Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Pismo Beach

5/5 - (2 votes)
Indulge in a culinary journey along the sun-kissed shores of Pismo Beach, where the salty breeze carries the promise of gastronomic delight. As seafood enthusiasts flock to this coastal haven, the quest for the best seafood in Pismo Beach becomes a delightful pursuit. From exquisite lobster bisque to impeccably grilled salmon, the diverse array of flavors and culinary craftsmanship make selecting the top ten seafood spots an art form. These reviews unveil the treasures of Pismo Beach’s seafood scene, offering a delectable roadmap to savor the finest oceanic flavors this charming locale has to offer.

Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Pismo Beach

1.Ada’s Fish House – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Ada’s Fish House in Pismo Beach emerges as a local gem, drawing in patrons with its delightful blend of exceptional seafood, friendly service, and a laid-back ambiance. As a pair of locals experiencing Ada’s for the first time, we were pleasantly surprised by the culinary treasures awaiting us. The restaurant strikes a balance between not being overly upscale yet offering food of remarkable quality. Our dining experience was elevated by dishes like the impeccably prepared fish and chips along with tantalizing fish tacos. The patio, basking in the warmth of a sunny day, provided a delightful setting for our meal. What truly stood out was the impeccable service, notably exemplified by our server Ashley, who expertly balanced being friendly, informative, and appropriately attentive throughout our visit.
Ada’s Fish House - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Ada’s Fish House – best seafood in Pismo Beach
Observing the hardworking and personable staff contributed to the overall positive ambiance. A glance around revealed tables adorned with tantalizing dishes, confirming the restaurant’s consistent ability to please its patrons. The halibut, a standout on the menu, was praised by many and left an indelible mark on our dining experience, ensuring we’ll savor thoughts of those meals for a long time. Flexibility with customizing dishes, like changing sauces to suit preferences, showcased their commitment to meeting customer needs.
The restaurant’s cleanliness, immediate seating, and a warm welcome upon arrival added to the favorable impression. Although Ada’s Fish House may not boast the fanciest interior, the focus remains on the star attraction: the delectable seafood. The spot-on execution of each dish coupled with the exceptional service make this an establishment worth visiting, especially for those seeking a genuine and satisfying seafood experience. Overall, Ada’s delivers excellent value for those craving tasty seafood in a welcoming, relaxed atmosphere—a recommendation we gladly extend, followed by a suggestion to complement the meal with a visit to a local winery, thereby completing a quintessential Pismo Beach experience.
Located in: Pismo Beach
Address: 558 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Reservations: opentable.com
Phone: +1 805-556-3077

2.Cracked Crab – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Cracked Crab, nestled conveniently on Price Street just a short stroll from the heart of Pismo Beach, is a seafood haven that warrants a deliberate visit. Brace yourself for the generous portion sizes that accompany the flavorful offerings awaiting you at this bustling establishment. The unassuming ambiance may seem casual, yet it buzzes with an infectious, relaxed energy—a delightful departure from formal dining, where comfort reigns supreme.
Cracked Crab - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Cracked Crab – best seafood in Pismo Beach
On our visit, the gumbo bowl and the crab salad stood out among the dishes, both bearing testimony to the kitchen’s commitment to taste and quality. The restaurant’s wine list, showcasing a diverse selection of local wines, added an extra layer of pleasure to our dining experience, perfectly complementing the coastal culinary delights.
The place exudes a vibrant and jovial atmosphere, encouraging patrons to unwind and embrace the casual beach vibe. Our server, embodying the spirit of the venue, guided us through the menu with expertise and warmth, enhancing our overall enjoyment.
The menu boasts several crowd favorites, and our experience aligned with the hype. The crab dip, clam chowder, and crab sandwich tantalized our taste buds, the latter provoking sheer delight with its perfect combination of lightly toasted, irresistibly soft bread and delectable crab filling—a true gluten-induced pleasure.
One of the standout features was the evident effort to deliver freshly made, flavorsome seafood, a welcome departure from the mundane fast-food fish offerings commonly found near beachfronts. The spotless ambiance, coupled with an attentive and congenial staff, added to the allure of the place, making it an instant hit in our book.
We found ourselves returning, lured back by the magnetic appeal of the Cracked Crab. The bucket of choices—whether three types of crab, clams, mussels, or wild shrimp—proved to be a wise indulgence. Upgrading to the king crab was a decision that reaped rich rewards, the succulent flavors leaving a lasting impression. The sauces accompanying the clams and mussels were an unexpected delight, elevating the dining experience to a new level of satisfaction.
For an extended seafood fiesta, this place undeniably stands tall as a must-visit destination. The medley of Dungeness and snow crab, accompanied by an array of other seafood offerings, ensured our return the very next day—an indisputable testament to the excellence and sheer pleasure Cracked Crab offers. This establishment comes highly recommended for those seeking a leisurely and indulgent seafood lunch, promising an enduringly enjoyable experience amidst the beachside charm of Pismo Beach.
Address: 751 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Menu: crackedcrab.com
Phone: +1 805-773-2722

3.Oyster Loft – best seafood in Pismo Beach

The Oyster Loft in Pismo Beach stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, earning its rightful spot at the pinnacle of dining destinations. From the moment you step foot into this elevated dining establishment, the fusion of breathtaking views, impeccable service, and divine cuisine transports you to an unparalleled gastronomic experience.
Oyster Loft - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Oyster Loft – best seafood in Pismo Beach
During our visit, the unanimous praise from our group of five echoed the sentiment of its well-deserved #1 status. Each dish we ordered, coupled with the indulgence in fresh oysters on the half shell, left an indelible mark of satisfaction. Our server, a consummate professional, skillfully opened a 2009 bottle of Pinot, exemplifying the restaurant’s commitment to both service and expertise.
The outdoor dining experience is an absolute must for those seeking an intimate connection with the coastal allure. Sitting on the deck, tantalizingly close to the beach, added an enchanting touch to the evening, further complemented by the breathtaking sunset—a picturesque backdrop that enhances the culinary journey.
The menu, a testament to culinary artistry, presented dishes that surpassed expectations. The roasted Brussels sprouts, embellished with dried cherries and bacon, left an indelible impression, setting a new standard for this often-underestimated vegetable. The entrees, a pinnacle of culinary craftsmanship, were universally praised, whether it was the perfectly cooked pork chops that defied convention or the scallops, deemed the best globally by one diner—an extraordinary feat that speaks volumes about the kitchen’s prowess.
The only downside, as pointed out by a patron, was the additional charge for credit card usage, a practice that detracted from an otherwise flawless dining experience—a sentiment echoed by many. Despite this blemish, the exceptional quality of the dishes and service shone through, leaving a lasting impression of excellence.
The culinary journey continued with dishes like the delectable octopus and the astonishingly flavorful sablefish entree. To cap off the night, the chocolate peanut butter mousse dessert proved to be the perfect denouement, tantalizing the taste buds and leaving an eagerness to return for another memorable dining escapade.
In conclusion, the Oyster Loft not only lives up to its accolades but surpasses them, offering an extraordinary amalgamation of captivating views, flawless service, and culinary brilliance. With an invitation to indulge in an array of palate-pleasing dishes, this establishment stands as a beacon of excellence in Pismo Beach—an unequivocal recommendation for those seeking an unparalleled dining experience.
Address: 101 Pomeroy Ave, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Reservations: opentable.com
Phone: +1 805-295-5104

4.Ventana Grill – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Ventana Grill in Pismo Beach is an absolute gem that delivers a culinary experience complemented by unparalleled views of the ocean. Situated in a prime location, this establishment beckons with unobstructed vistas that serve as a captivating backdrop to an already delightful dining experience.
Ventana Grill - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Ventana Grill – best seafood in Pismo Beach
Despite its popularity, which may entail a slight wait, our seating at the bar on consecutive nights provided immediate access—a testament to their efficient service and welcoming ambiance. The food, a symphony of flavors, surpassed expectations, leaving a lasting impression of gastronomic satisfaction. From the savory burger to the delectable flat iron steak, the chili relleno, and the flavorful Jumbo Shrimp Al Ajillo, each dish showcased the kitchen’s commitment to delivering nothing short of excellence.
Amidst apprehensions raised by online reviews, our dining experience defied any preconceived notions. The superb food and exemplary service exceeded our expectations, amplifying the enjoyment of our meals. The menu’s appeal extends beyond just taste; the reasonable prices and diverse beverage options, including commendable beers and a lovely Rose, further enhanced our dining pleasure.
The attentive service, exemplified by servers like Phil, contributed significantly to our memorable experience, reflecting a high level of professionalism and attentiveness. Moreover, being seated by the windows, offering an unobstructed ocean panorama, elevated the overall ambiance, adding a scenic charm that perfectly complemented the delectable dishes.
One patron’s enthusiasm was infectious, echoing our sentiments about Ventana Grill being a great place. The corner booth afforded us a breathtaking view, heightening the enjoyment of the exquisite culinary offerings. The halibut fish and chips left a profound impression, while the Ventana burger, featuring an Angus patty coupled with a Chorizo patty and cheese, proved to be a heavenly delight, especially when paired with their delectable fries.
In essence, Ventana Grill stands tall as a must-visit spot in Pismo Beach, combining a stunning setting with exceptional food and service. Whether it’s the impeccable ocean views, the diverse and flavorful menu offerings, or the attentive staff, this establishment encapsulates a dining experience that exceeds expectations. As a result, it earns our wholehearted recommendation as a dining destination that promises not just a meal, but a memorable culinary journey.
Address: 2575 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Menu: ventanagrill.com
Reservations: opentable.com
Order: alohaorderonline.com
Phone: +1 805-773-0000

5.Splash Café – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Splash Café in Pismo Beach is a perennial favorite, an iconic spot that beckons visitors year after year to savor its delightful offerings. Nestled conveniently on the corner, it bustles with a steady stream of patrons either relishing their meals inside or eagerly carrying out their delectable orders to the nearby beach—a mere stone’s throw away.
Splash Café - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Splash Café – best seafood in Pismo Beach
The star of the show undoubtedly remains the clam chowder, earning well-deserved accolades for its unparalleled creaminess, abundant chunks of clam and potatoes, setting a high standard amidst a sea of lackluster imitations. The option to savor this delightful concoction in a cup or their flavorful sourdough bowl only adds to the appeal.
The lobster roll, fish and chips, and other menu offerings maintain the standard of excellence set by the chowder. Despite the somewhat limited seating, the anticipation and preparation for a crowded evening are well worth the savory delights that await.
Patrons are quick to extol the virtues of the grilled middle in the bread bowl, an ingenious touch that elevates the entire chowder experience. The ability to customize with extra toppings further enhances the dining pleasure, offering a personalized touch to an already beloved dish.
Visitors returning to Pismo Beach often make it a point to revisit Splash Cafe, drawn back by the loaded chowder fries, steamed clams, fried shrimp, and calamari—a medley of delights that cater to the entire family’s cravings. Arriving early to secure a table or opting to relish the meal with a view near the pier adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the experience.
The clam chowder bread bowl, a star in its own right, makes for a memorable takeout option, its grilled opening and bread pieces providing the perfect vessels for dipping and savoring the rich flavors. Such is its allure that even a secondary order from elsewhere pales in comparison, as testified by a daughter’s change of heart after tasting this culinary masterpiece.
In conclusion, Splash Café earns its sterling reputation through consistently outstanding offerings, particularly the clam chowder, which stands as a shining beacon drawing patrons back time and again. For those seeking the epitome of clam chowder excellence, this spot is an undisputed recommendation, making it an essential stop for anyone visiting Pismo Beach—a testament to culinary prowess that doesn’t just meet expectations but exceeds them, ensuring a delightful dining experience.
Address: 197 Pomeroy Ave, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Order: goldbelly.com, doordash.com, trycaviar.com
Phone: +1 805-773-4653

6.Zorro’s Cafe & Cantina – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Zorro’s Cafe & Cantina in Pismo Beach stands as a local favorite, serving up a dependable and satisfying Mexican dining experience that keeps both locals and visitors coming back for more. As Pismo Beach locals ourselves, we find comfort in the reliability of a solid meal at Zorro’s—a testament to its enduring reputation for good food and a welcoming atmosphere.
Zorro's Cafe & Cantina - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Zorro’s Cafe & Cantina – best seafood in Pismo Beach
Bringing visiting relatives along to share in the Mexican cuisine joy, our evening was elevated not just by the delectable meals but also by the exceptional service provided by Christopher, our server par excellence. His infectious smile and warm personality amplified the dining experience, making it more than just a meal—it was an enjoyable evening filled with laughter and flavorful dishes.
The menu offerings at Zorro’s cater to various palates, and it’s evident in the rave reviews received. The guacamole, particularly fresh on the night of our visit, tantalized the taste buds, while the margaritas proved to be a hit—an added bonus to an already delightful meal.
The atmosphere at Zorro’s exudes a casual charm that complements the laid-back vibe of the Shell Beach area, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed, unpretentious meal. The service, consistently friendly and attentive, added to the overall positive experience, ensuring a memorable visit.
Dishes like the chicken flautas, sweet corn tamale, carne asada plate, and the indulgent fried ice cream stood out among the favorites, displaying a harmony of flavors that left a lasting impression. The meticulous attention to detail in the food presentation, exemplified by the homemade-style corn tortillas and the rich creaminess of the #6 combo with shrimp and crab enchilada, attested to the culinary expertise present in every dish.
While our experience was takeaway, the efficiency and attentiveness of the staff remained consistent. The immediate greeting upon arrival, coupled with recommendations and guidance in placing the to-go order, showcased their dedication to providing exceptional service to every patron.
Zorro’s boasts a blend of indoor and outdoor seating, a testament to its versatility in accommodating diners’ preferences. The reasonable prices and the presence of local patrons signify a consistent quality in both food and service—a reassuring sign for anyone seeking an authentic Mexican dining experience.
In summary, Zorro’s Cafe & Cantina remains a standout choice for Mexican cuisine in Pismo Beach, offering not just delicious food but a welcoming environment and exceptional service. Whether for a casual dine-in experience or a convenient takeaway, this establishment continues to uphold its reputation as a go-to spot for consistently good meals—a sentiment shared by locals and visitors alike.
Address: 927 Shell Beach Rd, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Menu: zorroscafe.com
Order: eatstreet.com
Phone: +1 805-773-9676

7.Giuseppe’s Cucina Italiana – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Giuseppe’s Cucina Italiana in Pismo Beach exudes a blend of delightful Italian flavors, warm ambiance, and a touch of authentic hospitality that elevates the dining experience to unforgettable heights. As an Italian restaurant owner from Madrid, my standards for Italian cuisine are quite high, and I must admit, Giuseppe’s did not disappoint.
Giuseppe's Cucina Italiana - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Giuseppe’s Cucina Italiana – best seafood in Pismo Beach
Upon dining at Giuseppe’s, the culinary journey began with an encounter with Giuseppe himself—an experience that left a lasting impression of warmth and kindness. The food, a true standout, lived up to its reputation of excellence. The ambiance of the restaurant added to the overall charm, setting the stage for a delightful culinary adventure.
The bread service, never-ending and accompanied by a parmesan olive sauce/dip, was a true testament to the attention to detail and commitment to quality at Giuseppe’s. The Sand Dabs from Moro Bay, a unique dish on the menu, proved to be a delightful surprise, showcasing both freshness and exceptional flavor—a true standout among the offerings.
Despite the bustling Saturday evening, the service remained impeccable, with an energetic ambiance that added to the overall dining experience. The cleanliness and attire of most patrons added to the upscale yet welcoming atmosphere, and the bill, surprisingly reasonable for such high-quality dining, added to the overall satisfaction.
As a note, reservations are not taken, and arriving early is recommended due to the popularity of the restaurant. The wait, although inevitable, was worth it, as attested by the multitude of diners who eagerly flock to this culinary gem.
The Giuseppe salad and the spicy pizza were highlights for another diner, underscoring the restaurant’s ability to cater to various tastes while maintaining exceptional quality. The waiter’s entertaining demeanor, coupled with excellent service, added an extra layer of enjoyment to the dining experience, creating a memorable evening.
For many, Giuseppe’s has become a must-visit spot in Pismo Beach, a place that exudes warmth, invites patrons to savor the incredible Italian bread with Parmesan cheese, garlic, and olive oil spread, and consistently delivers exceptional food that leaves a lasting impression. Without a doubt, Giuseppe’s Cucina Italiana remains the epitome of Italian dining in the area, an establishment that encapsulates not just delicious cuisine but an ambiance that feels like home—a recommendation that echoes the sentiment of many patrons who have found themselves enchanted by its allure.
Address: 891 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Menu: giuseppesrestaurant.com
Phone: +1 805-773-2870

8.Hoagies Sandwiches & Grill – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Hoagies Sandwiches & Grill in Pismo Beach beckons both locals and visitors with its bustling ambiance, delivering an array of delectable sandwiches and an inviting beachy atmosphere. As a popular spot, a brief wait is often well worth the flavorful delights that await.
Hoagies Sandwiches & Grill - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Hoagies Sandwiches & Grill – best seafood in Pismo Beach
The Stanley sandwich, juicy and delectable, was a standout among the offerings. Despite the busy environment, the staff efficiently served patrons with friendly service, ensuring a quick and enjoyable dining experience. However, while some enjoyed the curly fries, others preferred the regular ones—suggesting personal preferences may vary.
For aficionados of pulled pork, the Kingston pulled pork sandwich emerged as a revelation, drawing enthusiastic praise that transcends distance—a testament to its phenomenal taste. The beachy ambiance, allowing patrons to savor their meals either outdoors watching the world go by or inside, adds to the overall charm of this downtown gem.
The Pismo Wrap, a perfect fusion of trip-tip, pepper jack cheese, avocado, curly fries, and BBQ sauce, left an indelible mark on one patron, evoking excitement and fond memories with every thought. Its generous proportions made it a challenge to finish, even for a big eater—an ode to the restaurant’s dedication to hearty portions and delightful flavors.
Families find themselves drawn back repeatedly to Hoagies, with consistent praises for the quality and quantity of their offerings. Not only is every meal fantastic, but the drinks, such as the famous Bloody Mary adorned with shrimp, bacon, green olives, and a pepper, stand out as crowd favorites, offering a unique and enjoyable experience. The ingenuity of adding a Red Stripe to keep the drink going further attests to the creativity and fun atmosphere at this establishment.
While the lines may be long due to its popularity, the efficient service ensures that patrons are quickly attended to, making the wait worthwhile. Whether it’s enjoying a cold drink alongside a satisfying meal or relishing the flavors of the varied sandwiches, Hoagies Sandwiches & Grill earns its acclaim as a go-to spot in Pismo Beach—a place where good food, ample portions, and a lively atmosphere converge to create unforgettable dining moments.
Located in: Cypress Landing Shops
Address: 580 Cypress St N 5, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Menu: hoagiesca.com
Phone: +1 805-773-3580

9.Papi’s Grill – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Papi’s Grill in Pismo Beach delivers a sensational experience, elevating Mexican cuisine to new heights through its commitment to freshness, simplicity, and unparalleled flavors. Nestled in the heart of California’s culinary scene, this eatery showcases authentic Mexican fare that is truly delightful.
Upon entering, the warm welcome from the proprietor, coupled with his evident pride in the culinary creations, sets the tone for an exceptional dining experience. The menu offerings, crafted from family recipes, captivate the taste buds and exemplify the epitome of delicious simplicity.
The ceviche, made from local halibut and fresh vegetables, shines as a testament to the quality of ingredients and the meticulous attention to detail. The pozole, adorned with cilantro, onions, jalapenos, lime, and accompanied by homemade chips, offers a complexity of flavors that tantalize the senses—a true delight for the palate.
Dining al fresco under the cool coastal evening air, though requiring a bit of bundling up, becomes a worthy experience when complemented by such exceptional cuisine. The attention to customer service further enhances the dining journey, with friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable visit.
Patrons rave about the tacos, heralding them as among the best they’ve ever had. The potato tacos and fish tacos, bursting with freshness and flavor, leave a lasting impression. The soft, non-greasy corn tortillas serve as the perfect canvas for the generously filled tacos—grilled halibut, corn, black beans, and cabbage harmoniously paired with just the right amount of sauce.
Despite the higher price point for a single taco, the consensus remains strong—a testament to the exceptional quality and value offered by Papi’s Grill. It’s not just about the affordability but the unparalleled taste and quality that patrons seek, making it a standout choice for those craving authentic Mexican street food.
For many, Papi’s Grill becomes the quintessential go-to spot for a five-star taco experience, a place where simplicity meets excellence. While not a fine dining establishment, the simple yet expertly crafted tacos, particularly the house-made chorizo, consistently earn accolades, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking an authentic and satisfying culinary adventure in Pismo Beach.
Address: 1090 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Phone: +1 805-295-6660
Order: doordash.com, trycaviar.com

10.Penny’s All American Cafe – best seafood in Pismo Beach

Penny’s All American Cafe in Pismo Beach stands as a beacon for delightful breakfast experiences, drawing locals and visitors alike with its fast service, friendly staff, and an array of mouthwatering dishes that keep patrons returning for more.
For many, Penny’s has become an integral part of their yearly Pismo vacation routine, offering a delectable range of breakfast delights that cater to various tastes. The Pismo Pier Omelet and the spicy sausage patty with biscuits and gravy emerge as clear favorites, showcasing a delicious blend of flavors that satisfy cravings.
Penny's All American Cafe - best seafood in Pismo Beach
Penny’s All American Cafe – best seafood in Pismo Beach
The generous portions and exceptional service are consistent highlights, with special mention of Ashley, who embodies exceptional service and sweetness—a valued asset to the establishment. Patrons praise the strawberry waffles for their light, fluffy texture, overflowing with beautiful strawberries and topped with decadent whipped cream—a true culinary delight that leaves a lasting impression.
The outstanding Chili Verde, home fries, perfectly cooked fried eggs, and delicious coffee are among the menu items that garner high praise. The omelettes, hash browns, and scrambled eggs, meticulously prepared and served with warmth, are indicative of the care and attention to detail that define the Penny’s experience.
Across the board, the friendly service and great coffee contribute to the inviting atmosphere that beckons patrons back repeatedly. The breakfast offerings, ranging from cheese omelettes to oatmeal, demonstrate the versatility and quality that Penny’s prides itself on.
Perhaps the most resounding endorsement comes from a patron who declares Penny’s as the best breakfast place they’ve encountered in 62 years—an assertion that speaks volumes. The perfect eggs, buttery and crispy shredded hash browns, outstanding bacon, and stunning strawberry waffles exemplify the diverse and exceptional menu that awaits visitors.
In conclusion, Penny’s All American Cafe emerges as a gem in the breakfast scene of Pismo Beach, offering a quintessential breakfast experience that transcends expectations. With its delightful dishes, friendly service, and a warm ambiance, it’s no wonder that patrons of all ages, from near and far, find themselves returning to savor the exceptional culinary offerings at Penny’s—a must-visit destination for anyone seeking a memorable breakfast outing.
Address: 1053 Price St, Pismo Beach, CA 93449, United States
Phone: +1 805-773-3776
See also  Reviews of The 10 BEST Steakhouses in Cleveland