc.com
Phone: +1 212-459-1222
