Reviews of the 10 Best Steakhouses in Milwaukee

5/5 - (2 votes)

Milwaukee, Wisconsin, also known as the “Cream City” and “Brewtown,” is a haven for carnivores. Whether you’re a seasoned steak enthusiast or simply seeking a memorable dining experience, Milwaukee boasts a sizzling selection of steakhouses to tantalize your taste buds. From classic chophouses to modern interpretations of the genre, this article curates the 10 best steakhouses in Milwaukee, offering insights into their signature cuts, delectable sides, and inviting atmospheres. We’ll delve into details like menu options, service quality, and price range to help you choose the perfect spot for your next celebratory dinner, romantic rendezvous, or casual get-together. So, grab your fork and prepare to explore the best steakhouses that Milwaukee has to offer.

The 10 best steakhouses in Milwaukee an some reviews

1. Rare Steakhouse

Rare Steakhouse in Milwaukee consistently impresses patrons with its combination of upscale ambiance, delectable cuisine, and attentive service. Located in downtown Milwaukee, it’s a perfect spot for special occasions or a memorable night out. The cozy booths and street view provide a comfortable setting for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal. Customer reviews highlight the knowledgeable and friendly staff, with shoutouts to servers like Raj and Ian for their exceptional service.

Rare Steakhouse doesn’t disappoint in the culinary department either. The menu offers a variety of options, but it’s the steaks that steal the show. The Bottleneck Steak, a lean ribeye center cut, has garnered praise for its firm texture and remarkable flavor. Meanwhile, the dry-aged KC bone-in strip steak and Wagyu steak are described as melt-in-your-mouth experiences. Accompaniments like Lobster Mac & Cheese and delicious appetizers like crab cakes and a cheese board elevate the dining experience.

reviews Rare Steakhouse in Milwaukee : best steakhouses in Milwaukee
reviews Rare Steakhouse in Milwaukee

It’s worth noting that Rare Steakhouse also shines during special occasions, as seen during Thanksgiving and anniversary celebrations. The special three-course menu for Thanksgiving received high marks, with patrons raving about the beet salad, butternut squash soup, and pumpkin cheesecake. For anniversaries and birthdays, the staff goes above and beyond to make the experience memorable.

The drinks, including craft cocktails, are consistently well-made and reasonably priced during happy hour, making it an enticing spot for pre-dinner drinks and appetizers. Rare Steakhouse also boasts an extensive wine list, adding to the overall sophistication of the dining experience.

While Rare Steakhouse is undeniably a higher-end establishment, patrons appreciate the value they receive for the quality of food, service, and ambiance. Whether it’s a romantic dinner, a celebration with friends, or a special occasion, Rare Steakhouse in Milwaukee consistently delivers a memorable and delightful dining experience. So, if you’re willing to splurge a bit for an extraordinary steakhouse experience in Milwaukee, Rare Steakhouse is an excellent choice.

Address: 833 E Michigan St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

Hours: Closes soon ⋅ 10 PM ⋅ Opens 4 PM Sat

Menu: raresteaks.com

Reservations: opentable.com

Order: toasttab.com

Phone: +1 414-273-7273

2. Five O’Clock Steakhouse

Five O’Clock Steakhouse in Milwaukee has earned its reputation as a top-notch dining destination, consistently delivering exceptional service and exquisite cuisine. From the moment you step through the doors, you’re greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, reminiscent of Milwaukee’s classic supper club era.

Customer reviews repeatedly praise the attentive service, with standout mentions of servers like Dona, Eric, Wally, and Crystal, who enhance the dining experience with their knowledge and friendly demeanor. Their dedication to making your meal memorable is evident, from start to finish.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show – the steaks. The filet mignon is described as the best many patrons have ever had, while the bone-in fillet receives praise for being superb and leaving diners wanting more. These steaks are prepared to perfection, creating a mouthwatering, caramelized outer layer that’s irresistible.

reviews Five O'Clock Steakhouse in Milwaukee
reviews Five O’Clock Steakhouse in Milwaukee

Complementing the steaks are a range of sides that elevate the meal. The creamed spinach is hot, creamy, and full of flavor. The house-made desserts, particularly the tiramisu, leave a lasting impression, and the fully loaded mashed potatoes, asparagus, green beans, and crab mac ‘n’ cheese all receive praise.

Five O’Clock Steakhouse pays attention to the little details that make a big difference. The relish tray and homemade bread set the tone for a memorable meal. The Brandy Old Fashioned drinks at the bar are a perfect way to start your evening.

While the salad may have disappointed some due to its simplicity, the homemade dressings are a redeeming feature, and other options like green beans and mashed potatoes are recommended for a more satisfying experience.

As for the price, it’s clear that Five O’Clock Steakhouse offers value for the quality of food and service provided. It’s a place where you can celebrate special occasions, enjoy a night out with friends, or savor a classic Wisconsin supper club experience. So, if you’re a steak lover looking for an unforgettable dining experience in Milwaukee, Five O’Clock Steakhouse is undoubtedly a top choice.

Address: 2416 W State St, Milwaukee, WI 53233, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4:30 PM Sat

Menu: fiveoclocksteakhouse.com

Reservations: opentable.com

Phone: +1 414-342-3553

3. The Milwaukee Steakhouse

The Milwaukee Steakhouse is a true gem in the city, offering a dining experience that consistently exceeds expectations. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving an outstanding meal, this establishment stands out for its superb food and exceptional service.

Customer reviews repeatedly emphasize the high quality of both the food and the service. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with friendly bartenders and reasonably priced cocktails, setting the stage for a memorable evening. The attention to detail is evident, from the relish tray to the warm bread with honey butter, ensuring that every aspect of your meal is delightful.

See also  The 12 best restaurants in Cayman islands

Steaks take center stage here, and patrons rave about their quality. The charred steaks, cooked at 1000 degrees, are a standout feature, and the bone-in filet receives special mention as a must-try. The French Onion soup is a perfect pre-steak appetizer, and the prime rib, especially on Thursdays and Saturdays, is a crowd-pleaser.

reviews The Milwaukee Steakhouse in Milwaukee
reviews The Milwaukee Steakhouse in Milwaukee

What sets Milwaukee Steakhouse apart is its inclusive pricing. Each meal includes a potato and a choice of soup or salad, a detail that diners appreciate in comparison to other upscale steakhouses. This, along with the pride and passion of the owner, servers, and cooks, guarantees an impressive dining experience.

The staff, including servers like Darcy, Morgan, Debbie, and Julie, consistently go above and beyond to make diners feel welcome and ensure they have a memorable time. Their knowledge and efficiency add to the overall enjoyment of the meal.

While the focus is on steaks, the Milwaukee Steakhouse also impresses with its crablegs, lobster, and other offerings for seafood enthusiasts. The extensive menu ensures that there’s something to please every palate.

The Milwaukee Steakhouse may not be the cheapest option, but patrons agree that it’s worth every penny. If you’re looking for a place that delivers on quality, flavor, and service, this establishment is a top choice. So, whether you’re a local looking for a go-to steakhouse or a visitor in search of a fantastic meal, the Milwaukee Steakhouse is sure to leave you satisfied and eager to return for another memorable dining experience.

Address: 6024 W Bluemound Rd, Milwaukee, WI 53213, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4 PM

Takeout: 10 AM–9 PM · More hours

Menu: places.singleplatform.com

Order: toasttab.com

Phone: +1 414-312-7891

4. Carnevor

Carnevor in Milwaukee is undeniably a top-notch dining destination, offering an extraordinary atmosphere and culinary experience that consistently impresses patrons. From the moment you step inside, the ambiance is warm, inviting, and exudes a sense of sophistication.

Customer reviews highlight the exceptional quality of both the food and the service. The menu boasts a wide array of delights, from oysters and ribeyes to lobster tails and mac and cheese with lobster. Each dish is executed to perfection, showcasing the culinary expertise of the kitchen staff. The bacon-bourbon appetizer and steak tartare receive special mentions for their outstanding flavors.

The steaks at Carnevor are a true standout, cooked to perfection and seasoned beautifully. Whether you opt for the filet, ribeye, or New York strip, you can expect a memorable steakhouse experience. The herbed garlic butter topping adds an extra layer of flavor that’s simply divine.

reviews Carnevor in Milwaukee
reviews Carnevor in Milwaukee

The attention to detail extends to the sides as well, with truffle fries, steamed spinach, and more making for delightful complements to your meal. The wine list, featuring over 700 different wines, ensures that there’s a perfect pairing for every taste.

The service is consistently excellent, with servers like Eric, Diana, and Ali going above and beyond to create a memorable dining experience. Personal touches, such as a personalized birthday card and friendly, knowledgeable service, enhance the overall experience.

While the ambiance of Carnevor is unique and reminiscent of a wine cellar, it can get quite loud, especially when there are large groups nearby. However, this minor inconvenience doesn’t deter diners from returning for the exceptional food and wine.

In summary, Carnevor in Milwaukee is a culinary gem that offers not only outstanding food but also an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, looking for a perfect steak, or simply seeking a fine dining experience, Carnevor consistently delivers and leaves patrons eager to return for more.

Address: 718 N Milwaukee St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 5 PM

Menu: places.singleplatform.com

Reservations: opentable.com

Phone: +1 414-223-2200

5. Ward’s House of Prime

Ward’s House of Prime in Milwaukee is an exceptional dining establishment that consistently impresses its patrons with its superb service and delectable cuisine. From the moment you step through the door, you’re greeted with warm and attentive service that makes you feel like the only table in the house, despite the restaurant’s bustling atmosphere.

The prime rib at Ward’s House of Prime is the star of the show, and it’s prepared to perfection. Reviewers praise its tenderness, flavor, and quality, with some patrons even calling it the best prime rib they’ve ever had. The range of sizes offered ensures that everyone can enjoy this culinary delight. The creamy horseradish and mild au jus complement the prime rib perfectly, enhancing the dining experience.

The menu offers a variety of options, from filets and seafood to double-baked potatoes and lobster bisque. Even if you’re not a prime rib enthusiast, you’re sure to find something to satisfy your palate. The sides, including caramelized Brussels sprouts and twice-baked potatoes, receive their fair share of compliments.

Ward's House of Prime
Ward’s House of Prime

The service at Ward’s House of Prime is consistently praised for its attentiveness and knowledge. Servers like Tim, Jenny, and Emily D. ensure that every diner feels welcome and informed about the menu. The ambiance is described as both romantic and inviting, making it a popular choice for special occasions.

Desserts, like the decadent chocolate cake and pistachio creme brulee, provide a sweet ending to the meal, leaving diners with fond memories of their dining experience.

Despite the minor challenge of parking, the consensus among reviewers is that the food, service, and overall experience at Ward’s House of Prime make it well worth the effort. It’s a destination for prime rib lovers and anyone seeking an unforgettable dining experience in Milwaukee.

See also  Reviews 10 Best Steakhouses in Detroit

Address: 540 E Mason St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4 PM

Menu: wardshouseofprime.com

Reservations: opentable.com

Phone: +1 414-223-0135

6. Mo’s A Place For Steaks

Mo’s A Place For Steaks in Milwaukee stands out as a premier dining destination, and its reputation is well-deserved. This restaurant has consistently impressed patrons with its exceptional service, inviting atmosphere, and outstanding cuisine.

Upon entering, you’ll immediately notice the warm and welcoming atmosphere, which sets the stage for a memorable dining experience. The attentive and knowledgeable staff, from the host to the servers, ensures that your visit is nothing short of outstanding. Special occasions are celebrated with care, and the personalized touch adds to the overall charm.

The star of the show at Mo’s is undoubtedly the steak. Reviewers rave about the perfectly cooked cuts, such as the Wagyu steak and the filet mignon, which are described as tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. The sides, including the Lobster Mac & Cheese, creamed corn, and baked potatoes, enhance the meal and leave diners thoroughly satisfied.

reviews Mo’s...A Place for Steaks in Milwaukee
reviews Mo’s…A Place for Steaks in Milwaukee

While the focus is on steak, Mo’s offers a variety of options for all tastes, including seafood dishes like salmon and shrimp cocktail. The lobster bisque and calamari appetizer receive high praise as well.

The bar area, complete with a piano, adds to the nostalgic ambiance and makes for an enjoyable pre-dinner experience. The drink selection, including wine and specialty cocktails, is diverse and complements the meal perfectly.

While Mo’s A Place For Steaks is known for its high-quality cuisine, it is acknowledged that it comes at a price. However, patrons unanimously agree that the exceptional food and service make it well worth the cost. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an unforgettable meal in Milwaukee, Mo’s is a must-visit destination.

Address: 720 N Plankinton Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53203, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 5 PM

Menu: mosaplaceforsteaks.com

Reservations: mosaplaceforsteaks.com

Order: toasttab.com

Phone: +1 414-272-0720

7. Milwaukee ChopHouse

The Milwaukee ChopHouse is undoubtedly a gem in the city’s dining scene, offering an exquisite dining experience that exceeds expectations on all fronts.

From the moment you step inside, the staff at the ChopHouse sets the tone for a memorable evening. Their attentiveness and professionalism make you feel truly valued. The restaurant’s comfortable yet refined setting strikes the perfect balance, providing an atmosphere that is neither overly elegant nor too casual.

When it comes to the menu, the ChopHouse delivers outstanding cuisine that leaves a lasting impression. The seafood bisque and diver scallops are hailed as decadent, with the bisque described as deliciously velvety. The high-quality steaks, prepared to perfection, are a highlight. Reviewers particularly commend the filet mignon for its tenderness and flavor.

Milwaukee ChopHouse
Milwaukee ChopHouse

The sides, including the brussel sprouts and a trio of sides, are crafted to complement the main dishes impeccably. And if you have room for dessert, the crème brûlée is the perfect way to conclude your meal.

Beyond the food, it’s the service that truly shines at the Milwaukee ChopHouse. Servers like Terri and Josue are praised for their attentiveness, knowledge, and courtesy. They ensure that your dining experience is flawless, offering recommendations and accommodating special occasions. Even in the midst of a busy evening, they go above and beyond to make your visit exceptional.

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking an outstanding dining experience, the Milwaukee ChopHouse is a must-visit destination. Its combination of exceptional food, attentive service, and inviting ambiance makes it a top choice for those seeking an unforgettable meal in Milwaukee.

Address: 633 N 5th St, Milwaukee, WI 53203, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 5 PM

Menu: milwaukeechophouse.com

Reservations: opentable.com

Phone: +1 414-226-2467

8. Dream Dance Steakhouse

Dream Dance Steakhouse is a hidden gem nestled within the Potawatomi Casino, offering a dining experience that is truly a cut above the rest.

Upon entering, the restaurant provides a welcome escape from the hustle and bustle of the casino, with a serene ambiance that sets the stage for an unforgettable meal. The staff here truly understand the art of hospitality, making each guest feel special. Reviews highlight the attentive and friendly service, with servers like Elbin and William earning praise for their top-tier customer service.

The culinary journey at Dream Dance begins with a tantalizing array of appetizers, from the indulgent cheese curd fritters to the delectable shrimp cocktail. The attention to detail in presentation and taste is apparent in every dish.

Dream Dance Steakhouse
Dream Dance Steakhouse

The stars of the show, the steaks, are seasoned to perfection and cooked to your liking. The filet mignon, in particular, receives glowing reviews for its flavor and tenderness. Guests appreciate the three sauce options that accompany the steak, enhancing the overall dining experience. The generous portion sizes ensure you leave satisfied.

Accompaniments like the button mushrooms and the sharing of sides like crab legs showcase the restaurant’s commitment to providing a well-rounded and luxurious meal.

Dream Dance Steakhouse also offers an impressive wine list, catering to wine enthusiasts who seek the perfect pairing for their meal.

To top off your dining experience, the dessert offerings, including the creme brûlée, are described as a sweet and satisfying conclusion to your meal.

Despite its location in a casino, Dream Dance Steakhouse manages to create a refined and peaceful dining atmosphere. The restaurant is perfect for special occasions, date nights, or simply a memorable evening out.

See also  Reviews of the 10 best steakhouses in Columbus Ohio

In summary, Dream Dance Steakhouse is a culinary oasis within Potawatomi Casino, where impeccable service, exquisite cuisine, and a serene setting come together to create a dining experience that is truly worth savoring.

Address: 1721 W Canal St, Milwaukee, WI 53233, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4 PM

Menu: paysbig.com

Reservations: paysbig.com

Phone: +1 414-847-7883

9. Mason Street Grill

Mason Street Grill in Milwaukee stands out as a culinary gem, consistently delivering an exceptional dining experience that keeps patrons returning for more.

From the moment you walk through the door, you’re greeted with warmth and professionalism. Cesar, our server, and the team behind the scenes, including Kam and Sous Chef Sasha, ensure that the service is nothing short of perfection.

The menu offers a tantalizing array of options, each dish meticulously crafted and brimming with flavor. The seafood cocktail, featuring mixed seafood in a zesty lemony dressing, showcases the kitchen’s dedication to excellence. The filet mignon, prepared with a three-step process that includes lemon zest and brown butter, is described as perfection itself. Guests rave about the generous portion sizes, perfectly seasoned steaks, and the delightful trio of sauces.

The side dishes, like the truffle creamed spinach and Delmonico potatoes, are generously portioned, often serving two or more. The mac n’ cheese with bacon is highly recommended and regarded as one of the best.

Mason Street Grill
Mason Street Grill

Mason Street Grill also boasts an impressive drink menu. Whether you’re a wine enthusiast or prefer a cocktail, you’re sure to find the perfect libation to complement your meal.

The restaurant’s atmosphere exudes elegance and refinement, making it an ideal setting for special occasions or a sophisticated night out. Jazz enthusiasts appreciate the live music adding to the overall ambiance.

Mason Street Grill’s attention to detail extends to dessert, with offerings like the chocolate dessert being a sweet ending to a memorable dining experience.

The staff’s attentiveness is commendable, ensuring that guests feel welcome and attended to without being overbearing. The restaurant’s staff, from the hostess to the servers, are praised for their friendly and professional service.

In conclusion, Mason Street Grill proves itself as a standout dining establishment in Milwaukee. With impeccable service, a delectable menu, and a warm and inviting ambiance, it consistently earns its place as a top choice for discerning diners. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking for an exceptional meal, Mason Street Grill delivers on all fronts.

Address: 425 E Mason St, Milwaukee, WI 53202, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 4 PM

Menu: masonstreetgrill.com

Reservations: masonstreetgrill.com

Phone: +1 414-298-3131

10. The Packing House

The Packing House in Milwaukee, a cherished establishment with a rich history, continues to shine as a culinary destination known for its exceptional food and warm atmosphere.

Located conveniently near the airport, the restaurant boasts a well-maintained and spacious parking lot, making it accessible for patrons. The inviting outdoor patio with a fireplace provides a cozy and sheltered ambiance, despite the bustling street nearby.

As you step inside, you’re greeted by the resplendent lounge area, exuding an art deco charm with elegant wood accents and mirrors. The atmosphere is further enhanced by the nostalgic tunes from the ’50s and ’60s, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.

The bar is staffed by skilled bartenders who can craft classic cocktails, like the Negroni, with expertise. The well-curated wine list and a variety of drink options cater to all preferences.

Seated at a round table in a corner, our group of eight was pleasantly surprised by the attentive and friendly staff. The lunch menu, though not extensive, offers something for every palate. The food is skillfully prepared, with the turkey rice soup being a highlight. While one diner required more marinara sauce, the staff promptly accommodated the request. The steak options are renowned for their perfection, while the fries are celebrated as some of the best.

The Packing House
The Packing House

However, the stars of the show are the desserts. The banana cream pie and tiramisu are heavenly creations that delight the palate.

The Packing House is a go-to choice for holiday celebrations, as the impeccable service, drinks, appetizers, entrees, and desserts consistently impress. The roast duck is succulent, the steaks are cooked to perfection, and the banana cream pie is a must-try.

Service stands out as exceptional, with attentive waitstaff ensuring a memorable dining experience. Even though the dining room can get busy, the staff’s efficiency and friendliness shine through.

One diner commends the restaurant for its detailed approach to food preparation, describing the food as well-prepared and delicious. From the flavorful steaks to the succulent roast duck, The Packing House maintains its reputation for quality.

A variety of menu options cater to different tastes, from meats to fish, and each dish is a testament to the restaurant’s commitment to excellence. For dessert, the creme brulee and banana cream pie are divine options.

In conclusion, The Packing House in Milwaukee remains a cherished culinary destination for locals and visitors alike. With its superb service, meticulously crafted dishes, and timeless ambiance, it consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply savoring a meal out, The Packing House is a top choice that never disappoints.

Address: 900 E Layton Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207, United States

Hours: Closed ⋅ Opens 3:30 PM

Menu: packinghousemke.com

Phone: +1 414-483-5054