Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Bethany Beach

Cottage Cafe - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Rate this post
Welcome to the ultimate guide featuring comprehensive reviews of the 10 best seafood spots in the serene coastal haven of Bethany Beach. Nestled along the picturesque Delaware shoreline, Bethany Beach boasts a culinary scene renowned for its delectable ocean delights. Whether you’re a local seafood aficionado or a visitor seeking the freshest catches, this curated selection promises an exploration of gastronomic excellence, unveiling the hidden gems and well-known establishments that offer the finest in seafood delights across this charming beach town.

Reviews of the 10 best seafood in Bethany Beach

1.Bethany Diner – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Bethany Diner in Bethany Beach is an unassuming gem that consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience, drawing patrons back time and again. This beloved eatery stands out for its welcoming atmosphere, hearty portions, and a menu that celebrates classic diner fare with a delectable twist. From the moment you’re greeted by the friendly servers, their warmth and attentiveness make you feel like part of the family. Customers are treated not just to a meal but to an engaging and personable service, evident in the thoughtful interactions and genuine interest in guests’ experiences.
Bethany Diner - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Bethany Diner – best seafood in Bethany Beach
The diverse menu boasts a range of options, making decisions tough yet rewarding, with specials that offer remarkable value for money. One such standout is the two for $25 special, a testament to their commitment to affordability without compromising on taste or portion size. The seafood basket, roast beef sandwich, mega fries, and chopped steak are among the highlights, leaving taste buds in awe with their flavors and generous servings.
The quality of the food truly shines, evidenced by perfectly cooked shrimp, clam strips, and sizable, flavorful fish portions that exceed expectations. Even the open-faced roast beef sandwich, generously drenched in savory gravy, impresses beyond measure. Not to be overlooked is the starter salad, fresh and crisp with an ample variety of dressings to suit every palate. The diner’s attention to detail extends to their dessert offerings, like the deliciously comforting rice pudding, capping off a meal that consistently leaves patrons happily satiated.
Whether you’re a local regular or a visiting family seeking a safe, comforting haven amidst uncertain times, Bethany Diner remains a beacon of reliability, offering a haven of great food, reasonable prices, and a welcoming ambiance that feels like a home away from home. For those prioritizing a genuine dining experience over opulence, this unpretentious yet exceptional establishment is an absolute must-visit.
Address: 792 Garfield Pkwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Phone: +1 302-616-1117
Order: doordash.com, trycaviar.com

2.Bluecoast Seafood Grill & Raw Bar Bethany – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Bluecoast Seafood Grill & Raw Bar in Bethany Beach stands as a beacon of culinary excellence, charming patrons with its vibrant atmosphere, top-notch service, and an array of delightful seafood offerings. Stepping into this inviting eatery, guests are welcomed by an atmosphere that effortlessly combines casual comfort with a touch of sophistication. The restaurant exudes a relaxed ambiance, providing both indoor and outdoor seating options to suit diverse preferences. The menu showcases a range of delectable dishes, each boasting flavors that elevate the seafood experience to new heights.
Bluecoast Seafood Grill & Raw Bar Bethany - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Bluecoast Seafood Grill & Raw Bar Bethany – best seafood in Bethany Beach
For starters, the crab dip served with homemade chips sets the tone, offering a delightful introduction to the culinary journey that lies ahead. On crabcake night, patrons are treated to generously portioned cakes made from large lump crabmeat, slightly spicy and bursting with flavor. Accompanied by a rich slaw and crispy French fries, these dishes exemplify the restaurant’s commitment to quality and taste. The rockfish, raved about by many, serves as a testament to the diverse yet consistently exceptional offerings.
The happy hour menu stands out for its affordability and range of tantalizing options, including $1 raw oysters of the day and standout items like mussels in a tomato, garlic, and andouille base, as well as generously portioned tater tots perfect for sharing. Patrons have also praised the Caesar salad, ample enough for two, and a dessert to remember—the Sodel Lime Pie—featuring a coconut and graham cracker crust layered with lime filling and a delightful mango curd, all drizzled with a strawberry margarita sauce.
The staff, notably praised for their knowledge, personable nature, and attentive service, add an extra layer of enjoyment to the dining experience. Whether it’s Ruby or other members of the team, their professionalism and friendliness create an inviting and welcoming environment for patrons.
Regular visitors to Bethany Beach hold Bluecoast in high regard, making it a staple in their dining experiences. The restaurant’s electric vibe, stellar service, and consistently outstanding food leave an indelible mark, ensuring that every visit is a memorable one. From calamari to trout entrees, complemented by an excellent wine list and expertly crafted cocktails, the restaurant offers an unforgettable dining escapade that keeps guests coming back for more.
Overall, Bluecoast Seafood Grill & Raw Bar emerges as a standout destination for those seeking a remarkable seafood dining adventure in Bethany Beach, offering not just a meal but an experience that tantalizes the senses and leaves a lasting impression of culinary excellence.
Address: 30904 Coastal Hwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Menu: bluecoastseafoodgrill.com
Order: toasttab.com
Phone: +1 302-539-7111

3.Mickey’s Family Crab House – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Mickey’s Family Crab House in Bethany Beach is an unassuming gem cherished by locals and visitors alike for its laid-back atmosphere and consistently delightful seafood offerings. Nestled in a casual setting that exudes a quintessential crab shack vibe, this eatery beckons patrons with its promise of exceptional food and welcoming service.
Mickey's Family Crab House - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Mickey’s Family Crab House – best seafood in Bethany Beach
For starters, the crab dip, though not surpassing a family recipe, holds its own in flavor and sets the stage for the seafood feast to come. The king crab legs steal the spotlight, arriving perfectly cooked and brimming with deliciousness, leaving patrons craving more of their savory taste. Even the Maryland crab soup, while not meeting one patron’s exact expectations, impresses with its flavors, earning commendation for its taste and quality.
Visitors staying at Hotel Bethany Beach, conveniently located nearby, find Mickey’s to be a satisfying dining option. The restaurant’s specials showcase the kitchen’s prowess, complemented by the friendly and courteous staff who contribute to a comfortable and welcoming dining experience.
Seating options include the inviting bar area, where patrons rave about the attentive bartenders and the continuous flow of drinks that accompany the excellent food choices. Diners delight in a range of offerings beyond traditional seafood fare, such as chicken tenders, clam chowder, Mahi Mahi Ruben, and fish tacos—each dish earning its own accolades for taste and quality.
The allure of the all-you-can-eat blue crabs and oysters at a reasonable price of $48 captivates diners seeking a seafood extravaganza, offering exceptional value for those with time to savor the bounty. Even with the bustling crowds, especially during peak hours, patrons appreciate the worth of this experience and express willingness to return for another round of delectable seafood delights.
While some note the snug table arrangements, this does little to deter the overall positive dining experience. Patrons unanimously express their intent to revisit Mickey’s if given the opportunity, praising the eatery’s value-driven menu, tasty crab cakes, and the promise of a gratifying meal, making it a compelling choice for future visits to the area.
In essence, Mickey’s Family Crab House remains a cherished dining spot in Bethany Beach, celebrated for its inviting ambiance, flavorful seafood offerings, and a commitment to providing a memorable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more, ensuring that each visit is a testament to quality and satisfaction.
Address: 39610 Jefferson Bridge Rd, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Phone: +1 302-539-5384

4.Bethany Blues BBQ Pit – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Bethany Blues BBQ Pit in Bethany Beach beckons patrons with its irresistible blend of mouthwatering dishes and attentive service, crafting an experience that goes beyond the expectations of a traditional barbecue joint. Situated in the heart of a bustling beach town, this establishment effortlessly combines exceptional food with a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Bethany Diner - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Bethany Diner – best seafood in Bethany Beach
During peak dinnertime, the wait of 45 minutes proved worthwhile for many diners, allowing them to explore the charming beach town while anticipating their flavorful meal. The menu, though renowned for its barbecue offerings, surprises and delights with unexpected gems like the brown sugar-coated salmon—a unique yet delightful choice that left diners raving. Accompanied by fresh corn and garlicky mashed potatoes, this unconventional dish exemplifies the restaurant’s ability to create diverse and satisfying options.
Large groups also find solace in the exceptional service provided by the attentive staff, even if the name of a standout server might slip from memory. The crab dip stands out as a must-order, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to quality and flavor. The crab mac skillet impresses with its richness and abundance of crab, earning praise from all corners of the table.
Even those aiming for lighter fare find satisfaction in Bethany Blues BBQ Pit’s offerings. The slider and salad combo, tailored for those seeking healthier options, leaves guests content with its portion size and taste. Meanwhile, the Carolina Cuban, generously sized and bursting with flavor, ensures a delightful dining experience for those with heartier appetites.
Consistency in both food quality and customer service remains a hallmark of this establishment. The attentive servers go the extra mile, providing timely refills and thoughtful gestures, such as offering to-go cups on hot summer days. Cleanliness, a welcoming atmosphere, and an efficient staff round out the dining experience, leaving diners feeling not just satisfied but also appreciated.
Bethany Blues BBQ Pit’s commitment to excellence in both cuisine and customer service continues to draw patrons back for more. Whether craving classic barbecue dishes or yearning for a delightful twist on familiar flavors, this establishment stands as a testament to impeccable food, warm hospitality, and an experience that ensures diners leave with satisfied palates and a desire to return for more of their outstanding fare.
Address: 6 N Pennsylvania Ave, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Reservations: resy.com
Order: toasttab.com
Phone: +1 302-537-1500

5.Cottage Cafe – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Cottage Cafe in Bethany Beach has etched itself as a quintessential dining spot, drawing patrons back year after year with its delectable offerings, warm atmosphere, and commendable service. Situated on the bustling culinary scene of Bethany, this eatery seamlessly blends a casual ambiance with exceptional food, making it a go-to destination for locals and tourists alike.
Cottage Cafe - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Cottage Cafe – best seafood in Bethany Beach
The anticipation for the fried oyster special brings patrons back annually, and Cottage Cafe consistently lives up to the hype. On a Monday night, patrons were promptly seated and warmly greeted by Kim, an attentive server who enhanced the dining experience. The presentation of the meal, including good-sized oysters accompanied by standout sides like creamed spinach and tater tots, garnered praise, showcasing the kitchen’s commitment to both taste and presentation.
While previous attempts to visit Cottage Cafe might have been deterred by crowds, patrons find that timing is key to securing a table without the hassle of long waits. Despite its popularity, the restaurant retains a laid-back, casual atmosphere that complements the sumptuous dishes served.
Diners rave about the menu’s highlights, such as the shrimp appetizer, flavorful crab cakes, and flounder with crab cakes—each dish delivering a burst of coastal flavors. The portions impress, accompanied by delectable sides like fresh French fries and coleslaw, leaving patrons delightfully satisfied. The warm cranberry orange mini muffins add a delightful touch, although the portions are so generous that dessert becomes a challenge due to the delightful fullness experienced after the main course.
Even accommodating larger groups, Cottage Cafe manages to please, offering ample space and efficient service. Micaela, among the attentive staff, adds to the experience with her friendly demeanor and efficiency. The variety on the menu caters to all tastes, ensuring even the youngest diners are delighted with their meal choices.
The overall consensus among patrons is that Cottage Cafe remains a highlight of their beach experience, offering an array of flavorful dishes at reasonable prices, served by a hospitable staff. While reservations might not be an option, the call-ahead list and short waiting times ensure that patrons can savor the culinary delights this establishment has to offer. For those seeking a relaxed yet flavorful dining experience in Bethany Beach, Cottage Cafe comes highly recommended as a must-visit destination.
Address: 33034 Coastal Hwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Menu: cottagecafe.com
Order: toasttab.com
Phone: +1 302-539-8710

6.Off the Hook – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Off the Hook in Bethany Beach is an extraordinary dining haven that leaves a lasting impression on patrons seeking an exceptional culinary adventure. Nestled within a small shopping mall, this unassuming gem stands out for its innovative and diverse menu offerings that promise a unique gastronomic experience.
Off the Hook - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Off the Hook – best seafood in Bethany Beach
The standout among many highlights is the mussels appetizer, an unexpected delight that could easily qualify as a meal in itself. Infused with a tantalizing blend of flavors—mussels, tomatoes, tasso, basil, fennel, all with a touch of spice, served alongside crostini—it’s a journey off the beaten path that never fails to amaze. Patrons are left awestruck by the creativity and the unmatched taste of this unconventional appetizer.
For those seeking a break from routine family-oriented dining, Off the Hook delivers an array of delectable options. Dishes like the flash-fried soft-shell crab and the raved-about scallops leave an indelible mark on diners, offering a departure from the ordinary. However, while the food shines, some patrons note the need for more substantial accompaniments, such as bread, to complement the flavorful oils served for dipping.
The establishment’s brunch service on Father’s Day garners praise for its superior quality and the outstanding service provided by Sandra. While some dishes like the seafood plate with German potato salad may not meet traditional expectations, others like the cinnamon French toast with fresh fruit earn accolades as the very best.
The attentive and knowledgeable staff, exemplified by waitresses like Kelly, elevate the dining experience. Their cheerful demeanor and expertise in guiding patrons through the menu add to the enjoyment. Diners appreciate the generous portion sizes, especially during the half-off specials on certain weekdays, ensuring both value and satisfaction.
Though housed within a modest shopping complex, Off the Hook surprises and delights with its exceptional food quality and service. Patrons consistently express their satisfaction with both the meals and the attentive service, creating an overall positive dining experience.
In conclusion, Off the Hook remains a standout destination in Bethany Beach, offering an innovative menu and attentive service that leave a lasting impression on diners seeking a unique and flavorful culinary escapade off the typical dining path.
Address: 769 Garfield Pkwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Menu: offthehookbethany.com
Order: takeout7.com
Phone: +1 302-829-1424

7.DiFebo’s Restaurant Bethany Beach – best seafood in Bethany Beach

DiFebo’s Restaurant in Bethany Beach stands out as a culinary haven, offering an exquisite dining experience that beautifully blends elegance and down-to-earth charm. Nestled in this beach town, this establishment caters to those seeking exceptional cuisine and attentive service.
DiFebo's Restaurant Bethany Beach - best seafood in Bethany Beach
DiFebo’s Restaurant Bethany Beach – best seafood in Bethany Beach
Arriving early as walk-ins on a Wednesday evening proved fortuitous, allowing for a delightful experience with the experienced and professional wait staff. The meal commenced with starters like Italian Wedding soup and a classic Caesar salad, both earning praise for their quality and taste. Main courses like the pan-seared Mahi Mahi and the bone-in veal chop with fresh pasta and asparagus wowed diners, with the latter even drawing comparisons to Chicago’s finest. The attention to detail in dishes, from the perfectly cooked fish to the tasty accompaniments, impressed patrons, ensuring a memorable dining experience.
The desserts, including tiramisu and ricotta cheese torte, left taste buds in awe, offering a delightful conclusion to an exceptional meal. The live music provided by a solo saxophone musician added to the ambiance, elevating the dining experience to a whole new level.
Patrons appreciate the elegant yet welcoming atmosphere at DiFebo’s, describing it as a perfect blend of sophistication and comfort. The exceptional quality of the food is highlighted, complemented by the generous portion sizes and reasonable pricing. The addition of a shop across the street offering fancy cookies, olive oil, and merchandise adds to the overall charm of the experience, encouraging patrons to extend their connection with the restaurant beyond their meal.
While some patrons mention the smaller portion sizes for takeout orders, the overall consensus remains positive regarding the food quality and the prompt service. Families find the menu diverse and appealing, with dishes like lasagna, Brussels sprouts, calamari, eggplant Parmesan, and more, catering to various tastes and leaving everyone thoroughly satisfied.
In conclusion, DiFebo’s Restaurant in Bethany Beach is a culinary gem that delivers a dining experience worth savoring. Despite higher prices, the exquisite quality of the food, impeccable service, and inviting atmosphere ensure that every visit feels like a special occasion, making it a standout destination for locals and vacationers alike.
Address: 789 Garfield Pkwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Reservations: toasttab.com
Order: doordash.com, toasttab.com
Phone: +1 302-539-4550

8.Fins Ale House and Raw Bar – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Fins Ale House and Raw Bar in Bethany Beach encapsulates the essence of a must-visit dining destination, drawing patrons back time and again with its exceptional cuisine, accommodating service, and inviting atmosphere. Situated ideally for outdoor dining experiences, this establishment manages to leave a lasting impression on its diners, offering an array of delightful dishes and a hospitable environment.
Fins Ale House and Raw Bar - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Fins Ale House and Raw Bar – best seafood in Bethany Beach
For many, a visit to Fins during their Bethany stay is a non-negotiable, with outdoor dining being a preferred choice. Despite visiting on a Saturday sans the usual Happy Hour, patrons still revel in the culinary delights, indulging in delectable offerings like the crab dip, steamed clams, and locally crafted beers. The efficient service and excellent food ensure a promise of return.
Among the standout dishes, the seafood paella earns rave reviews, proclaimed as the absolute best by diners who have sampled this dish elsewhere. The restaurant’s ability to accommodate food allergies with grace, presenting perfectly grilled salmon and flawlessly steamed broccoli, speaks volumes about their attention to detail and commitment to diner satisfaction.
Even during the COVID-19 era, Fins continues to impress with its takeout offerings, ensuring that the deliciousness of their food extends beyond the restaurant’s walls. Patrons attest to the consistent quality of the dishes, with options like seafood pasta and blackened rockfish delighting taste buds at home.
Reservations are recommended, especially for outdoor dining, where spacing between tables ensures a comfortable and safe dining experience. Early dining hours also allow patrons to partake in the delightful Happy Hour options, amplifying the overall dining experience. The attentive and amiable service further enhances the visit, leaving diners content and appreciative of the warm atmosphere.
The convenience of Fins’ location, coupled with its tantalizing menu options and welcoming ambiance, makes it a go-to spot for families and vacationers. The short walk to nearby condos adds to its allure, promising convenience and a satisfying meal experience.
In essence, Fins Ale House and Raw Bar maintains its status as a top choice in Bethany Beach, providing not just excellent food but an all-encompassing dining experience characterized by superb service, diverse menu choices, and an ambiance that encourages patrons to return for more unforgettable dining escapades.
Address: 33544 Market Pl, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Menu: places.singleplatform.com
Order: doordash.com, trycaviar.com, toasttab.com
Phone: +1 302-539-3467

9.Ropewalk Bethany Beach – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Ropewalk Bethany Beach in Bethany Beach sets itself apart as a standout dining spot, dispelling any doubts with its superb food offerings, generous portions, and commendable service. Amidst mixed reviews, our experience turned out to be nothing short of exceptional, proving that this establishment deserves a closer look beyond a few negative comments.
Ropewalk Bethany Beach - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Ropewalk Bethany Beach – best seafood in Bethany Beach
During our visit, the abundance of food and flavors surpassed expectations. The bang bang shrimp bucket was a delightful start, overflowing with perfectly spiced shrimp. The crab egg rolls impressed with their bursting freshness and crisp texture, while the Ahi fish tacos delighted with their generous fish portions and crunchy coleslaw. Dining outside in the sandy area added a fun element to our meal, enhancing the overall experience.
On a bustling New Year’s Eve, Ropewalk didn’t disappoint. Despite previous hesitations due to reviews, the evening unfolded beautifully. Starting with the Korean Cauliflower, Bada Bing Shrimp, and chicken wings, each dish proved excellent in taste and portion size. The main courses, including the pepper-crusted filet, jerk chicken, short ribs, and Murphy’s mac, continued the trend of excellence, showcasing both flavor and quality.
Eric, our server, deserves applause for his top-notch service, ensuring a seamless dining experience with promptness and attentiveness. Even without indulging in desserts, the outstanding quality of the meals hinted at a delightful finish to the dining experience.
The welcoming atmosphere and accommodating service extended to large groups, making celebrations like birthdays enjoyable for all. The play structure for kids provided entertainment, allowing adults to savor their meals without distraction.
The restaurant’s commitment to ample portions, creative drink presentations, and a family-friendly atmosphere stood out among our experiences. With delicious meals, great service, and a range of offerings for both adults and children, Ropewalk Bethany Beach stands as a place worth recommending and revisiting.
In conclusion, our visit to Ropewalk Bethany Beach was a resounding success, demonstrating that sometimes, overlooked establishments offer exceptional dining experiences. Despite occasional negative reviews, our experience highlighted the establishment’s commitment to quality, generous servings, and attentive service, making it a destination worthy of exploration and an assurance of a delightful meal.
Address: 107 Garfield Pkwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Phone: +1 302-537-1330

10.Pomodoro Pizzeria – best seafood in Bethany Beach

Pomodoro Pizzeria in Bethany Beach is a true gem for pizza aficionados, standing out as a carry-out-only establishment that consistently delivers exceptional New York-style pizzas, earning a well-deserved reputation for its quality and flavors.
A glance at the bustling business, evident from the lines and constant phone calls, showcases the high demand for Pomodoro’s offerings. Patrons laud the Pomodoro special pizza, recognizing it as the pinnacle of pizza perfection at the shore. The commendable NY-style crust coupled with delectable toppings underscores the pizza’s excellence, leaving customers eagerly planning their return visits.
Pomodoro Pizzeria - best seafood in Bethany Beach
Pomodoro Pizzeria – best seafood in Bethany Beach
Regular patrons express unwavering loyalty to Pomodoro, making it a must-stop spot whenever they visit Bethany Beach. The praise extends to the chewy yet foldable NY-style crust, the flavorful sauce with a tantalizing bite, and the perfectly pulley mozzarella cheese, all combining to create a pizza experience that’s hard to beat. With an $18 price tag, patrons deem it a reasonable bargain for the quality received, claiming it as their favorite pizza, possibly even surpassing experiences from other locales.
Customers delight in their snack stop at Pomodoro, reveling in slices of plain cheese and Margherita pizzas. The oven-tossed slices brought back to the perfect temperature for an al fresco beachside feast contribute to a memorable dining experience. The praise for the impeccable crust, just-right sauce, and cheese ratio unanimously declares Pomodoro as the best pizza find at the beach in years.
Beyond the stellar pizzas, Pomodoro also receives accolades for its well-curated salads, boasting quality ingredients and flavorful dressings that complement the pizzas perfectly. While the establishment operates on a take-out-only basis, patrons can find tables available in the interior shopping mall nearby, providing an option for those preferring an indoor dining space.
In summary, Pomodoro Pizzeria emerges as a quintessential destination for pizza enthusiasts in Bethany Beach, earning its stripes as the go-to spot for authentic New York-style pizza. With consistently commendable crust, delectable toppings, and a well-deserved recognition as the top pizza place in Delaware, Pomodoro continues to impress patrons, ensuring that every visit is a delightful celebration of great pizza craftsmanship.
Address: 101 Garfield Pkwy, Bethany Beach, DE 19930, United States
Phone: +1 302-537-1359