Reviews of the 10 Best Seafood Restauants in Pigeon Forge

5/5 - (2 votes)
Embark on a culinary journey through the heart of Pigeon Forge as we unveil a gastronomic delight – the Reviews of the 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Pigeon Forge. Nestled within the scenic beauty of the Smoky Mountains, Pigeon Forge offers more than just breathtaking landscapes; it’s a haven for seafood enthusiasts seeking the finest dining experiences. From delectable crab legs to succulent shrimp, our comprehensive guide is your passport to savoring the ocean’s treasures in the heart of Tennessee. Join us as we explore and critique the establishments that proudly claim to serve the best seafood in Pigeon Forge, ensuring your taste buds embark on an unforgettable culinary expedition.

Reviews of the 10 best seafood Restaurants in Pigeon Forge

1. Huck Finn’s Catfish 

Huck Finn’s Catfish in Pigeon Forge exceeded our expectations, providing a delightful dining experience that left us thoroughly satisfied. Despite some mixed reviews we had read, our visit was nothing short of fantastic.
Our waiter, Brandon, deserves special commendation for his outstanding service. Despite having two large tables, he assured us we could easily get his attention if needed. The entire staff was friendly and helpful, contributing to the warm and inviting atmosphere of the restaurant.
The menu offered a variety of options, and we were not disappointed with our choices. Mom enjoyed the haddock and clam strips, especially raving about the hush puppies. I opted for the frog legs and gator bites, both of which were delicious. The French fries were fresh, and the mashed potatoes were equally satisfying.
Huck Finn's Catfish in Pigeon Forge
Huck Finn’s Catfish in Pigeon Forge
Portions were generous, ensuring that we left the restaurant completely full. The review advising future patrons to “come hungry and leave full” couldn’t be more accurate. The diverse menu and ample servings make Huck Finn’s Catfish the best place in Pigeon Forge for a hearty and satisfying meal.
Alyx, another server at the restaurant, made a lasting impression on us. Her exceptional service and welcoming demeanor elevated our dining experience, making us feel like part of the Huck Finn’s family. We would return just to be served by Alyx again.
While the review mentioned a slight disappointment with the pork chops and mashed potatoes, it’s clear that the diverse menu has something for everyone. The automatic presentation of hush puppies, coleslaw, pinto beans, pickles, and onion slices upon arrival adds a charming touch to the dining experience.
The perfectly fried catfish was a standout, seasoned to perfection and leaving us wanting more. The prompt service, relaxing atmosphere, and Southern charm further enhanced our overall impression of Huck Finn’s Catfish. The restaurant has earned a spot on our list of go-to places whenever we’re in the area.
In conclusion, Huck Finn’s Catfish in Pigeon Forge offers a delightful culinary experience with excellent service, a diverse menu, and generous portions. Don’t hesitate to visit this establishment if you’re in the mood for a Southern feast that will leave you satisfied and planning your return. Thanks again to Brandon, Alyx, and the entire team at Huck Finn’s for a memorable dining experience!
Address: 3330 Parkway, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, United States
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Order: doordash.com, trycaviar.com
Phone: +1 865-429-3353

2. Harpoon Harry’s Crab House  

Harpoon Harry’s Crab House in Pigeon Forge stands out as a gem among dining establishments, offering a delightful experience that combines exquisite cuisine, attentive service, and a charming ambiance.
My husband and I recently visited Harpoon Harry’s for lunch on a weekday, and we were pleasantly surprised by the lack of crowds, allowing us to enjoy a more intimate dining experience. The restaurant’s decor, adorned with intricate carvings, created an inviting atmosphere that set the stage for what turned out to be a memorable meal.
Harpoon Harry's Crab House in Pigeon Forge
Harpoon Harry’s Crab House in Pigeon Forge
Our server, whom we affectionately referred to as the ‘Main Bar,’ was not only efficient but also incredibly personable. She provided us with insightful information about the area and engaged us in friendly chit-chat, adding a personal touch to our dining experience.
One noteworthy aspect of our visit was the restaurant’s accommodation of a garlic allergy. The staff took special care to ensure that my husband’s meal, the Surf and Turf, remained free from any garlic contamination. This attention to dietary needs reflects the commitment of Harpoon Harry’s to customer satisfaction and safety.
During our first visit, I opted for the Shrimp and Grits, while my husband savored the Crab Stuffed Flounder and Broiled Red Snapper. The dishes were a culinary delight, with each bite showcasing the freshness and quality of the ingredients. The Crab Stuffed Flounder and Broiled Red Snapper were particularly outstanding, and our waiter’s friendliness and attentiveness enhanced the overall dining experience.
Impressed by our initial encounter, we decided to return for a second visit, making it a highlight of our 10th-anniversary celebration. The steak we ordered was nothing short of amazing, underscoring the consistency of Harpoon Harry’s commitment to delivering top-notch food quality.
On our second visit, the restaurant was bustling, but the efficient service and warm atmosphere remained unchanged. We were pleasantly surprised to be attended to by the Manager, a friendly and hardworking young man who exemplified leadership through his exceptional service. It became evident that the positive atmosphere at Harpoon Harry’s is a result of the dedication of the entire staff, led by this exemplary manager.
In conclusion, Harpoon Harry’s Crab House in Pigeon Forge is a must-visit for those seeking a memorable dining experience. From the delectable cuisine to the warm and friendly service, this establishment has earned our highest recommendation. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Harpoon Harry’s is sure to leave you with a lasting impression of exceptional food and hospitality.
Address: 112 Community Center Dr, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, United States
Menu: harpoonharryscrabhouse.com
Reservations: harpoonharryscrabhouse.com, opentable.com
Phone: +1 865-428-2006

3. Mel’s Classic Diner 

Mel’s Classic Diner in Pigeon Forge proved to be a delightful surprise for our group of six after a day at the Island. Despite the scorching weather, we were determined to find a place away from the hustle and bustle, and Mel’s did not disappoint.
Upon arrival, we were greeted by a bustling atmosphere, but the accommodating staff quickly found a solution for our party of six by allowing us to sit at two separate booths. This gesture set the tone for our dining experience, highlighting the restaurant’s commitment to customer satisfaction.
Mel's Classic Diner - best seafood in Pigeon Forge
Mel’s Classic Diner – best seafood in Pigeon Forge
The menu offered a classic diner selection, and the food exceeded our expectations. The dishes arrived promptly, even considering the busy environment. Our hunger was quickly satisfied by the fantastic burgers and fries – some of the best we’ve had. The portions were generous, leaving us with leftovers despite our voracious appetites.
The ambiance of Mel’s Classic Diner added to the overall positive experience. The clean and welcoming atmosphere created a comfortable setting to enjoy a classic diner meal. The staff’s efficiency and attentiveness stood out, making us feel well taken care of throughout our visit.
It’s worth noting that Mel’s Classic Diner seems to be a popular choice among locals and visitors alike, evident from the consistently busy restaurant. Despite the small parking lot, the convenience of early opening hours and late closing times is a definite plus for those looking to grab a meal at almost any time of the day.
One reviewer mentioned revisiting Mel’s multiple times during their stay, and it’s easy to understand why. The continuity of excellent service was evident when they had the same friendly waitress on both visits, creating a sense of familiarity that enhances the overall dining experience.
One particularly touching review highlighted the exceptional nature of the dining experience at Mel’s. A customer who had been unwell for years found the meal at Mel’s to be the best they had enjoyed in at least two years. The staff’s kindness and the delicious food left a lasting impression, with the reviewer expressing a desire to make Mel’s their first stop on any future visits to the area.
In conclusion, Mel’s Classic Diner in Pigeon Forge offers more than just a meal; it provides a welcoming atmosphere, delicious food, and a level of service that goes above and beyond. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, Mel’s is a must-visit spot for a satisfying diner experience in the heart of Pigeon Forge.
Address: 119 Wears Valley Rd, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, United States
Menu: melsdinerpf.com
Phone: +1 865-429-2184

4. Chesapeake’s Seafood and Raw Bar 

Chesapeake’s Seafood and Raw Bar in Gatlinburg has proven to be a hidden gem that leaves a lasting impression on its patrons. The consistent praise for both the exceptional service and delectable seafood offerings speaks volumes about this fine dining establishment.
One customer commended the professional service, specifically highlighting the efforts of Jason M. and his charming bowtie. The reviewer expressed gratitude for Jason’s detailed menu explanations, perfectly timed table visits, and overall gentlemanly demeanor. It’s clear that the staff at Chesapeake’s goes above and beyond to create a memorable dining experience.
Chesapeake's Seafood and Raw Bar in Pigeon Forge
Chesapeake’s Seafood and Raw Bar in Pigeon Forge
Another diner, grateful for making a reservation, enjoyed the busy yet attentive atmosphere. The seafood was lauded, with a particular mention of the delicious grouper with brown rice and quinoa. The clam chowder received positive remarks as well, contributing to a satisfying meal easily accessible from the town center.
Cassidy, a standout member of the waitstaff, received high praise from a group of four diners. Her exceptional service, marked by efficiency in order taking and an overall delightful demeanor, left a lasting impression on the party. This personal touch from the staff enhances the overall dining experience, making Chesapeake’s a must-visit.
A more detailed review painted Chesapeake’s as a beautiful, fine dining restaurant specializing in fresh seafood. The complimentary bread basket, featuring a variety of tasty breads, set the stage for an impressive meal. The Maryland blue lump crab cake appetizer, described as all crab with no filler, showcased the commitment to quality ingredients.
The main courses, including fried prawns and a special dish featuring wolffish, were met with rave reviews. The wolffish, likened to lobster/sweet shrimp, was expertly prepared with a lobster sauce and served on a bed of brown rice and quinoa. The attention to detail in each dish, including the well-executed green beans in garlic butter, demonstrated the culinary prowess of the kitchen.
In a downtown area rife with tourist traps, Chesapeake’s Seafood and Raw Bar stands out as a respite for those seeking a genuine and exceptional dining experience. The extensive catch of the day menu, the emphasis on fresh seafood, and the attentive service combine to make Chesapeake’s a destination worth returning to. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this restaurant seems to have mastered the art of delivering a truly wonderful meal.
Address: 437 Parkway, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Phone: +1 865-622-6999
Reservations: opentable.com

5. The Peddler Steakhouse

The Peddler Steakhouse in Pigeon Forge has clearly left a lasting impression on its patrons, as evident from the glowing reviews that highlight various aspects of this fine dining establishment. One recurring theme in the reviews is the exemplary service provided by the staff. From the courteous host staff to the knowledgeable and attentive wait staff, customers consistently praise the level of professionalism and friendliness exhibited by the team at The Peddler. The mention of Skylar ensuring a seamless dining experience reflects the dedication to customer satisfaction.
The culinary expertise of the cook staff is another point of acclaim. Diners appreciate the skill in preparing dishes, with specific emphasis on the filet mignon that is described as “to die for.” The perfect balance of seasoning and char on the steaks is noted, underscoring the commitment to culinary excellence. The fact that everything was cooked perfectly the first time is a testament to the kitchen’s precision and attention to detail.
The Peddler Steakhouse - best seafood in Pigeon Forge
The Peddler Steakhouse – best seafood in Pigeon Forge
The scenic view of the creek adds a delightful touch to the dining experience, with one customer even spotting a black bear wandering nearby—a unique and unexpected bonus. The atmosphere, described as cozy and intimate, further enhances the overall ambiance of the restaurant.
The value for money at The Peddler is emphasized, with a total bill of $118 before tip deemed reasonable for the quality of the meal and service received. The inclusion of a top-notch salad bar is noted as a distinguishing factor, elevating The Peddler above some of its competitors in the area.
Despite being busy, especially on Wednesday evenings, patrons recommend making reservations in advance to secure a table. While there is open seating in the bar upstairs, the popularity of The Peddler makes reservations a wise choice for those seeking a guaranteed dining spot.
In conclusion, The Peddler Steakhouse in Pigeon Forge consistently delivers a superb dining experience, from the warm and professional service to the culinary delights that leave customers raving. With its scenic location, cozy atmosphere, and attention to detail, The Peddler stands out as a top choice for a memorable meal in Gatlinburg and Pigeon Forge. Bravo, Peddlers!
Address: 820 River Rd, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Menu: peddlergatlinburg.com
Reservations: resy.com
Phone: +1 865-436-5794

6. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co

Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. in Pigeon Forge offers a delightful dining experience with a few minor hiccups. Our visit, like many others, showcased both the highlights and areas for improvement.
The standout feature of our dinner was undoubtedly the impeccable service provided by Stan, our server. Stan’s recommendations, particularly the fried chicken on linguine, were spot-on, resulting in a delicious and memorable meal. His friendly demeanor, timely service, and attention to detail enhanced our overall dining experience. The positive remarks from other patrons about their servers echo our sentiment, making it clear that the staff at this location is a definite asset.
Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. - best seafood in Pigeon Forge
Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. – best seafood in Pigeon Forge
The restaurant’s seating arrangements, however, drew some criticism. A Saturday night visit at 6:30 pm meant a manageable wait time, but an unfortunate seating arrangement left one party uncomfortable. The close proximity of the booth’s bench to the table made it impossible to find a comfortable position. While this may be an isolated incident, it’s worth noting for those who prioritize spacious seating arrangements.
On the culinary front, Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. received praise for its diverse seafood offerings. The crab-stuffed shrimp left a lasting impression, with one customer expressing their satisfaction. The menu, featuring options like the Forrest Seafood and mixed seafood and steak meal, showcases a variety of choices for seafood enthusiasts. The positive reviews suggest that the restaurant excels in delivering delicious and well-prepared meals that cater to different tastes.
For those visiting Gatlinburg, Tennessee, Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. emerges as a commendable dining option. The excellence of the seafood meals, coupled with Stan’s outstanding service, outweighs the minor discomfort caused by the seating arrangement. Additionally, the presence of a Forrest Gump gift shop adds a unique touch to the overall experience. In conclusion, while there are some areas for improvement, Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. remains a solid choice for those seeking a delightful seafood dining experience in Pigeon Forge.
Address: 900 Parkway, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Menu: bubbagump.com
Order: allsetnow.com, seamless.com, doordash.com, postmates.com, waitrapp.com, ubereats.com, grubhub.com, trycaviar.com
Phone: +1 865-430-3034

7. Crawdaddy’s Restaurant & Oyster Bar

Crawdaddy’s Restaurant & Oyster Bar in Pigeon Forge has clearly left a lasting impression on its patrons, offering a delightful combination of excellent service, delectable seafood, and breathtaking views.
One recurring theme among customer reviews is the establishment’s commitment to exceptional service. Fabio and Lou, mentioned in separate reviews, were both praised for their attentive and friendly service, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. The staff’s enthusiasm for engaging with customers, providing local insights, and ensuring a memorable visit is certainly a highlight.
Crawdaddy’s Restaurant & Oyster Bar in Pigeon Forge
Crawdaddy’s Restaurant & Oyster Bar in Pigeon Forge
The outdoor seating, described as having an “awesome view,” appears to be a major draw for visitors. Overlooking the town and offering fantastic vistas, the outdoor setting enhances the overall dining experience. Whether enjoying oysters, shrimp, or a seafood platter, customers have raved about the picturesque surroundings that complement the delicious cuisine.
The menu at Crawdaddy’s seems to cater to a variety of tastes, with fish & chips, shrimp, scallops & pasta, snow crab, and King Crab legs receiving particular acclaim. The grilled shrimp brochette, a bacon-wrapped shrimp stuffed with crab meat, is singled out as “incredible,” showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to unique and flavorful dishes.
The Big Daddy Seafood platter, featuring a medley of fried oysters, Whiting, and shrimp, is highlighted for its deliciousness and generous portions, ensuring patrons leave satisfied.
It’s worth noting that even in a situation where the original plan to visit another restaurant was disrupted, Crawdaddy’s managed to win over patrons, showcasing its flexibility and ability to turn an unexpected visit into a positive experience. Lou, the server in this particular instance, is commended for her personable nature and valuable insights into the local area, adding an extra layer of hospitality.
In conclusion, Crawdaddy’s Restaurant & Oyster Bar seems to have mastered the art of combining delectable seafood, attentive service, and stunning views. Whether you’re a seafood enthusiast, seeking a scenic dining experience, or both, Crawdaddy’s appears to deliver on its promises. The overwhelmingly positive reviews, praising everything from the food to the service, suggest that a visit to Crawdaddy’s is not just a meal but an experience to be savored.
Address: 762 Parkway #5, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Menu: crawdaddysgatlinburg.com
Reservations: resy.com
Phone: +1 865-430-3755

8. Cherokee Grill and Steakhouse 

Cherokee Grill and Steakhouse in Gatlinburg has left an indelible mark on our taste buds, making it a standout choice for those seeking an exceptional dining experience. Based on a series of glowing customer reviews, this establishment consistently delivers on its promise of delectable cuisine, superb service, and a welcoming atmosphere.
One review from a honeymooning couple emphasized the meticulous attention to detail exhibited by the kitchen staff. The house salad and side dishes were particularly praised, highlighting the passion and dedication behind the scenes. The reviewer applauded the courteous and knowledgeable waitress, Robin, who added a personal touch to the dining experience.
The decor and ambiance were noted as pleasing, contributing to an overall memorable evening. Despite the slightly higher price point, the reviewer deemed it absolutely worth the investment, recommending Cherokee Grill as a must-visit in Gatlinburg.
Cherokee Grill and Steakhouse in Pigeon Forge
Cherokee Grill and Steakhouse in Pigeon Forge
Another reviewer, sharing a dining experience with a friend from Louisiana, commended the excellent service from check-in to the server. The quality of the steaks, cooked to perfection, and the delectable side of niche potatoes showcased the establishment’s commitment to using top-notch ingredients. A recommended pumpkin caramel dessert added a sweet note to the culinary journey.
The positive encounter prompted the reviewers to plan a return visit, specifically requesting the exceptional service of David. The combination of attentive service, high-quality cuisine, and a welcoming atmosphere solidified Cherokee Grill as a preferred dining destination.
The next enthusiastic review came from a couple who had an “awesome” experience at Cherokee Grill. The server, David, played a pivotal role in ensuring a seamless and enjoyable dining experience from start to finish. The succulent steak and seafood dishes were highlighted as culinary delights. The reviewer went on to declare Cherokee Grill as the best restaurant in Gatlinburg, offering a perfect blend of superior food and impeccable service. The icing on the cake, as mentioned by the reviewer, was the absence of moonshine sales, contributing to a refined and sophisticated dining environment.
The final review underscored the outstanding service provided by waitress Susan, who was described as sweet, attentive, and knowledgeable. The cocktails were praised for their perfection in pour and taste, setting the tone for a delightful dining experience. The stuffed mushrooms appetizer and the ribeye steak were specifically highlighted, with the latter described as a “special experience” and cooked to perfection.
The use of a skillet plate kept the ribeye piping hot, adding a unique touch to the presentation. The reviewer concluded with a resounding endorsement, urging readers to stop contemplating and dine at Cherokee Grill, guaranteeing satisfaction.
In conclusion, Cherokee Grill and Steakhouse in Gatlinburg stands out as a culinary gem, consistently delivering exceptional food, impeccable service, and a welcoming atmosphere. The enthusiastic reviews from satisfied customers paint a vivid picture of a dining establishment that goes above and beyond to create memorable experiences for its patrons. For those seeking a top-tier dining experience in Gatlinburg, Cherokee Grill and Steakhouse is undoubtedly a prime choice.
Address: 1002 Parkway, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Reservations: opentable.com
Phone: +1 865-436-4287

9. Smith & Son Corner Kitchen 

Smith & Son Corner Kitchen in Pigeon Forge has captured the hearts of its patrons, offering a delightful blend of great atmosphere, top-notch service, and delicious food. The overwhelmingly positive reviews echo a consistent theme of excellence that spans various aspects of the dining experience.
First-time visitors raved about the welcoming atmosphere, exceptional service, and delectable cuisine. The staff, from the night shift manager to cooks, servers, and bartenders, were commended for their friendliness and willingness to go the extra mile. The attentive service, quick response to requests, and a friendly atmosphere left a lasting impression, earning the establishment a well-deserved 5-star rating.
Smith & Son Corner Kitchen in Pigeon Forge
Smith & Son Corner Kitchen in Pigeon Forge
One customer highlighted the charm of the restaurant being located on the 2nd floor, showcasing an authentic Smoky Mountain ambiance with captivating old pictures. The review praised the sizable portions and freshness of the dishes, such as the fried chicken salad and a double burger with fries, emphasizing the overall positive experience despite the potential disadvantage of the location.
A visit on November 1, 2023, left another set of patrons thoroughly impressed. The bartender, doubling as a waiter, demonstrated exceptional hospitality, making the customers feel truly valued. The memorable customer service, coupled with great food, prompted a high recommendation, with the promise of a return visit.
Even those with time constraints during a conference found Smith & Son Corner Kitchen to be a convenient and enjoyable choice for a quick lunch. Sierra, a standout server, played a crucial role in making the visit special. Her friendly and attentive demeanor, coupled with prompt recommendations and service, transformed a brief stop into a memorable encounter. Customers felt a genuine connection, describing the experience as making a new friend.
In conclusion, Smith & Son Corner Kitchen in Pigeon Forge has proven to be a standout dining destination, earning praise for its inviting atmosphere, excellent service, and delectable offerings. The consistently positive reviews paint a picture of a restaurant that not only meets but exceeds customer expectations, making it a must-visit for locals and tourists alike.
Address: 812 Parkway Ste 105 at Stoplight No, 8, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Phone: +1 865-430-1978

10. Howard’s Restaurant Gatlinburg’s Oldest Restaurant  

Howard’s Restaurant in Gatlinburg stands as a testament to the adage “old is gold,” consistently delivering exceptional dining experiences that resonate with both locals and visitors alike. As Gatlinburg’s oldest restaurant, Howard’s seamlessly blends tradition with a commitment to culinary excellence, making it a must-visit destination for those seeking a memorable meal.
The cozy ambiance of Howard’s sets the stage for an inviting dining experience, as noted by numerous patrons. One customer praised the restaurant’s warmth, describing it as a “great cozy place to get dinner.” The establishment’s ability to balance its historical charm with a welcoming atmosphere is commendable, creating a space where patrons can unwind and enjoy their meals.
Howard's Restaurant Gatlinburg's Oldest Restaurant in Pigeon Forge
Howard’s Restaurant Gatlinburg’s Oldest Restaurant in Pigeon Forge
The culinary offerings at Howard’s have left an indelible mark on its customers. The steaks have been lauded as “amazing,” and the jalapeño poppers, recommended as an appetizer, showcase the restaurant’s commitment to delivering a delightful dining experience. The incorporation of local whiskey from the King family into their old-fashioned cocktail adds a distinctive touch, further enhancing the overall enjoyment of the meal.
The menu diversity at Howard’s has received high praise, with customers expressing delight in the cajun catfish and pan-fried trout. The variety of side dishes, described as “many and all delicious,” ensures that patrons can tailor their meals to their liking. The generous and reasonably priced drinks, coupled with attentive service, contribute to the overall satisfaction of diners.
For those seeking an iconic experience, Howard’s does not disappoint. One reviewer highlighted the restaurant’s superb setting overlooking a local brook and waterfall, creating a relaxed atmosphere that enhances the dining experience. The vegetable soup, described as “simply amazing” and packed with fresh veggies and delicious broth, showcases the culinary prowess that Howard’s consistently delivers.
The commitment to maintaining high standards is evident in the continued success of Howard’s, as noted by a customer who acknowledged the restaurant’s longevity and its dedication to quality in terms of food and service. From a delectable filet to a well-crafted Bloody Mary, Howard’s ensures that each aspect of the dining experience is met with excellence.
In conclusion, Howard’s Restaurant stands as Gatlinburg’s culinary cornerstone, offering a delightful blend of tradition, exceptional cuisine, and welcoming hospitality. Whether you’re a local or a traveler passing through, Howard’s is a timeless gem that continues to shine as one of the region’s premier dining establishments.
Address: 976 Parkway, Gatlinburg, TN 37738, United States
Phone: +1 865-436-3600
See also  The 15 Best Seafood Restaurants in Gulf Shores