Reviews of the 10 Best Steakhouses in Rochester NY

5/5 - (1 vote)
When it comes to savoring the finest cuts of succulent beef and indulging in an unparalleled dining experience, discerning palates seek out the 10 best steakhouses in Rochester NY. Known for its rich culinary scene, Rochester boasts a myriad of dining options, but only a select few establishments have mastered the art of delivering impeccable steaks that tantalize taste buds and leave patrons craving more. From classic ambiance to innovative culinary techniques, the quest to uncover the top ten Steakhouse gems in Rochester promises a journey through flavor, sophistication, and unmatched quality.

Reviews of the 10 best steakhouses in Rochester NY

1. The Capital Grille 

The Capital Grille in the Chicago Suburbs isn’t just a restaurant; it’s an epitome of unparalleled dining experiences, seamlessly blending exceptional cuisine, impeccable service, and an inviting ambiance. Stepping into the 40’s room, a haven for those seeking a tranquil yet sophisticated setting, we were immediately embraced by the warmth exuded by our server, Mike. His profound knowledge of both wine and the menu was evident, guiding us through a gastronomic adventure that was nothing short of extraordinary.
Our culinary expedition commenced with a delectable assortment—the calamari, a delightful prelude, and the field green salad, a fresh symphony of flavors. The Wagyu beef special, accompanied by a medley of mushrooms, was a masterpiece in itself, tantalizing our taste buds with its succulence. Pairing this culinary delight with the Stonecreek cab was a stroke of genius, accentuating the flavors to perfection. It’s no surprise that each course was served with a keen understanding of our pace, a testament to Mike’s attentive and considerate service.
The restaurant’s excellence goes beyond the dishes; it lies in the attentive gestures and professionalism exemplified by the staff. Mike, our waiter, was not merely a server but a maestro orchestrating an unforgettable dining experience. His adeptness in suggesting the finest offerings and his amiable nature added a layer of warmth that enhanced our evening.
Moreover, The Capital Grille’s bar-to-table service was exemplary, ensuring a seamless transition between each stage of our meal, making our evening a gastronomic delight. From the Long Island iced teas to the impeccably prepared steaks and chops, every aspect was meticulously crafted to perfection.
The Capital Grille - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
The Capital Grille – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
We mustn’t forget to extend our gratitude to Adam, who made our celebratory evening for our 40th wedding anniversary and an 80th birthday an absolute dream. The on-the-bone steak was a culmination of flavors, perfectly cooked to our preference, and complemented the exquisite atmosphere, fostering a truly romantic and unforgettable experience. The management and staff’s efforts in making us feel cherished added an extra layer of delight to an already stellar evening.
In conclusion, The Capital Grille in the Chicago Suburbs isn’t just a dining destination; it’s a sanctuary where exceptional cuisine, impeccable service, and an inviting ambiance converge to create unforgettable memories. Whether for a quiet evening or a celebratory occasion, The Capital Grille, coupled with its outstanding staff like Mike and Adam, continues to set the bar high for exquisite dining experiences.
Located in: College Town Rochester
Address: 22 Celebration Dr, Rochester, NY 14620, United States
Phone: +1 585-471-6333

2. Black & Blue 

Venturing into Black & Blue in the Chicago Suburbs promises an exploration of American cuisine with a modern twist, an experience that leaves a lasting impression. This restaurant captivates with its phenomenal fare, extensive menu, and generous portions that tantalize taste buds while leaving patrons impressed by the friendly and hardworking staff.
Black & Blue - - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Black & Blue – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Upon arrival, the accommodating service swiftly seated us, and our host, Justin, warmly introduced us to the menu, setting the stage for a delightful culinary journey. The array of offerings, including the salmon, half rack of lamb, crab soup, and the off-menu but delectable lobster mac n cheese, showcased the kitchen’s prowess. Each dish was artfully prepared, highlighting the precision in Cooking and the flavorsome creativity of the chef.
The lamb, complemented by two specialty sauces, stood out for its succulence, while the perfectly cooked salmon and the rich flavors of the lobster mac were undeniable highlights. Despite our satiated state, the desserts beckoned and did not disappoint; they were a delightful conclusion to our feast, leaving us yearning for future visits.
Black & Blue prides itself on being accommodating, offering vegetarian options and modifications to cater to individual preferences. The restaurant’s wheelchair accessibility and the provision of ample, free parking further enhance its appeal, ensuring a seamless and convenient dining experience for all guests.
However, amidst the culinary brilliance, minor discomfort arose from the seating, with chairs that did not meet expectations in comfort—a negligible flaw in an otherwise exceptional establishment.
The ambiance, highlighted by an impressive wine selection and a decent array of whiskeys, along with perfectly prepared steaks and seafood, makes Black & Blue an ideal choice for both business meetings and celebrations. The professional and hospitable staff further elevate the dining experience, ensuring every visit leaves behind cherished memories.
While our anniversary celebration at Black & Blue was marked by a timely table, complimentary champagne, and honest guidance from servers, it’s important to note the mild disappointment with the somewhat lackluster flavor of the lobster, despite the exceptional quality of other dishes. Yet, the overall experience at this upscale restaurant undeniably warrants a return, albeit reserved for special occasions due to the higher price point.
In summary, Black & Blue in the Chicago Suburbs stands tall as an establishment delivering exceptional modern American cuisine, offering a memorable dining escapade marked by delectable dishes, attentive service, and an ambiance suited for celebrations and cherished moments.
Located in: Pittsford Plaza
Address: 3349 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14618, United States
Phone: +1 585-421-8111

3. Texas Roadhouse 

Nestled in the Chicago Suburbs, Texas Roadhouse holds a special place in the hearts of many, drawing patrons back time and again for its delectable steaks and inviting atmosphere. As we stepped in just before the midday rush on a Saturday, we were greeted with a calm ambiance, perfect for savoring their renowned fare without the bustling crowds.
Texas Roadhouse - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Texas Roadhouse – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
The journey began with tantalizing ‘bites’ that set the tone for an exceptional dining experience. Our choice of dishes ranged from mouthwatering steaks with chips and beans to sumptuous lobster tails and savory ribs paired with sides that left us pleasantly satiated. The servings were generous, and the flavors, a testament to the chef’s mastery, were simply outstanding. It’s no surprise that we ended up taking home some leftovers; the portions were as abundant as they were delicious.
Returning on subsequent occasions proved to be a recurring theme for us, drawn back by the appeal of the quiet ambiance, friendly servers, and, most importantly, the consistently delightful dishes. The option to take a drink away added an extra touch of convenience, a feature not commonly found elsewhere, making Texas Roadhouse stand out among other dining choices in the area.
While our experiences were largely positive, one visit on a Saturday night brought us face-to-face with a bustling atmosphere filled with families and kids. Despite the lively ambiance, the clever booth designs ensured a semblance of privacy, allowing us to enjoy our meals undisturbed.
The exceptional service, highlighted by the attentiveness of the servers, added to the overall charm of Texas Roadhouse. On one occasion, during our daughter’s birthday celebration, the staff’s thoughtful gesture of singing and presenting her with a sweet treat made the evening truly memorable.
Consistency seemed to be the hallmark of this establishment, evident in the quality of their offerings and the warm, welcoming atmosphere. Even on a busy night, the wait for a table was reasonable, and the experience remained consistent in delivering delightful meals, reinforcing our loyalty to this chain.
While minor drawbacks included occasional scarcity of certain menu items and the restaurant’s tendency to get loud during peak hours, the reliability of the food quality and the attentive service continue to draw us back to Texas Roadhouse, ensuring that it remains a favored destination for those seeking consistently excellent steaks and a hospitable dining experience.
Located in: Ridgemont plaza
Address: 3065 W Ridge Rd, Rochester, NY 14626, United States
Phone: +1 585-441-0100

4. Nosh 

Located in the heart of the Chicago Suburbs, Nosh invites diners on a flavorful journey filled with culinary creativity and modern elegance. Our visit to this vibrant establishment left a lasting impression, delivering a dining experience that was nothing short of exceptional.
Booking a table was a breeze through their user-friendly online system, and even when our plans shifted, the accommodating front desk swiftly adjusted our reservation. Upon arrival, the warm welcome from the staff set the tone for a delightful evening. We were promptly seated and introduced to a courteous and efficient server who guided us through the menu.
Nosh - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Nosh – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
The standout feature of Nosh undoubtedly lies in its tantalizing array of dishes. The bone marrow and beef skewers were highly recommended and rightfully so; the freshness of the ingredients paired with perfect seasoning left our taste buds in awe. Despite generous portion sizes that surpassed our expectations, the flavors were so captivating that we couldn’t resist taking some leftovers back to our hotel. Even upon reheating, the food retained its deliciousness, a testament to its quality.
While the pace of service seemed slightly slow due to the bustling nature of the restaurant, it was evident that the popularity was well-deserved. The K-chop and Pollo Loco showcased the kitchen’s innovation, offering unique flavor combinations that delighted our palates. Additionally, the fresh ingredients in the pizza received high praise from our friends.
Our server, Mickayla, deserves commendation for her friendly demeanor and insightful recommendations, making our dining experience even more enjoyable. The cocktail selection, boasting diverse flavor profiles, perfectly complemented the delectable entrees and was reasonably priced.
The atmosphere exuded an industrial chic vibe, contributing to a lively ambiance that might be a tad loud for intimate conversations but ideal for a vibrant night out with friends or group dinners. Their Instagram, adorned with enticing menu photos, serves as a delightful preview of the culinary delights awaiting patrons.
For vegetarians, a separate full menu caters to diverse dietary preferences, enhancing the inclusivity of the dining experience. Parking is convenient with a free lot adjacent to the restaurant and ample street parking.
In conclusion, Nosh captivates with its creative cuisine, welcoming staff, and chic ambiance. It’s a culinary gem that stands out for its innovative dishes, making it a must-visit spot for those seeking a memorable dining adventure in the Chicago Suburbs. Whether indulging in ahi tuna nachos or exploring their vegetarian offerings, Nosh is a haven for food enthusiasts seeking quality, creativity, and a delightful dining atmosphere.
Address: 47 Russell St, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
Phone: +1 585-445-8700

5. Mac’s Philly Steaks 

Nestled in the heart of the Chicago Suburbs, Mac’s Philly Steaks stands as the ultimate destination for those craving the quintessential Philly cheesesteak experience. Seeking the best steak subs for my son’s birthday, we stumbled upon this gem, and it turned out to be a delightful discovery.
As someone not particularly fond of steak subs, I found myself surprised and thoroughly satisfied after devouring a 4-inch sub. The quality of the ingredients, from the thinly sliced real chopped steak to the perfectly melted cheese and flavorful peppers, elevated this sandwich to unparalleled heights. Even my son’s girlfriend, opting for the 8-inch sub, regretted not getting a larger size, a testament to the deliciousness that satisfied everyone’s cravings.
Mac's Philly Steaks - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Mac’s Philly Steaks – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
What sets Mac’s Philly apart is its commitment to authenticity and quality. Their subs are massive, delectable, and reasonably priced, ensuring that customers get real value for their money. The use of real chopped steak rather than fake substitutes results in a flavorsome delight that’s hard to resist. Typically, my husband can finish a whole sub elsewhere, but here, half a sub is more than enough to leave us pleasantly full.
The only downside is the limited operating hours, which can be inconvenient for late workers like myself. However, the quality and taste of their offerings make it worth the effort to grab a bite before closing time. Despite occasional parking challenges in the plaza, Mac’s Philly remains the go-to place for authentic and sizable Philly cheesesteaks.
According to some notes, Mac’s Philly takes pride in their sandwiches, ensuring they are freshly made to order, capturing the essence of some of the freshest tastes in the Chicago Suburbs. The added touch of onions and extra cheese elevates the flavors to a whole new level, making it a top choice for any mealtime craving.
In conclusion, Mac’s Philly Steaks in the Chicago Suburbs is a haven for cheesesteak aficionados. Whether dining in or ordering to go, this establishment delivers on its promise of quality, freshness, and flavors that linger on the taste buds. Don’t miss the chance to indulge in this culinary experience that offers an awesome combination of taste, quality, and affordability.
Located in: Corn Hill Landing Apartments
Address: 298 Exchange Blvd, Rochester, NY 14608, United States
Phone: +1 585-232-1577

6. Good Luck 

Nestled within the Chicago Suburbs, Good Luck exudes an aura of culinary excellence, captivating diners with its impeccable attention to detail in cocktails, menu curation, and desserts. Our visit to this establishment was an amalgamation of exceptional flavors, though a slight oversight in seasoning was the only drawback, notably with the walnut pasta lacking a hint of salt. However, this minor setback was overshadowed by the sheer brilliance of the dining experience.
From delectable burgers to multiple salads, braised fennel, and the heavenly malloreddus, each dish epitomized culinary perfection. The house-made malloreddus, in particular, left an indelible mark—a dish worth savoring repeatedly.
Good Luck - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Good Luck – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Securing reservations well in advance is a must due to the restaurant’s popularity. The relatively unassuming entrance, marked only by a discreet plaque, leads to a haven of gastronomic delights. The menu, although stable, boasts a treasure trove of consistently delicious dishes, seamlessly transitioning from smaller appetizers to generously portioned entrees, perfectly suited for sharing tapas-style.
The cocktails at Good Luck are not to be missed. The peach, black tea, and violently citrus cocktails were a symphony of flavors, harmonizing with the Basque cheesecake to create an unforgettable dining experience.
During our visit, the offerings surpassed expectations. The burger, double chicken fries, duck breast, and ricotta sacchettoni were culinary marvels. The chicken, tender and flavorful, stood out as an absolute delight, closely followed by the perfectly executed duck and the tantalizing fries accompanied by the exquisite “fancy sauce,” a blend of ketchup, mayo, and brandy.
The homemade ice creams showcased unique flavors that tantalized the taste buds, culminating our meal on a sweet note.
The atmosphere exuded contemporary charm, complemented by professional yet friendly staff who delivered impeccable service. For those aiming for a pre-dinner drink, the craft cocktails and delectable appetizers are an enticing start to the evening.
The Good Luck burger, hailed as a culinary masterpiece, lives up to its reputation, cooked and seasoned to perfection, further accentuated by the iconic “fancy sauce,” a culinary delight that deserves accolades.
In summary, Good Luck is a culinary haven in the Chicago Suburbs, offering exceptional food, cocktails, and an inviting atmosphere that beckons diners for a delightful experience. With an array of dishes served family-style, this restaurant promises an opportunity to explore and savor an array of tantalizing flavors. A visit to Good Luck is a testament to the artistry of culinary excellence and remains a must-visit for discerning food enthusiasts seeking an extraordinary dining adventure.
Located in: Village Gate Square
Address: 50 Anderson Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
Phone: +1 585-340-6161

7. Rocco 

Tucked away in the heart of the Chicago Suburbs, Rocco is an absolute revelation, offering an exquisite culinary experience that surpasses expectations. From the moment you step into this intimate Italian bistro, the allure of exceptional service and delectable food invites you into a world of gastronomic delight.
The service at Rocco is nothing short of fantastic, elevating the dining experience to new heights. The intimate atmosphere, coupled with impeccable service, creates a warm and welcoming ambiance that resonates throughout. The squid dish, cooked to absolute perfection, emerged as a standout favorite among the offerings, setting the tone for an exceptional culinary journey.
Rocco - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Rocco – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
It’s important to note that the venue is on the smaller side, so individuals requiring additional accommodation for seating—whether due to size or accessibility needs—should request suitable arrangements beforehand.
The menu, although not overwhelming, boasts a delightful array of options that satisfy diverse palates. During our group dinner, the appetizers, main courses, and desserts impressed every diner, earning unanimous praise for their quality and flavor. The attentive yet unobtrusive service added to the overall enjoyment, making Rocco a cherished addition to our list of favored dining spots.
The Italian bistro ambiance exudes authenticity and charm, perfectly complemented by a stellar selection of cocktails. The Paulie G pizza comes highly recommended, showcasing the culinary expertise that defines Rocco’s offerings.
One of the highlights of our visit was the unpretentious yet authentically Italian dining experience. The grilled calamari, arancini, tri-color salad, crispy fish with butternut caponata, mushroom pizza, spaghetti with shrimp, and quail with Gorgonzola polenta—each dish presented a symphony of flavors that delighted the taste buds. The indulgence continued with a to-die-for butterscotch pudding that left a lasting impression, accompanied by a birthday candle to mark the occasion, a thoughtful touch that exemplifies the attention to detail at Rocco.
The homemade ricotta with charred bread emerged as a must-try starter, further enhancing the dining experience. With such culinary finesse on display, reservations are highly recommended to secure a table in this intimate setting unless the inviting bar area suits your preference.
In summary, Rocco is a treasure trove of authentic Italian cuisine, offering an unassuming yet rich culinary experience. Whether indulging in sumptuous dishes or savoring delightful cocktails, Rocco proves to be a haven for discerning food enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable dining escapade in the Chicago Suburbs.
Address: 165 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
Phone: +1 585-454-3510

8. Lento Restaurant 

Nestled within the charming confines of the Chicago Suburbs, Lento Restaurant stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, enchanting diners with its exquisite dishes and impeccable service. Upon stepping inside, the warm ambiance and exceptional flavors transport guests into a world of culinary delight.
Lento Restaurant - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Lento Restaurant – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
The menu at Lento beckons with its complexity, showcasing dishes that captivate even the most discerning palates. An unexpected joy was seeing a 16-month-old relishing the sweet pea ravioli, a testament to the restaurant’s ability to delight all ages. The duck fat fries emerged as a highlight—a symphony of flavors that arguably make them the finest fries one could savor. The lamb, too, was a flavorful triumph, showcasing the kitchen’s skill in crafting delectable dishes. A delightful finish awaited with the affogato, a heavenly blend of ice cream and coffee.
Noteworthy is their dedication to locally sourced ingredients and small-batch sodas, a testament to their commitment to quality and sustainability.
The service at Lento is exemplary, offering swift and attentive assistance. Their proficiency in accommodating dietary restrictions, except for soy, adds to the dining experience. The staff’s warmth and knowledge, especially regarding vegan options, contributed to an excellent meal.
Dollar oyster nights are a cherished tradition here, making reservations a necessity. The cozy atmosphere and the warm hospitality of the staff provide an inviting setting to relish their menu of locally sourced cuisine.
The vegan garam masala stands out among the many delightful dishes, joined by the steelhead trout with polenta, veggies, and a tempting scallop dish. Notably accommodating, Lento offers a gluten-free menu to cater to various dietary needs.
The unassuming entry may belie the elegance within, but once inside, guests are met with a welcoming ambiance and top-tier cuisine. From delectable charcuterie to fingerling sweet potatoes, scallops, duck, trout, and steak, each dish was a testament to the restaurant’s high culinary standards.
One guest’s experience, having stumbled upon this gem during a brief stay, encapsulates the sentiment shared by many. The delightful outdoor seating in the charming Village Gate Square, coupled with a delectable selection of dishes, left an indelible mark. Accompanied by a knowledgeable and attentive staff, the evening was nothing short of wonderful.
In summary, Lento Restaurant is a haven for gastronomy enthusiasts seeking a blend of exquisite flavors, exceptional service, and a commitment to sustainability. Whether relishing local fare or embracing vegan options, dining here promises an unforgettable culinary escapade in the heart of the Chicago Suburbs.
Located in: Village Gate Square
Address: 274 N Goodman St, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
Phone: +1 585-271-3470

9. Roux 

Nestled within the lively atmosphere of the University of Chicago campus in Hyde Park, Roux Diner emerges as an absolute culinary delight, beckoning diners with its Cajun-Creole inspired menu and inviting ambiance. Whether it’s brunch or a leisurely lunch, Roux has an undeniable allure that captivates visitors from the moment they step in.
Our brunch experience at Roux was an absolute delight. While waiting to explore the DuSable Museum, my wife savored the delightful biscuits with hot honey and a plate of beignets, while I indulged in a scrumptious feast comprising deviled eggs, grits, breakfast potatoes, and sourdough toast. Every dish showcased the kitchen’s prowess in delivering flavors that delighted the taste buds.
Roux - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Roux – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Despite the long line, the efficient service ensured a swift transition from ordering to being seated, offering a testament to the staff’s efficiency in managing the bustling crowd. The light, airy, and impeccably clean atmosphere added to the overall dining experience, highlighted by the use of cloth napkins and real dishes that enhance the ambiance.
The standout chicken and waffles, although not quite reminiscent of the New Orleans standard, offered a satisfying Northern twist to this classic dish. The counter-order system expedited service, ensuring our meals were promptly delivered to the table, allowing us to bask in the great atmosphere Roux had to offer.
Lunch was an equally delightful affair, with an array of delectable options. A colleague and I relished a sumptuous meal—eggs, sausage, grits, and a delectable biscuit for me, while she savored a generous portion of fried catfish, both dishes exceeding our expectations in both taste and portion size.
Roux Diner received a glowing recommendation and rightfully so. Its bright, cheerful space coupled with a Cajun-Creole menu that caters to all tastes ensures a remarkable dining experience. The warm welcome, comfortable seating, and fantastic food made for a memorable holiday celebration, fostering an ambiance perfect for gatherings.
The dining experience at Roux was so delightful that it left an indelible impression, prompting the desire for a return visit for a serving of their tantalizing beignets. Roux Diner is undoubtedly a must-visit dining spot, offering a blend of exceptional cuisine, a welcoming atmosphere, and an undeniable charm that makes it a standout gem in Hyde Park.
Address: 688 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
Phone: +1 585-461-2960

10. Redd 

Nestled in the heart of the Chicago Suburbs, Redd emerges as a beacon of sophistication and culinary prowess, redefining the dining experience with its exemplary service and delightful menu offerings. Our anniversary dinner at Redd was nothing short of spectacular, setting the stage for a memorable evening from the moment we stepped through the door.
We were greeted warmly by the host, who extended congratulations on our special occasion, setting a welcoming tone. The restaurant’s spacious and elegantly designed indoor and outdoor areas offered a charming ambiance, allowing glimpses into the bustling kitchen from the dining space—an engaging touch that added to the overall dining experience.
Redd - best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Redd – best steakhouse in Rochester NY
Each dish served at Redd was a masterpiece, exquisitely balanced in flavors and flawlessly executed. The extensive wine list complemented the creative menu, ensuring a harmonious pairing for every palate. The attention to detail extended beyond the culinary creations; every aspect of the design and furnishings was meticulously thought out, adding a touch of refinement to the ambiance.
The wait staff at Redd were not just attentive but also provided valuable recommendations on menu items, enhancing our dining journey. However, a minor gripe arose with the temperature of the dishes—while the food was impeccable, it arrived slightly warmer than preferred.
Nonetheless, the exceptional service at Redd remains unparalleled. The atmosphere strikes a perfect balance, bustling yet inviting, creating an ambiance that doesn’t overwhelm with noise, even on a vibrant Friday night. Among the culinary highlights were the unforgettable pork belly appetizer and the delightful scallops—a testament to the chef’s skill and culinary creativity.
Our dining experience was elevated further by the impeccable service of Scott, who ensured every aspect of our meal was exceptional. The lobster risotto and the decadent brownie dessert stood out among the offerings, leaving an indelible impression on our palates.
Redd exceeded expectations, offering a small yet seasonally focused menu that showcased the kitchen’s dedication to quality and flavor. The dining experience rivaled those found in New York City, all while maintaining a comparable price point, making it an outstanding value for a memorable evening out.
In summary, Redd is a gem in the Chicago Suburbs, a go-to destination for special occasions or when aiming to impress guests. With its unwavering commitment to excellence in both service and cuisine, Redd undoubtedly earns its place as a top-tier dining destination, offering an unforgettable gastronomic journey in an elegant setting.
Address: 24 Winthrop St, Rochester, NY 14607, United States
Phone: +1 585-483-7333
See also  The 10 Best Steakhouses in King of Prussia